At incompetent startups with no expertise in security
> found a raw request log, which inevitably contained...
But the existence of the log is not inevitable! Is it so inreasonable to hold Facebook to a professional standard?
> they disclosed the log in a way
They snuck in an amendment to a previously posted press release while the press was in an uproar about the Mueller report!
They handled this in about as clumsy and dishonest a way as possible. Knowing the executive team, I dare say that -is- as good as we can expect.
Not exclusively.
I think that's significant in itself, and at odds with claims the big five make in public and to regulators about the viability of their core business model.
I do not think people can pretend to work in an industry where this isn't a norm, and that Facebook is somehow handling this far worse than everyone else is.
Companies that take security serious wouldn't give access to logs to everyone in the company in the first place.
And a leak doesn't need evidence that it was accessed to be deemed a leak. They were stored in plaintext, potentially accessible by internal employees. That's enough to warrant a password reset. It's not asking for much.
One should only entrust their password to a hashing algorithm.
Access to account credentials for a large social media platform definitely falls into the sensitive & personally-identifying category.
1. Aren't they legally required to under GDPR?
2. Let's not give them too much credit. They updated an old blog post on the day the Mueller investigation report got released.
Yeah, if they get caught. Which they don't have to be.
Also, it isn't clear if there is PD (Personal Data) there--just a password would not be enough to identify a person. If it were in combination to user ID or email, it would be.
Security people see shit like this all the time. Facebook found a raw request log, which inevitably contained lots of passwords. Rather than doing what most tech companies would have done --- delete the log and pretend nothing ever happened --- they disclosed the log in a fashion that guaranteed a whole news cycle about it.
I don't like Facebook. Facebook is bad. But Facebook handled this about as well as I've seen anyone handle this. Cheers to them for that. This story is not a good reason to single Facebook out.