This was core to Apple's argument. Qualcomm was insisting on unreasonable licensing rates for standards essential patents. I don't know who was right or wrong, but that was the position.
More importantly, point me to the clause in the Constitution that says, "unless other people really really want it". If any thing, would restriction of a standard not promote a competitor? For years, h.264 licensing was necessary. Now we have AV1.
Should contracts only be legally binding until you no longer like the terms you have agreed to?
Which 2? If you mean GSM and CDMA, they're effectively dead (yes, I am aware legacy 3G networks are still in use some places). LTE killed them both.
The constitution allows Congress to create a patent system. It doesn't require them to issue patents at all, much less without qualifications.
Moreover, promoting the progress is a trade off. Suppose various entites had two hundred standards essential patents. This is actually less than the number of patents on a device like an iPhone, which follows standards for everything from wireless to USB to TLS. Then if each of the patent holders wanted 1% of the total device price, there wouldn't be iPhones because they'd lose two dollars for every one they made.
In principle that isn't in the interests of the patent holders, because if there are no iPhones then they collect no royalties, but it's basic tragedy of the commons. Every patent holder has a blocking patent, they all want the device to be profitable enough that it's produced, but they also all want the other patent holders to be the one to reduce their percentage in order to make that happen and between coordination problems and brinkmanship it can easily sink the whole endeavor.
Moreover, if entities holding blocking patents could charge whatever they like, then there would be reduced incentive for anyone else to make further progress because the holders of the existing patents continuing to charge their existing rates would automatically capture the new value that should go to the new inventor when the value of the device increases.
So given that "promote the progress" is a trade off, giving Qualcomm a monopoly on the whole world is clearly not a good way to optimize it.
The Constitution patent clause grants Congress the right to "To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries." Would this ruling not, under that clause, be unconstitutional? Qualcomm is making use of its exclusive right. I agree they've got some rather bad business practices, and the FTC could try to get a ruling that they had to only charge for the chip, but I don't understand the way that ruling is worded.
I feel like the media model, the whole "you only buy a license" mess, is leaking into physical stuff. You now must buy not only a chip but a license? Why would a company choose that business model?
To summarize, I feel that it's not the best business practice, but don't understand why Koh ruled as she did and how she could justify the ruling's constitutionality.