News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by GeekyBear on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @07:14PM (#19678147)
Qualcomm's biggest threat to their current level of profitability is that they could be forced to stop seeking a percentage of the retail price of a cellular device directly from the device makers.

Qualcomm's strategy has been to refuse to license their standards essential patents to their cellular modem competitors, and instead go after device makers.

Judge Koh in the Qualcomm vs. FTC antitrust trial has already issued a ruling that Qualcomm may not continue to refuse to license it's standards essential patents to it's competitors.

https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest/ftc-v-qualcomm-standard-...

Apple sought a ruling in this case that once Qualcomm's rival modem makers received a license to Qualcomm's standard essential patents on FRAND terms, Qualcomm's patents would be exhausted, and they could not continue to seek additional fees (a percentage of the retail price of the entire device) from the device maker.

This has a huge effect on profitability because the courts have already shut down Google's attempt to price gouge Microsoft for a percentage of the retail price of Microsoft's XBox over standards essential FRAND encumbered patents back when Google owned Motorola.

>In a closely watched case, a federal judge has determined that Motorola is entitled to millions -- not billions -- of dollars in compensation for Microsoft's use of certain standard-essential patents.

U.S. District Judge James Robart ruled Thursday that Microsoft should pay Google's Motorola Mobility unit $1.8 million a year in royalties for use of wireless and video coding patents it used in the Xbox and its smartphones.

Motorola had demanded Microsoft pay royalties of $4 billion for use of patents that are part of the H.264 video and 802.11 wireless standards, which is baked into Windows and the Xbox video game console. Microsoft was willing to pay a royalty, but not at the 2.25 percent of the product price that Motorola has sought.

https://www.cnet.com/news/court-sides-with-microsoft-over-mo...

Given the percentage of Qualcomm's bottom line that comes in as licensing fees, getting paid a FRAND appropriate licensing fee set by the courts instead of a percentage of the retail price of the whole device would have been absolutely disastrous for Qualcomm's bottom line.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by tooltalk on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @08:01AM (#19681748)
It's a bit more nuanced than that.

Under ETSI, where most of QCOM's SEPs (standard essential patents) are declared, licensing SEPs only to end-device makers is consistent with FRAND terms. It's essentially a contract law under French law. While there aren't too many case laws to precise define what is deemed FRAND, in Dec 2018, judge Gilstrap ruled in support of end-device licensing scheme in HTC vs Ericsson ("District Court Holds That FRAND Commitment Does Not Require Licensing at Chip Level").

Another thing to consider is that most SSO's (standard setting organizations, eg, ETSI) usually don't set out precise terms of licensing rates or basis, in part their fear of breaking local antitrust laws*. Instead, ETSI allows reliance on existing industry common practices and the courts have used "comparative analysis" (ie, licensing practices by similarly situated SEP holders) to determine what is "fair," "reasonable," and "non-discriminatory." So for instance, in Microsoft vs Moto, Moto's patents weren't as large in number or significant in contribution to justify Moto's demand, in addition to being completely out of whack with the common licensing practices embraced by the industry. By contrast, it's widely accepted that Qualcomm is a significant contributor to various wireless standards and holds large seminal/essential SEPs -- QCOM's case is nothing like Motorola's. Further, in the wireless business, it's a common industry practice for SEP holders to collect royalties at the end of the supply chain, ie end-device makers, for simplicity and maximum monetization; and this custom has been embraced and practiced for the past two decades.

In a pre-trial decision last November, however, Apple's hometown judge Lucy Koh, sided with the FTC that under ATIS/TIA FRAND obligation (yes, there are competing SSOs with overlapping FRAND terms apparently). I'm not entirely sure why Koh's novel decision has precedence over ETSI FRAND where QCOM's SEPs are actually declared, but I'm pretty sure it would be appealed and reversed in next year or two.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @12:30PM (#19684032)
> Further, in the wireless business, it's a common industry practice for SEP holders to collect royalties at the end of the supply chain, ie end-device makers, for simplicity and maximum monetization; and this custom has been embraced and practiced for the past two decades.

That seems like a weak argument given how slowly courts and regulators move on things like this. By the time they get around to telling you to stop doing something you're already claiming that it's an established practice.

And there is no simplicity there because there are more end device makers than chip makers, so "maximum monetization" is precisely the issue -- they're claiming more than they brought to the table using a manifestly unreasonable practice.

Surely Qualcomm is not entitled to the same percentage of a $1M house that a wireless router is installed in as they are of the $100 wireless router to begin with, or the same percentage of a $100M commercial jetliner when it has in-flight wireless. They are not responsible for any of the difference in value between a $100K house and a $1M house, what reasonably entitles them to a percentage of the difference?

If one iPhone is worth $300 more than another because it has a bigger screen and faster processor but the exact same wireless capability, why should Qualcomm receive any of the additional money?

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by tooltalk on Thursday April 18, 2019 @05:49AM (#19689858)
> ... how slowly courts and regulators move on things like this. By the time they get around to telling you to stop doing something you're already claiming that it's an established practice.

Not really. We are talking about industry practices that have been around for two or three decades now and precede the development of various wireless standards created by the SSOs.

> And there is no simplicity there because there are more end device makers than chip makers, so "maximum monetization" is precisely the issue -- they're claiming more than they brought to the table using a manifestly unreasonable

That's not true. We are not talking about at the baseband level, but there are also many others who operate at different level (ie, Skyworks) which complicates the licensing. If we are to follow SSPPU, SEP holders would have to go after everyone from end device makers (Apple), to baseband chips (Qualcomm), to power management chips used in baseband chips (Qorvo), to etc... as QCOM's patent portfolio covers many different areas of wireless communication. The end-user device is one single aggregation point that embodies all patented features and where royalty collection is simpler.

> Surely Qualcomm is not entitled to the same percentage of a $1M house that a wireless router is installed in as they are of the $100 wireless router to begin with, ...

Sure, if QCOM can demonstrate that QCOM's patented features are a) an integral part of the $1M home, b) add significant value and c) drive market demand for that $1M house, yes. In another word, if QCOM's $100 wireless modems is an essential part of the 1M house, significantly enhances the market value (eg, $1M with $100 modem, $300K without it), and attracts home buyers, that's very legit. QC's $100 wireless router in a $1M house or a $100M jetliner however wouldn't pass this test in reality -- no sane buyers would pay such premium for features that are not essential in aviation or housing business. But can you say the same for wireless mobile devices?

> If one iPhone is worth $300 more than another because it has a bigger screen and faster processor but the exact same wireless capability, why should Qualcomm receive any of the additional money?

Yep, Apple's iPod Touch is almost at feature parity with the iPhone, but without QCOM's patented features. The Touch sells significantly fewer units despite its significantly lower price (even lower than that older iPhones with LCD and low capacity memory/storage). In this case, QCOM can argue that their $30 modem + wireless patents are integral part of the wireless mobile product, add significant value and drive market demand for their iPhones, that most consumers wouldn't otherwise buy at that price point.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 18, 2019 @01:10PM (#19692752)
> We are talking about industry practices that have been around for two or three decades now and precede the development of various wireless standards created by the SSOs.

That's an eternity in tech years but barely overnight in court years. An individual court case can take a decade to come before the Supreme Court, and first that case needs to make it into court to begin with and then not be settled (as the vast majority are) before the court has the opportunity to set a precedent.

And Congress typically doesn't get involved until after the courts have done something sufficiently problematic.

> We are not talking about at the baseband level, but there are also many others who operate at different level (ie, Skyworks) which complicates the licensing. If we are to follow SSPPU, SEP holders would have to go after everyone from end device makers (Apple), to baseband chips (Qualcomm), to power management chips used in baseband chips (Qorvo), to etc... as QCOM's patent portfolio covers many different areas of wireless communication. The end-user device is one single aggregation point that embodies all patented features and where royalty collection is simpler.

Isn't the baseband chip the SSPPU in all of those cases? How is that not the single aggregation point?

> Sure, if QCOM can demonstrate that QCOM's patented features are...

The point is that they can't. Otherwise why do two devices with the exact same wireless capability, even the exact same wireless baseband chip, have significantly different prices?

> Yep, Apple's iPod Touch is almost at feature parity with the iPhone, but without QCOM's patented features.

Not just without Qualcomm's patent features, without the entire wireless standard that they cover. The whole point of treating standards essential patents specially is that compatibility with the standard is worth significantly more than the contribution of any individual company's patents, because it's a holdup for the ability to implement the standard and communicate with the cellular network.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by tooltalk on Friday April 19, 2019 @02:23PM (#19701751)
>That's an eternity in tech years but barely overnight in court years.

That sounds like a lot of nonsense. No, it isn't the lack of time or convoluted legal process hindering the industry or discovery of such licensing violation. Companies like Apple, TCL challenged the wireless industry, but lacking evidence or substance to back up their argument, Apple usually settled at the last minute (take for example, Apple's lawsuit against Nokia in 2008, 2016). When there was a realm full case (Samsung vs Apple, USITC 337-TA-794), it found Apple's abuse of FRAND obligation by reverse hold-up, and Apple subsequently lost all of its claims on Samsung's FRAND violation (even Apple's own ETSI FRAND experts came out testifying against Apple).

> Isn't the baseband chip the SSPPU in all of those cases? How is that not the single aggregation point?

No, there are other components, according to Qualcomm, that are not embedded in the baseband, such as security framework.

> The point is that they can't. Otherwise why do two devices with the exact same wireless capability, even the exact same wireless baseband chip, have significantly different prices?

If your gripe is your inability to understand what a percentage-based licensing model is (vs per unit price, vs exclusionary, vs lump-sum models), I can't help you there. I already explained to you why the wireless industry's licensing is fair and gave you various legal analysis/factors courts consider to determine fair, or at least to weed out extortionate, licensing schemes in patent cases. In your hypothetical $1M house, I clarified that the patents wireless features don't add any value or create market demand for $1M house, so that's a no-go. However, for mobile devices like Apple iPhone, the wireless SEPs are not only intrinsic part of the product, but also significantly increase the market value (by 100%-200% in comparison to the iPod Touch) and creates market demand that wouldn't otherwise exist . Some, eg, TCL vs Ericsson, like judge Selna ruled and estimates that 10% of wholesale end-user device is an appropriate aggregated FRAND rate for the whole 4G stack; while China's NDRC believes domestic Chinese companies deserve some more discount (about 50% of whatever everyone else deems fair; or 5% of end-user device).

> ... The whole point of treating standards essential patents specially is that compatibility with the standard is worth significantly more than the contribution of any individual company's patents, because it's a holdup for the ability to implement the standard and communicate with the cellular network.

Sure, and these goals of wireless standards don't preclude SEP holders from profiting from their invention. FRAND commitment doesn't mean charity. FRAND obligation and wireless standards don't exist solely to serve device-makers's interest and to increase their bottom-line. The industry licensing model as it currently stands enables SEP holders to partake in end-user makers sales while lowering the licensing burden by new low-cost mobile device makers. They achieve all that in addition to promoting wide industry adoption, inter-operability of their technical standards.

You could theorize potential abuses of hold-up, royalty stacking, etc all you want -- I have yet to hear any actual "hold-up" by wireless SEP holders, but there is at least one known case of "reverse hold-up" by a rogue unwilling device maker, Apple.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by mises on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @08:13PM (#19678512)
I'm not sure I understand the rationale behind Koh's ruling. Why ought a firm be forced to license IP?

The Constitution patent clause grants Congress the right to "To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries." Would this ruling not, under that clause, be unconstitutional? Qualcomm is making use of its exclusive right. I agree they've got some rather bad business practices, and the FTC could try to get a ruling that they had to only charge for the chip, but I don't understand the way that ruling is worded.

I feel like the media model, the whole "you only buy a license" mess, is leaking into physical stuff. You now must buy not only a chip but a license? Why would a company choose that business model?

To summarize, I feel that it's not the best business practice, but don't understand why Koh ruled as she did and how she could justify the ruling's constitutionality.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by dev_tty01 on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @09:51PM (#19678992)
It is the law around "standard" essential patents. Company X develops technology and then works the standards process to make their technology the standard. Now anyone who wants to use the standard must license the technology from company X. Phones only work if everyone uses a published standard. In order to have something approved as the standard, company X has to agree beforehand that they will license the tech to everyone at reasonable rates.

This was core to Apple's argument. Qualcomm was insisting on unreasonable licensing rates for standards essential patents. I don't know who was right or wrong, but that was the position.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by mises on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @10:04PM (#19679065)
They made it a standard. GSM branched off years ago for this exact reason. Phones currently work with two different ones.

More importantly, point me to the clause in the Constitution that says, "unless other people really really want it". If any thing, would restriction of a standard not promote a competitor? For years, h.264 licensing was necessary. Now we have AV1.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by GeekyBear on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @12:33AM (#19679775)
As part of the standards setting process, Qualcomm voluntarily entered into a binding legal agreement to license those patents that are necessary to implement the standard to any competitor who wanted a license, and to license them under FRAND (Fair, Reasonsble And Non Discriminatory) terms.

Should contracts only be legally binding until you no longer like the terms you have agreed to?

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by abfan1127 on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @03:29AM (#19680521)
Apple entered into a contract until it didn't like the terms, then just quit paying...
Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by ac29 on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @01:06AM (#19679903)
> They made it a standard. Phones currently work with two different ones.

Which 2? If you mean GSM and CDMA, they're effectively dead (yes, I am aware legacy 3G networks are still in use some places). LTE killed them both.

Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by dodobirdlord on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @12:57AM (#19679871)
The patent clause is a pretty vague and open ended statement, and is clear that (a) it's giving Congress the ability to regulate something (b) to promote the common interest. Common standards are useful, so Congress has chosen to create patent regulation that prohibits refusing to license certain essential patents to your competitors.
Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by wbl on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @08:33PM (#19678601)
Because they signed agreements as parts of the standards process to do so.
Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by jxdxbx on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @10:20PM (#19679169)
right. and SEPs only have value because they are included in a standard. not all of the Q patents at issue are technically SEPs though. That said, just because you have a patent, doesn’t mean you can behave anticompetitively around licensing it. it’s your car but you can’t run over pedestrians.
Re:Qualcomm and Apple agree to drop all litigation by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @11:59AM (#19683715)
> The Constitution patent clause grants Congress the right to "To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries." Would this ruling not, under that clause, be unconstitutional?

The constitution allows Congress to create a patent system. It doesn't require them to issue patents at all, much less without qualifications.

Moreover, promoting the progress is a trade off. Suppose various entites had two hundred standards essential patents. This is actually less than the number of patents on a device like an iPhone, which follows standards for everything from wireless to USB to TLS. Then if each of the patent holders wanted 1% of the total device price, there wouldn't be iPhones because they'd lose two dollars for every one they made.

In principle that isn't in the interests of the patent holders, because if there are no iPhones then they collect no royalties, but it's basic tragedy of the commons. Every patent holder has a blocking patent, they all want the device to be profitable enough that it's produced, but they also all want the other patent holders to be the one to reduce their percentage in order to make that happen and between coordination problems and brinkmanship it can easily sink the whole endeavor.

Moreover, if entities holding blocking patents could charge whatever they like, then there would be reduced incentive for anyone else to make further progress because the holders of the existing patents continuing to charge their existing rates would automatically capture the new value that should go to the new inventor when the value of the device increases.

So given that "promote the progress" is a trade off, giving Qualcomm a monopoly on the whole world is clearly not a good way to optimize it.