News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comcast, Level3 and You by wmf on Friday December 03, 2010 @05:23PM (#1967681)
I see it more as "If Comcast doesn't connect these ports to us, we're just going to have to send the traffic either through our existing congested ports or Tata's congested ports, which is worse for everyone". It's really not clear to me what the right solution to this is.
Re:Comcast, Level3 and You by tptacek on Friday December 03, 2010 @05:28PM (#1967691)
That's absolutely true, but what if, at the end of the day: L3 walked up to Comcast and said, "please give us 20+ additional ports for free", and what everyone is up in arms about is that Comcast said "no, not for free we won't". They're Comcast's ports!
Re:Comcast, Level3 and You by wmf on Friday December 03, 2010 @05:30PM (#1967699)
Perhaps Level 3 should have let the existing ports congest and waited for Comcast to ask for more capacity. It seems like Level 3 is being penalized for trying to proactively expand bandwidth capacity to meet anticipated demand.
Re:Comcast, Level3 and You by tptacek on Friday December 03, 2010 @05:55PM (#1967769)
Pretty much. Where does the logic here end? Which companies have the prerogative to come up to Comcast and ask for free ports? ISPs? What about ISPs that are acting as agents for individual companies? If that's fine, why not cut out the middleman? Can the next super-popular video site just ask Comcast for ports directly?

I have no opinion about this stuff, I just think it's really interesting.