News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trading bots are running wild on cryptocurrency exchanges by tptacek on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @01:40PM (#19675634)
They aren't "preconceptions". A preconception about the book would be if they hadn't read it, weren't familiar with it, and had opinions about it anyways. Flash Boys is a bad book. I'd argue that your desire to immunize the book, which is largely unrelated to your paper, from criticism is harming the case you're trying to make about distsys flaws in DEX's.

The paper is good! The surrounding context you're trying to provide about how real-money markets work, perhaps not so much.

Re:Trading bots are running wild on cryptocurrency exchanges by phildaian on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @04:15PM (#19676910)
I'm not saying he has preconceptions about the book, I'm saying his opinion of the book is creating unwarranted preconceptions about our work.

The paper doesn't comment on money markets much at all, and cites pretty unambiguous peer reviewed work which is highly substantiated when it does.

Re:Trading bots are running wild on cryptocurrency exchanges by tptacek on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @06:19PM (#19677851)
Sorry, I was confused because you referred to his "preconceptions of Flash Boys as a bad book", and also talked at some length about how industry insiders don't like the book on Twitter, and also alluded to practices described by Flash Boys that insiders want to hide upthread.