News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by penagwin on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @11:43AM (#19674625)
That's all correct, the higher frequency suffers from worse object penetration. Solutions I've heard was that 5G would likely involve neighborhood or even building repeaters.

IMO 5G is massively overhyped. My iPhone 7+ isn't limited by 4G LTE, it's limited by Verizon deciding to only allow it 10mbps down (with great signal). 5G won't matter one bit if the current bottleneck isn't 4G LTE in the first place.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by SkyPuncher on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @11:53AM (#19674722)
> My iPhone 7+ isn't limited by 4G LTE, it's limited by Verizon deciding to only allow it 10mbps down (with great signal)

This is in fact a limitation of 4G.

A single device is fine, but there is only so much bandwidth available. When you get lots of devices in the same area, something has to be limited.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by dzhiurgis on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @05:21PM (#19677441)
That seems to be american thing. Most countries I’ve lived easily get 100mbps.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by AnssiH on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @10:55PM (#19679365)
Yeah, in especially good conditions you can get over 800Mbps on a Galaxy S10 over here (e.g. https://bbs.io-tech.fi/threads/nettiliittymaesi-taemaenhetki...), and over 100Mbps is normal.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by rocqua on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:29PM (#19676545)
Smaller cells allow for fewer devices per tower, does it not?
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by tedunangst on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @05:52PM (#19677676)
Unfortunately, the density of people who don't want towers "too close to me" means we need bigger towers farther apart.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by rocqua on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @03:53AM (#19680615)
Smaller cells require lower signal power to prevent nearby cells from interfering.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by mikeash on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @11:52AM (#19674710)
Cell capacity is a shared resource. The reason (or part of it) that Verizon limits your speed is to let others use it too. 5G brings smaller cells and more capacity in each cell, which means less need to throttle.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by dragontamer on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:56PM (#19675278)
Not just cell capacity, but phone capacity in general.

One of my biggest memories of 9/11 as a school-boy was when all phone-lines were so congested that no one could call their parents. We all kept trying, but it was "busy" tones all the way through.

That's the only time I remember land-lines all being too congested to make a call, but it was part of the event that a lot of us talked about for days later. Some of the kids were trying to call their parents to see if they were still alive, because some of them worked at the Pentagon. (Their parents were fine, but they too couldn't contact their kids because all the phone-networks were too congested. I presume everyone was trying to call each other at that time).

Its the only time in my memory where I got a busy-signal from picking up a phone. You didn't even dial yet, it was too busy to even give a dial tone.

For the kids out there: texting wasn't common yet, and pagers weren't really worth the trouble. Pagers worked like text messaging today, except you didn't have a screen... so it was hard to use and weren't really used very much. You called a pager using a land-line, and then dialed "44 33 555 555 666" for "HELLO". People generally still just did phone calls for simple messages like "I'm okay".

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by ummonk on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @11:59AM (#19674787)
They'd have to upgrade the backhaul too though to take advantage of 5G capacity.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by PeterisP on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:06PM (#19676363)
Backhaul generally isn't the bottleneck - you have fiber to the towers, and you can bump the capacity of that with comparably cheap hardware upgrades - however, the available "air bandwidth" per cell is pretty much a hard limit, and to go beyond that you need to build more cells which either requires more frequencies or more towers, which both are very expensive and time consuming.

Perhaps it's different in USA, though, the geography and population density differences mean that the backhaul problems are different than in Europe; but here the bottleneck is on the radio side.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by module0000 on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:27PM (#19675020)
>> They'd have to upgrade the backhaul too though to take advantage of 5G capacity.

THIS!!! Even if more sites are added, each with their own 10/100gb fiber run - it's still running to the main circuit for a region. That circuit isn't changing(in the near term), this will just consume more of it. Regions without colossal backbone access that are already bandwidth constrained will remain bandwidth constrained.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by topranks on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @06:09PM (#19677799)
What, pray tell, is the “main circuit for a region?”

Network bandwidth is still going up and up in speed. 100G was very expensive and hard to do only a few years back, now it’s becoming standard. DWDM systems continue to evolve.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by mikeash on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:04PM (#19674839)
I’m sure they would. For all the faults of telecoms companies, they generally don’t like spending a massive amount of money on upgrades that do nothing.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by JohnFen on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @01:21PM (#19675476)
Being able to charge customers more for their service would absolutely count as "doing something".
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by udwum on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:12PM (#19674889)
It does something, it makes your mobile say 5G on the top. That's worth paying more money for some people.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by baddox on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:33PM (#19675067)
But that can be (and has been!) done with a phone software update, which is much cheaper.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by udwum on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @01:01PM (#19675313)
Depends on how expensive the settlement will be. :)
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by penagwin on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:20PM (#19674941)
They love to when customers pay for it! ;)

They spend massive amounts of money on marketing, at that doesn't benefit the product at all.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by isoprophlex on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @01:35PM (#19675599)
> building repeaters

so... sorta like a WiFi access point?

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by ip26 on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:27PM (#19676532)
Yeah, my thought exactly. People like to talk about how 5G will eliminate the need for wired internet because there will be 5G stations on every block, even on every building! I don't know if they simply assume it will be wirelessly repeated or they just haven't really thought about it too hard.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by rocqua on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:37PM (#19676609)
The main value of 5G as opposed to WiFi is that it comes with an entire system for roaming over different networks.

WiFi has no built-in system for authentication across different operators, no system for accounting usage, no system for ensuring trust.

This is what 3gpp brings. Their systems are hopelessly convoluted, and have some issues. However, it works.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by darkpuma on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @03:33PM (#19676577)
> "building repeaters"

In other words glorified wifi, except the AP is no longer owned or controlled by me.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by opencl on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:08PM (#19674867)
Is Verizon really that bad? I usually get around 100mbps on TMobile LTE.
Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by penagwin on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @12:25PM (#19674989)
That's with their rate limiting to fast.com (Netflix).

Speedtest.net (with Verizon hosted servers) was at a very consistent 50mbps/4.5mbps which would make sense for my unlimited plan.

Please note that speedtest.net is REALLY not a good representation of real world network usage, and I don't just mean like how they throttle netflix. They get to host the server in-network as well as full traffic shaping to get those juicy benchmark numbers.

Re:5G Is Likely to Put Weather Forecasting at Risk by tjoff on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @12:45AM (#19679822)
Well, seems like exactly the test you would want if you are testing the 4G network or your phone.

Lack of competition and sensible operators isn't 4Gs fault...