Re:Icons: Avoid temptation and start with user needs
by barbecue_sauce on Sunday April 14, 2019 @09:57PM
(#19662764)
As a player, having the same iconography in each game sounds terrible and would result in an almost clinical experience.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Icons: Avoid temptation and start with user needs
by atoav on Monday April 15, 2019 @12:33AM
(#19663137)
This is because software in contrast to games is usually meant to get shit done with the least possible friction.
While experimentation will always have a driving force, standardization allows a program to lower the barrier of usage to everyone. Especially to those who are not a typical HN user but rather like your stereotypical parents.
Games are not about getting stuff done, so people enjoy learning how it works, which in its own way reduces friction.
Re:Icons: Avoid temptation and start with user needs
by Groxx on Monday April 15, 2019 @01:10AM
(#19663230)
Also as a player: I'd love more consistency. Especially on mobile - the impossibly vast array of same-but-different is wearying, not interesting.
Re:Icons: Avoid temptation and start with user needs
by kurtisc on Monday April 15, 2019 @04:52AM
(#19664024)
You're right but I've always thought it's a bit sad how many hours must be spent recreating the same similar assets - concrete, grass, clothes, etc. - just so people don't have this clinical moment where they recognise something from another game.