News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by unityByFreedom on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:02AM (#19651495)
What would be my incentive for fixing something if I earn no money from it?

From big companies to the lone worker, if IP is not a thing, I don't see how we can evolve technology.

I agree with the idea of not patenting software, since that is already covered by copyright, and patents were never intended to cover algorithms, however, discarding IP altogether seems like throwing the baby out with the bathwater.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by sarcasmOrTears on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:12AM (#19651511)
Even if something is allowed to be done by everybody it doesn't mean it can be done by everybody. Just look at programming. Lack of ip(patents) shifts the power from those with patents+lawyers to those with skills (workers). Innovators, even when they are a group, are always okay because they have the skills to perform.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by est31 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:19AM (#19651538)
Copyright had been created in the first place so that people with printing presses couldn't just copy popular stuff to get a chunk of the market for some work without compensating the creator.

Lack of IP doesn't shift the power to innovators, it shifts it to the people with printing presses, with large manufacturing plants that can scale, apple music, etc etc.

IP is the very basis for compensation of innovators.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by Drakim on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:53AM (#19651662)
The issue is that the reach of IP is so incredibly wide.

It makes sense that if you make a comic book about a superhero named Jumpman, printing presses shouldn't be able to just 1:1 copy your product and sell it. They also shoudln't be able to use your Jumpman character in their own works.

But we have moved so far that you can copyright generic things like the very concept of a comic book. Or having a HTML image that's also a link. Or having round corners on a mobile device.

The only reason we have anything public at all is because most of these inventions happened before the dawn of oppressive IP laws.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by dragonwriter on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:07AM (#19651706)
> But we have moved so far that you can copyright generic things like the very concept of a comic book. Or having a HTML image that's also a link. Or having round corners on a mobile device.

You can't, in fact, copyright any of those things. Were they novel, the first two might be the kind of thing to qualify for utility patents, and the last is presumably a loose description of an actual Apple design patent.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by est31 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:58AM (#19652037)
> The issue is that the reach of IP is so incredibly wide.

I fully agree. Software patents for example should be abolished, and we should get shorter terms on copyright (20 years after death of creator or 80 years after publication, whatever comes sooner would be a good choice). But the very basic concept of copyright and patent law is still good for the individual creators as well as the commons. Abolishing it does not benefit the creators in general, and only shifts power away from them.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by chongli on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:53AM (#19652444)
Copyright had been created in the first place so that people with printing presses couldn't just copy popular stuff to get a chunk of the market for some work without compensating the creator.

Not true. Copyright originally existed to give governments control over owners of presses in an effort to stop printing of dissenting material. It had nothing to do with compensation for authors.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ionised on Monday April 15, 2019 @05:59AM (#19664235)
And in that sense, the purpose of copyright has never changed. It is still used to decide who gets access to what information, with all the complicated licensing arrangements and insane life of author plus 70 years terms.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by hrktb on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:32AM (#19652143)
Not disagreeing, but hasn’t the power shifted to people with printing presses either way ?

I mean that producers are now strongly bound to distributors, and companies like Disney basically own everything from top to mostly bottom (they’re getting there with their streaming service).

In today’s world I don’t see “little guys” getting practical benefits by virtue of IP. Is there still a baby in the bath water?

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by pbhjpbhj on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:42AM (#19652182)
Yes, as you intimate the forerunner to the Statue of Anne, the Licensing of the Press Act, was concerned with restricting who was allowed to own the means to print, and what was allowed to be printed.

But I don't think copyright amendments have been about protecting creators, or the public domain, for some time.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by est31 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:14AM (#19651520)
Yeah, both extremes "all IP is bad" and "we must patent every product even if it brings nothing new to the table" are wrong. The devil is, as in so many cases, in the detail.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:42AM (#19652399)
True, some companies use it to troll.

But this case is exactly the reason why it should exist.

Yes, it should get tweaked a little bit though

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by kartickv on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:57AM (#19652461)
> What would be my incentive for fixing something if I earn no money from it?

Your incentive would be that your product is better and sells more, unless and until everyone copies it. As long as the extra profit exceeds the cost invested, it's worth it.

You're claiming there would be no innovation at all unless there's IP.

How did we innovate for hundreds or thousands of years before IP laws, whether the wheel, ironmaking or any other technology?

To flip your question on its head, if IP laws prevent your innovation from reaching everyone, the benefit to society from this innovation is reduced, and that's bad.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by dgudkov on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:19AM (#19652570)
>Your incentive would be that your product is better and sells more

I'm curious if you ever tried to sell anything in large volumes. You can invent a brilliant thing but still have hard times selling it because of a lack of resources for marketing and a lack of established sales channels. At the same time, big resourceful corporations just steal you invention and resell it to existing customer base, use huge marketing resources, benefit from brand awareness, etc.

Inventing something better doesn't automatically guarantee you a solid revenue stream. Monetizing good inventions for a small company is a way less trivial task than it might seem.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by kartickv on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:42PM (#19657249)
I do have experience with how hard marketing is, but big companies copying small companies' work is not the only application of IP laws. Big companies can copy other big companies' work, and small companies can copy big companies' work. Besides, many small guys — independent developers, three-person teams — don't even have the resources to patent their stuff. Which means patent laws disproportionately benefit big companies.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by unityByFreedom on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:29AM (#19657908)
> Besides, many small guys — independent developers, three-person teams — don't even have the resources to patent their stuff. Which means patent laws disproportionately benefit big companies.

Are you talking about software patents?

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by kartickv on Monday April 15, 2019 @01:43AM (#19663330)
Yes.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by unityByFreedom on Tuesday April 16, 2019 @06:18AM (#19672404)
That's already protected by copyright. I do not support software patents.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by kartickv on Wednesday April 17, 2019 @06:55AM (#19681412)
Sorry for not reading your original post carefully till now. However, I think my point still stands: if you have a product that people are paying you money for, say a camera, and you improve it, your product is more useful, and so you can charge more. Or sell more units at the same price. A camera that can record a timelapse is more useful than one that can't, whether or not other cameras record timelapses. In a world without copyright, the cost of improving your product also reduces, because you can take the code from somewhere, so it needn't sell that many extra units to recoup the lower cost.

In this way, eliminating copyright will create a race to the top, making all products better.