News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by dmlorenzetti on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:06AM (#1964834)
The author calls out med students for approaching physics through rote memorization. It reminds me of an experience my older brother and I had with a doctor friend.

Our friend, an OB/GYN, mentioned how hard her work is, because "the average baby is born at 3am."

We laughed, but then my brother asked, "What does 'average' mean when you have a 24-hour clock? It must mean the modal time or something like that."

I contributed that this is an issue in defining average wind directions, as well. The basic problem is that if you record times on a 0-24 hour scale, or wind directions on a 0-360 degree scale, and then naively average the numbers, you get meaningless results (for example, 180 degrees if the wind steadily rotates through every point of the compass).

A quick glance at our doctor friend showed she had checked out of the conversation entirely. Possibly she just felt slighted that we were not bowing down in awe at the terrible hours she keeps. But my main impression was that she lives in a world where one receives a piece of information, notes it, and stores it away. And when repeating that received information, one's listeners duly note and store it away.

Chasing down the source of the information, calling it into question, relating it to other things in the world-- these just weren't things she seemed to find pleasurable.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by jacobolus on Friday December 03, 2010 @02:34AM (#1965112)
It’s actually quite possible to define quantities like mean and variance on a circular dimension like hours or angles, with definitions analogous to the conventional ones on the reals; it just takes a bit of mathematical cleverness. (The general field is sometimes called “circular statistics”, and for the mean specifically, Wikipedia has an article here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mean_of_circular_quantities)

That the two of you ignored your friend’s point and started talking about mathematics instead could be insulting† and she was may have been quite justifiably annoyed. Interpreting that annoyance as evidence that doctors are uncritical/uncurious/uncreative is pretty narrow-minded, IMO.§

† depending on your existing relationship and usual interactions.

§ obviously I wasn’t there and don’t know your friend, so can’t really judge. YMMV

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by jfager on Friday December 03, 2010 @01:43AM (#1965015)
Or she knew that the term "average" can just as validly refer to the mode as the mean, and was bored by the whole exercise.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by nandemo on Friday December 03, 2010 @06:08AM (#1965420)
I believe a sizeable proportion of HN users would benefit from reading these two articles by Philip Guo. I know I did.

Geek behaviors present during conversations

http://www.stanford.edu/~pgbovine/geek-behaviors.htm

Social tips for geeks

http://www.stanford.edu/~pgbovine/social-tips-for-geeks.htm

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by dpritchett on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:01AM (#1966285)
I like the intention of the second one but it felt too prescriptive for my purposes. I've had decent success trying to learn to better empathize genuinely.

Practice with public speaking and corporate politics and influencing are doing a lot to help me better understand how to befriend and relate to people that don't share my interests. It was initially surprising for me to be one of the geekier people in a building that is ostensibly full of IT workers.

Things that work for me: Toastmasters, Dale Carnegie books, Rands in Repose (blog and/or books), regional sports blogs.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by dmlorenzetti on Friday December 03, 2010 @09:45AM (#1965950)
Correct. I could have written "bored by the whole exercise" rather than saying she had "checked out of the conversation".

To recap-- my brother said, literally, one sentence. I added one more sentence, relating the question to another field of study. Our friend was instantly, irremediably, and unabashedly bored.

From which I concluded that she took little pleasure in exploring any aspect of the statement she herself had introduced.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by variety on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:09PM (#1966600)
That she was "bored" by the exercise doesn't necessarily mean that she doesn't share you and your brother's bold, hard-driving, searingly intense curiosity about the world, and the nature of our ability to infer knowledge about it.

It might, instead, have had something do with the fact that the point you guys were trying to make was rather trivial.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by antareus on Friday December 03, 2010 @04:24PM (#1967485)
Exactly. Nobody cares if the exact details aren't 100% correct in a non-technical discussion. Suppose I begin recounting a blog entry which describes an odd situation. I may not remember all the details right, but I certainly have the gist of it and can convey that. There is no point in someone stepping in and saying, "you know, it was actually in Des Moines, not Dallas," if the city is entirely irrelevant to actual content of the post.

What is the group supposed to do with that statement? Someone has to segue back to the original topic, while someone else just lost face. Most people will just either ignore the correction entirely, or just drop the topic altogether.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by MaMa on Friday December 03, 2010 @03:01PM (#1967248)
Or that disecting a joke ruins it?
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by carbocation on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:35AM (#1964894)
The charitable interpretation (for your OB friend) is that she was not speaking literally, and got bored when you started perseverating on her hyperbole. The more likely explanation is that your analysis is indeed correct.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by mbreese on Friday December 03, 2010 @01:02AM (#1964935)
I'd say the more likely case is that she wasn't speaking literally. Doctors are usually trying to explain things to people who aren't going to know what modal means. Couple that with the fact that most doctors know just enough statistics to get by, and "the most common time for a baby to be born is 3am" gets translated to "the average baby is born at 3am".

The bored look was probably just her rolling her eyes.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by roel_v on Friday December 03, 2010 @05:33AM (#1965365)
"Doctors are usually trying to explain things to people who aren't going to know what modal means."

I talk to doctors quite often lately, with a daughter on the way and all, and the first few times I felt a bit miffed at what I took for her talking down to us. When it got to an absurd level with some nurses (who explained things like how to add several numbers by lining them up, putting a line underneath with a plus sign next to it, and then using a calculator to find the result (true story)), I thought about it some more and it must be because they need to target the lowest common denominator. Which I guess is someone with an iq of 85 or so, as people lower would get special counseling I think.

I've tried to find effective methods to communicate to people that they can skip some of the 'duh' parts, but that's not easy. Just saying 'listen I'm no dumb' or even worse, 'hi I'm <name> and I'm a <name profession that requires university degree>' makes you look arrogant and will antagonize people, and they might not dumb it down on purpose anyway, so they might not have a way of not dumbing it down, either. Usually after a few talks people pick up the vibe on how fast you understand things and what you already know, but when you have many different contacts with various people it often not even comes to that point.

Anyway sorry for the OT ;)

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by ZeroGravitas on Friday December 03, 2010 @06:08AM (#1965422)
My wife just had the same experience and I likened it to me phoning a tech support line. Although it's frustrating they're not insulting your intelligence, they're probably just as sad as you are that they have to break it down to that level for most people.

And, as someone with minor experience on the other side of tech support, you can't really afford to believe someone when they say they know what they're doing, they're quite possibly lying. A great tip my colleague mentioned from his days on tech support: "Never ask someone to check if it's plugged in. They'll just get offended, assume it's plugged in without checking and tell you it is. Instead tell them that dust gets into the plugs sometimes so take it out, blow on it and put it back in. When they're doing that they discover it wasn't plugged in, and replace it, usually without bothering to tell you why it magically starts working again. Must be that pesky dust!"

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by tjr on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:17AM (#1966091)
And sometimes we aren't as intelligent as we think we are.

On the phone with my home DSL service provider tech support, I was sure that the modem had been fried in an electrical storm (and, in fact, it had been). But they made me go through the standard script of stuff to check first, starting with unplugging the modem from the phone-line jack and plugging it back in. I did so, killing the conversation with tech support, as the phone was plugged into the modem...

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by roel_v on Friday December 03, 2010 @08:03AM (#1965644)
Yeah I think it's the same, you get to deal with all sorts of folk. My father in law is a doctor but he started out as a pathologist, as he always says - 'at least I didn't have to deal with all those sick people' ;)
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by mbreese on Friday December 03, 2010 @01:18PM (#1966862)
My wife is an MD/PhD, and I'm almost a PhD (molecular biology/bioinformatics), so I completely get what you're talking about. It is almost a night and day difference when talking to doctors. When they find out what you know, you can then have a much higher level conversation about things. For example, with our kids' pediatrician, there is no need to pitch vaccines. The only question is what shot are they getting today?

It's even funnier with our dog's vet. He started bringing out journal articles to explain stuff once.

So, yeah, it can be a bit of a give and take to figure out what level the conversation can take place at, but once you're there, you can be far more productive. I find that's it's easier to just say, "I'm a scientist/programmer/whatever, so I get it...". Unfortunately, this type of problem arises anytime you have a highly skilled person trying to explain something to a novice, doctors don't have a monopoly on this.

The other thing to remember is that sometimes they are just following policy and covering themselves legally by explaining something stupid.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by dmlorenzetti on Friday December 03, 2010 @01:35AM (#1964998)
Yes, and obviously I condensed the anecdote. Some aspects of the situation warranted charity (for example, we'd all traveled a long way to be there). Other aspects of her personality point to a basic lack of interest in anything outside her areas of expertise.

And obviously it's just an anecdote-- my friend doesn't represent all doctors. Nor am I detailing her many excellent qualities (she truly cares about her patients and those around her).

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by carbocation on Friday December 03, 2010 @01:39AM (#1965008)
I'm in medical school and took absolutely no offense; your storytelling was quite reasonable.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by bluesnowmonkey on Friday December 03, 2010 @02:56AM (#1965145)
Of course you can average times of day, as well as wind directions. Express them as vectors on a 2-D plane, then separately average the components in each dimension. Although this is somewhat obvious in the case of wind measurements, it works for times of day as well if you think of them as points on a 24-hour clock face.

Your medical friend was not checked out. She was busy stifling impolite laughter at your unfamiliarity with Cartesian coordinate systems.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by roel_v on Friday December 03, 2010 @05:36AM (#1965368)
For time, what would then be the average of let's say 3 and 9 o'clock? Center of the clock I presume, but what does that mean in terms of time? Or would you then need to define the average of several points in time as a non-point in time?
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by Vivtek on Friday December 03, 2010 @08:53AM (#1965756)
You'd have to talk about a time vector, with your case being the zero-length vector, or "no preference". Then a vector with a longer extent would indicate a "strong preference". Something like the standard deviation or something in a linear measure, I guess.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by DougBTX on Friday December 03, 2010 @07:22AM (#1965557)
Hand waving: I'm guessing that you could make a new vector from the average x and the average y. The direction would indicate the average time, and the length would indicate the certainty, so a length of zero would mean total uncertainty.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by cscheid on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:10PM (#1966604)
That's pretty much exactly right - the variance of the von mises distribution is essentially the length of the average vector.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Mises_distribution

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by d0mine on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:57AM (#1966267)
For 24-hours clock you should have said 6 and 18 hours.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by roel_v on Friday December 03, 2010 @11:23AM (#1966387)
How embarrassing - I initially had written a paragraph here pointing out how wrong you are and I was just seconds away from posting it before realizing you're right ;)

So yes you're right, to be consistent with the article and my reply elsewhere in this thread it should've been that. Luckily it seems that most posters managed to derive the underlying question from the circumstances ;)

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by copper on Friday December 03, 2010 @06:58AM (#1965510)
0 o'clock could be interpreted as 12 o'clock too.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by roel_v on Friday December 03, 2010 @08:00AM (#1965639)
The GP explicitly specified a 24-hour clock face, plus even on a 12-hour clock the question would remain.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by beambot on Friday December 03, 2010 @06:23PM (#1967838)
That may be a decent "hack" approach, but more generally you should use distributions meant to operate on circles, eg. von Mises (analagous to Gaussians): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Mises_distribution
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by eru on Friday December 03, 2010 @07:06AM (#1965522)
You can do that for wind, but what does it mean?

An equally valid measure for wind would be to take the absolutes, and average their squares. That'll give you a measure of the average energy in the wind.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by hugh3 on Friday December 03, 2010 @01:57PM (#1967019)
It means the average direction of the wind, which is an important factor in many places.

Of course this might need to be combined with an average windspeed to get a better picture of what the wind in a certain location is really like.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by eru on Saturday December 04, 2010 @06:40PM (#1970493)
Why don't we just look at the distribution in the first place? Make a nice circle chart for all wind vectors and color it according to probability.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by epo on Friday December 03, 2010 @09:36AM (#1965916)
How did this get voted for?

The doctor is far more knowledgeable about a VERY complex engineering system (the female reproductive system) than you or your brother are ever likely to be in any sphere of knowledge. She probably hadn't, as you put it, checked out, she was just being polite and waiting for you to stop babbling pedantic trivia. Perhaps amusing herself by wondering if you might have Aspergers.

Your final 'impression' of her thought processes is banal and insulting. And people wonder why geeks don't have girlfriends.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by sliverstorm on Friday December 03, 2010 @03:50AM (#1965217)
Chasing down the source of the information, calling it into question, relating it to other things in the world-- these just weren't things she seemed to find pleasurable.

Do you really want your doctor to be that sort of person? Do you want the person treating your kid for rickets to stand up and challenge the establishment and test a new hypothesis on the disease?

I don't know about you, but I'd prefer it if the medical researchers did the challenging, questioning and validating, and the practicing doctors (in general) went with the established knowledge. In my opinion practice and research (of most any subject) are fundamentally divided, and so long as a person can maintain perspective I think no worse of them for preferring one side to the other.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by Waywocket on Friday December 03, 2010 @05:52AM (#1965391)
>Do you really want your doctor to be that sort of person?

Are you joking? Abso-fucking-lutely I do.

Hell, I want everyone to be that sort of person. I contend that it is simply impossible for a person without those qualities to ever progress beyond 'adequate' at any task which is more than mechanical repetition of simple tasks.

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by Vivtek on Friday December 03, 2010 @08:51AM (#1965750)
Second this. Especially in medicine; not to go tl;dr on everybody again about my son's kidney disease, but our search through seven nephrologists stopped when we finally found one capable of looking at his case in a non-recipe-based manner.
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by rmc on Friday December 03, 2010 @07:48AM (#1965621)
Or the doctor was splitting the clock in half hour chunks (or similar). "born at 3am" probably means "born between 2:45am and 3:15am". If a baby was born at 3:02am, the next day they will say "I got no sleep, a baby was born at 3am last night!".
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by beambot on Friday December 03, 2010 @06:21PM (#1967833)
You can still say "average" (mean) for distributions over cycles (eg. on circles, von Mises distributions are analogous to Gaussians).

von Mises on Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Mises_distribution

Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by nostrademons on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:24AM (#1964876)
Unless you're House, apparently. I've always wondered how accurate that show really is...
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by jamesbritt on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:52AM (#1964923)
Re:Medical researcher discovers integration, gets 75 citations by kes on Friday December 03, 2010 @12:55AM (#1964927)