News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by narrator on Friday April 12, 2019 @09:17AM (#19644508)
Can we finally stop having sci-fi films in which the whole outcome of the movie is solely determined on some heroic manual flying of a spaceship while simultaneously using manually aimed weapons like it's World War II?
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by dragonwriter on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:39PM (#19646419)
> Can we finally stop having sci-fi films in which the whole outcome of the movie is solely determined on some heroic manual flying of a spaceship while simultaneously using manually aimed weapons like it's World War II?

Probably no, we can't stop having some of that. We can have her alternative, and, in fact, a lot of space combat in movies and TV is not resolved that way (both because it involves highly automated maneuver and targeting, and because, especially for combats that determine the outcome of the story, it is resolved by a social or technological advantage, often one provided by the quest making up the body of the plot, not by maneuvering or targeting (except to the extent that technical or social advantage impacts those abilities.)

Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by sandos on Monday April 15, 2019 @09:20AM (#19665064)
I like that about the Expanse novels, automatic systems control a lot of the lower level work in battles. Of course humans still come up with the crazy ideas and sort of execute them on a higher level.
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by bergoid on Friday April 12, 2019 @10:10AM (#19644923)
The Apollo 13 astronauts would like to share a couple of anecdotes with you.
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by jniedrauer on Friday April 12, 2019 @10:56AM (#19645290)
Apollo 13 (the movie) had plenty of careful checklist readbacks and minimal explosions or shaky cameras. Most scifi is more like Michael Bay in space. See Gravity for a more egregious example of a movie that tries to play itself off as "hard scifi" but ends up just being an over the top action movie.
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by TremendousJudge on Friday April 12, 2019 @04:31PM (#19648675)
Yeah, The Martian is like, the hardest sci-fi book I've ever read, but I found the film adaptation... lacking
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by chucksmash on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:33PM (#19646348)
Seems like it'd be tricky to do from a story telling perspective.

Totally removes all agency from protagonists. Every fight becomes a deus ex machina - "welp, our targetting subroutines continue to be superior to their maneuvering systems so they died. Hooray us?"

Or I guess more probably just a numbers game: "welp, our effective weapons range is larger than theirs, so that's that" with an MCRN exemption clause.

Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by philipkglass on Friday April 12, 2019 @03:18PM (#19648112)
Isn't this how real-world warfare is trending already? A vehicle full of soldiers may die before they even know there was a threat flying overhead. But it's not very heroic-looking to just keep the laser designator on target until the bomb lands.

I suppose that's why so many contemporary thrillers or even far-future science fiction movies devolve into hand to hand combat for the climactic showdown. It looks more interesting. (Though personally it makes me groan and want to throw things at the screen.)

Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by Retra on Friday April 12, 2019 @03:32PM (#19648224)
You can't really write a compelling story where your logistics make the hero rather than... heroism.
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by philipkglass on Friday April 12, 2019 @04:02PM (#19648478)
I wonder what the makers of Zero Dark Thirty did to keep it compelling. I haven't seen the movie myself. The real-life mission resulted in only one light injury among the Americans and involved zero fist fights. Osama bin Laden himself was killed before he could fire a single shot or throw a punch.
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by Florin_Andrei on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:39PM (#19647766)
> Every fight becomes a deus ex machina

Sounds like a book by Iain M. Banks.

Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by clarkmoody on Friday April 12, 2019 @11:07AM (#19645420)
My favorite sci-fi anticipates increased autonomy of technology and incorporates that smoothly into the narrative.
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by hwc on Friday April 12, 2019 @09:46AM (#19644726)
Also, can we start seeing this kind of re-usable multi-stage rocket used for achieving orbit in fiction?
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by inflatableDodo on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:20PM (#19646917)
Maybe look closely at the landing on the Hudson river. A good sci-fi plotline for getting out of hairy situations is heroic manual flying that is only made possible due to the automated systems.
Re:SpaceX nails triple booster landing after satellite delivery by timdiggerm on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:09PM (#19646060)
If you're talking about Star Wars, definitely not, because it's intentionally unrealistic.

Other sci-fi, maybe.