News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by bduerst on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:37PM (#19629739)
By that logic, any device with a microphone and potential to record should not exist.

Smart speakers are not telephone calls, and even if they were, federal law only requires consent of one party to record (11 states require all-party consent).

In public spaces, you generally lose any right to consent to recording. If you're in someone else's home and they record you with their smart speaker device, then your beef is with that person whose private property you're being recorded on. Same as if they were recording you with their phone's camera in their private residence, vs recording you in a public space.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by ridgeguy on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:48PM (#19630108)
I don’t agree. In your example, being in someone else’s home doesn’t put you in a public space for purposes of recording consent.

A dumb recording device can’t do something illegal without its owner’s/user’s affirmative action. If the homeowner uses the recording thing illegally they’re liable for that use.

In contrast, Alexa and similar devices operate on rules built-in by their builders. They do what their builders intend, not what applicable law or their owners require. Liability should rest with the builders.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by bduerst on Thursday April 11, 2019 @02:01PM (#19637369)
Right - being in someone else's home is their private residence. If they break the law using devices there then they are liable, not the device manufacturer. Maybe I didn't specify that enough.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by gumby on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:20PM (#19629948)
> By that logic, any device with a microphone and potential to record should not exist.

Not at all, it's how you use it. Cars can run over people but cars can exist; driving over someone is a crime committed by the operator. A machine with a microphone need not be, of itself, illegal.

There is an issue of a secret microphone, as with Google's camera that secretly included microphones. That seems fraudulent because the user is not able to knowledgable decide if she can trust the device.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by blotter_paper on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:31PM (#19630023)
I understand the distinction you're drawing with regards to the company secretly recording without anyone's consent, but in the imagined scenario discussed in this thread where a spouse or whoever gets recorded after a different user agrees to the terms and conditions wouldn't your reasoning place the blame on the original user who misused the tool, not on the company who supplied the tool? There are scenarios where a user might want to have an always-on microphone in a certain section of their house without violating anybody else's privacy.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by jakevn on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:49PM (#19630119)
Certainly, as long as the device does not trivialize the violation of those rights. If a car designed for road use by a human driver did not have a windshield to see out of, I'd say it is designed in a way to violate the rights of others.

Are Alexa and others designed to reasonably ensure only consenting users are being recorded?

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by blotter_paper on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @09:32PM (#19630359)
I have practically no doubt that Alexa and others are malevolently spying on their users, I hate to argue their case but I would like to be able to buy one if I wanted to.

Should I be allowed to buy a vehicle without a clear view of my surroundings if I only intend to use it on private land? Should I be allowed to buy a recording device with no privacy features if I intend to use it only in private? Does the potential harm produced by the availability of tools without bells and whistles for public safety outweigh the desires of users who would gladly pay for the bare-bones version and use it private?

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by jakevn on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @09:37PM (#19630387)
I don't believe Alexa and others are malevolently spying, but if the data exists, you should expect nothing less than it to be public at some point, or at least be accessed by someone you'd not expect to share your life with.

You _should_ absolutely be allowed to buy a non-street legal vehicle to operate on private land. You _should_ be able to buy a recording device that has no privacy features. You should _not_ be able to sell a recording device that by default is streaming all audio all the time for common consumers without a big label saying "everything this device is within hearing distance of is now public data and you agree you are in violation of the law, where applicable, for using it".

We are no longer in the days where consumers can be expected to know what their devices are even capable of, let alone what rights are being trampled.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by cortesoft on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @09:24PM (#19630311)
I mean, that is technically impossible? You have to record a voice to be able to analyze it to determine if the voice is of a person that consented.

This basically would outlaw ANY device that is voice activated, because it has to constantly be 'recording' to be able to be activated.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by jakevn on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @09:26PM (#19630327)
No, it's not. We can use facial recognition, we can use voice signatures. It doesn't even have to be recorded, as the device setup can record those signatures of consenting users and refuse to transmit or save any data that does not match those signatures.

Tell me, which of these do Alexa and the like perform?

Would it be more difficult? Yes! This is the reality for any company where rights and laws actually matter. If you can't abide, you can't release. Very simple.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by cortesoft on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @10:16PM (#19630572)
Ok, you are using a different definition of recording than me. I would say your definition is "recorded and stored"

I was thinking that in order to fingerprint a voice, you have to "record" it to a digital format that you can process to determine if it is the user who has consented. Even if it is deleted after processing, it was still "recorded" for a few milliseconds at least.

Does the law as written make that distinction? Would recording locally to check a fingerprint not still break the law?

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by gumby on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @11:46PM (#19630995)
the law on "copying" was abused by the music industry to try to get royalties on the buffering in dismal music devices and computers. The law eventually caught up and now there is no copyright violation in transient cacheing and buffering. I imagine the same will eventually happen for de minimums "recording" used to figure out if you may record or not (e.g. face recognition, voice printing and the like).
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by gumby on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @10:43PM (#19630704)
You don't need to record it, or at least you only need to record locally the part being spoken while you're doing the analysis; if they've consented you upload the recorded section and then realtime info; if they aren't one that consented you discard the cached snippet and stop recording that person.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by cortesoft on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @10:47PM (#19630731)
Right, but that is still recording, even if it is only temporary and local.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by thatoneuser on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:48PM (#19630112)
No its the responsibility of the device creator. This is more like an analogy where a self driving car killed someone as the company made the device activate under certain commands with no failsafe to prevent users who didn't agree to terms. Company was greedy to get the recordings.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by subway on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:41PM (#19629757)
The telephone is only relevant in some jurisdictions. For instance in Illlinois (an all-party state), you cannot record a private conversation. There's no mention of a phone or telecoms, and you should expect to get sued if you're in a conference room recording folks without their consent.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by bduerst on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:43PM (#19629762)
Precisely - the person who owns the conference room and placed the device there should expect to get sued. The person who manufactured the device shouldn't since they didn't use the device to break the law. The owner of the private property did.

It's the same with phone and security cameras - the manufacturers are not the ones at fault when the devices are incorrectly used by owners in states with specific legal laws regarding recording.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by subway on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:48PM (#19629790)
Imagine how long the devices would stay on the market if owners started being held liable for what the device does.

I'm not suggesting the device be made illegal, but I do think a ton of common applications should be... and without those applications, the device loses viability.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by bduerst on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:50PM (#19629804)
I imagine they will face the same market consequences that smart phones, security cameras, and other devices that have the potential to be used to record people in private places currently face. Customers with a low tolerance for being recorded simply just won't buy.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by subway on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:59PM (#19629852)
Security cameras often explicitly lack audio because of these laws. The other devices you mentioned all have primary functionality that doesn't depend of recording nearby audio arbitrarily. The possible exception is Siri and Google's assistant, which fall into the category of services/devices being questioned in this instance.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by nightfly on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:54PM (#19629824)
Tape recorders are still on the market.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by codetrotter on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:07PM (#19629897)
All of those toget devices you mention are activated manually by the user. Smart speakers activate automatically.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by bduerst on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:11PM (#19629914)
They activate on very specific commands. It's no different then adding a trigger phrase to start recording with those devices. Whether it's a VUI, physical button UI, or even motion-sensor triggered is splitting hairs, since the device is still owned and operated by the person who put it there.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by subway on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:35PM (#19630048)
It's very different when the trigger is locally a not-so-great guess followed by shipping the audio to a remote service that can make a slightly more informed guess.
Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by bisby on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @09:32PM (#19630355)
> The person who manufactured the device shouldn't since they didn't use the device to break the law.

The issue at hand is that if the manufacturer is the one who turns on the device, then yes, it is 100% them breaking the law.

If my phone is hacked and the microphone is remotely enabled to record a conversation and ends up violating the law, I'm not at fault, the hacker is.

So how is it different if the "hacker" is just the manufacturer using a private channel that they built for themselves?

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by tripzilch on Saturday April 20, 2019 @05:01AM (#19705503)
Ultimately what that boils down to is that if I don't want to be recorded, I should stay in my own home and not even visit anywhere, because only at home I can expect privacy.

That's not privacy.

Re:Is Anyone Listening to You on Alexa? A Global Team Review... by meko on Thursday April 11, 2019 @03:44PM (#19638398)
Minor correction, you said:

> private property

When you actually meant:

> personal property