News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by GordonS on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @05:45PM (#19629107)
I did the same 1-2 years ago, and haven't regretted it. Interestingly, I've experienced the same thing where others seem offended by decision, and I also get accused of being insular and "living in my own little bubble". I just don't get this though - what exactly am I losing out on?
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by bilbo0s on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:06PM (#19629568)
Well, the good news is that you guys aren't losing out on it!

You're on HN. Which means you get your daily dose of "outrage porn" like anyone else. I think many people don't think of HN as, basically, a "News" site. With a large percentage of the front page dedicated to "outrage porn". "Big Tech Helping China." "US Workers Highly Taxed." Etc etc etc. And those are just the more, kind of, moderate examples. I think yesterday's: "San Francisco's Slow Motion Suicide" was an example that went a bit further. And there have been discussions on here that just tend to devolve into extremism relatively quickly. (I guess the San Fran post from yesterday devolved into extremism relatively quickly as well. But I suppose I'm talking about discussions that tend to devolve right away.)

At any rate, yeah, if we're on HN, we can't realistically claim to have sworn off news, or "outrage porn". We're just, kind of, comfortable with the "outrage porn" that we get from Hacker News. So much so that some of us, apparently, don't even recognize it as news, or "outrage porn".

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by fzeroracer on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:53PM (#19630142)
Exactly. I've seen many ridiculous stories, nonsense etc on HN which existed purely to fuel outrage among the more tech-oriented crowd.

Ultimately when people say they've dropped out of a specific news bubble: that means they've just started ignoring things that don't personally affect them or they don't care about. It's essentially as another commentator said meant that you're in favor of the status quo, which means you shouldn't be surprised if you encounter someone who is negatively affected by the status quo and calls you out on being OK with it.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by jiggunjer on Thursday April 11, 2019 @12:47AM (#19631229)
I don't read the articles on HN. Just here because I often learn about new things (not news) from the discussion.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by mruts on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:24AM (#19634217)
You never read any articles on HN? Maybe you shouldn't be commenting if you've literally never read a single one?
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by johnchristopher on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:34AM (#19634911)
Doesn't mean parent isn't aware of the topic or hasn't heard about it from somewhere else.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by cerberusss on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:57AM (#19642088)
Man, things have changed. I used to be on Slashdot, where it was a badge of honor if you didn't RTFA (read the fine article).
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by dwaltrip on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:24PM (#19629673)
This is a good point. However, I think the major difference is the proportion of the content that is "outrage porn". I would argue that HN has a notably lower proportion.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by bilbo0s on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:47PM (#19629784)
Just took a look at my main "Go to", the BBC.

It's difficult to tell, because the front page of BBC has so many more articles on it than the front page of HN, but the "outrage porn" proportion seems about equal to me. Right around 1/4 or 1/5 of the articles I would classify that way. Seems about the same as HN.

Just for context, at the moment on HN, I'd say these are the "news"-y and "outrage porn"-y posts on the front page.

"Amazon Workers Are Listening To What You Tell Alexa" - Obligatory "outrage porn" post for FAANG company. (Generally a minimum of one is always present on the front page.)

"Urgent Quest For Slower, Better News"

"Most Prestigious Journals Publishing Least Reliable Science"

"New Human Species Found In Philippines" - (Predictable descent into extreme views on evolution. No more "Out of Africa", all that "scientific evidence" stuff is nonsense.)

"Startup Stock Options - Good Deal Gone Bad"

"Logic of Political Survival"

And that doesn't even count the posts on the front page that are borderline.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by intertextuality on Thursday April 11, 2019 @01:21AM (#19631371)
For starters, I think you're being extremely cynical.

Second, unlike other news sources, HN tends to have moderate to high quality discussion. I come to HN because I tend to learn things and grow here. That's not to say that it's perfect of course, but I think you're being more than a bit dishonest when you compare HN to mainstream media news.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by misterman0 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @01:48AM (#19631495)
>> compare HN to mainstream media news

HN is a aggregator of (mainstream) media news. It is in a position where it should be able to achieve a better ratio between clickbait and non-clickbait than others. Parent suggested it doesn't. I agree. Huston, we have a problem.

Am I outraged over the fact? Not at all. Because I do not expect HN to be better than mainstream. And in fact it isn't. HN is just a different pie.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by kgwxd on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:58AM (#19633406)
"If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic."

It's not supposed to be an aggregator of mainstream news. Unfortunatley, it has become that.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by lifthrasiir on Thursday April 11, 2019 @02:30AM (#19631682)
> Second, unlike other news sources, HN tends to have moderate to high quality discussion.

I firmly oppose to this view. What you are perceiving as "moderate to high quality" is actually just the suppression of mean words, that is good by itself but does not equate to the quality.

I too classify about one fifth of the HN front page as "outrage porns"; they tend to be visibly biased and their discussions are significantly worse in my humble opinion. For that portion of HN I believe they are no better than the mainstream media. If you want remaining four fifths, good! But you have to learn to filter the problematic fifth out.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by wavepruner on Friday April 12, 2019 @07:18AM (#19643775)
I think most of the political discussions on HN have a clear side that the commenters take. To disagree with the consensus invites down-votes into oblivion, so almost no one disagrees with the consensus.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by mixmastamyk on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:56PM (#19630168)
Still, HN is an order of magnitude more thoughtful than the clowns at Fox/CNN/etc news. Just the fact that it is mostly text is one factor.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by honzzz on Thursday April 11, 2019 @04:47AM (#19632179)
How would you define outrage porn? I think that we have to be careful with definitions. Just as we do not define everything that produces sexual arousal as porn because we would have to call even meaningful relationships porn, we should be careful not to call everything that might produce a certain level of disagreement "outrage porn". If there is a well reasoned and substantiated article about something that is bad and should be fixed, what is your metric to distinguish it from outrage porn?
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by enumjorge on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @06:58PM (#19629529)
I do agree that paying too much attention to the crazy that’s going on is not constructive or healthy. But you can definitely overcorrect.

If you completely disconnect you have no data with which to make your decisions come election time. A lot of what’s happening in politics does affect you directly. Changes to tax code, the budget, deregulation of industries (e.g. net neutrality).

And some of it may not affect you directly but affects people in the communities you live in. A Supreme Court nominee had allegations of sexual assault and gambling problems brought against him. Regardless of what you believe, it behooves you to be aware that this is happening. If the accusations were true don’t you want to know? It affects the women in your life to have someone like that be given a lifelong appointment to the most powerful court of the land. If the accusations weren’t, wouldn’t that be important too?

If you’re taking a break to maintain sanity I can understand that. But if you’re simply shrugging your shoulders at what’s happening simply because it doesn’t affect you right now—and trust me, some of the policies this administration is adopting are having a big impact on some—then I think that’s a pretty shitty, selfish attitude to have.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by malvosenior on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:03PM (#19629550)
> And some of it may not affect you directly but affects people in the communities you live in. A Supreme Court nominee had allegations of sexual assault and gambling problems brought against him. Regardless of what you believe, it behooves you to be aware that this is happening. If the accusations were true don’t you want to know? It affects the women in your life to have someone like that be given a lifelong appointment to the most powerful court of the land. If the accusations weren’t, wouldn’t that be important too?

This example is exactly why someone should ignore the news. This was pure partisan bickering and mud slinging. Not once during the whole episode were Kavanaugh's actual positions discussed. Just rumors, gossip, fighting and soundbites. No one came out ahead paying attention to this story.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by enumjorge on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:43PM (#19629763)
I understand your frustration, but I think this logic is easily exploited. Part of democracy is keeping our elected officials in check. If we mentally check out whenever they put on a circus show, we’re rewarding bad behavior.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by malvosenior on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @07:59PM (#19629854)
I see it more as by paying attention to the circus you’re rewarding bad behavior (circus creation). Being immune to the histrionics makes it harder to be exploited.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by vinceguidry on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:21AM (#19632754)
It works the other way too. No amount of leftist outrage managed to bring Trump to heel. Checking out of the news cycle and only getting involved when it seems to be particularly relevant seems like the saner strategy, particularly as our time and cognitive resources are the most precious ones we have.

Why blow it all on generating outrage when it'll just get manipulated into a bottom third talking point?

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by jiggunjer on Thursday April 11, 2019 @01:06AM (#19631296)
The Supreme Court example isn't very good, because you can't act on the outcome in a sensible democratic way.

A better example would be news that brings X to attention, so you can voice concern to the government. Or in the case where politicians are the focus of attention, it can affect your voting choice.

E.g. the internet filter law proposal in Europe. It's not practical for me to review every individual piece of legislation, so I rely on journalists/news platforms to highlight the important bits. As a consequence of the MEP vote I have now blacklisted one political party I considered moderate before. They will never get a vote or a good word from me again, ever.

Other examples you could have mentioned are stuff like the Panama papers and Wikileaks. If I heard a local construction company was funneling money to tax havens, I'd email my municipality and/or IRS.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by weaklearner on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:35AM (#19635643)
I think you can act in democratic ways. Like 1. donating 20 dollars to susan collin's opponent for instance 2. voting against your senator

I think the bigger thing is that it is a TORRENT that overwhelms.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by rayiner on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @09:38PM (#19630394)
Do you really need to read the news to know who to vote for given your views on those issues?
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by erikbye on Thursday April 11, 2019 @02:38AM (#19631708)
News is the here and now presentation of events (and basically press releases/packages), which one absolutely does not need to consume daily in order to do informed voting.

What you want to be reading is aggregate analysis, and quality articles of that kind are found on sites which mostly avoid feeding you the other bullshit. Publications like Economist, Atlantic, Politico, etc.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by geargrinder on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:50AM (#19633876)
Publications like those you named are tuned to your particular brand of "bs" but they have just as much bias as publications you find distasteful. That is the state of our news these days. I can't think of a mainstream news org on that level that is without significant bias.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by dragonsngoblins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:09PM (#19640606)
I really disagree with the consume daily part. I consume news most days, but why can't I just spend some time doing research on the various candidates and what they did over the past several years that was newsworthy in the few weeks immediately before an election? If anything I'd think that would be better as they won't have to worry about having forgotten some dick move some candidate pulled three years ago
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by megaremote on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @09:12PM (#19630255)
> If you completely disconnect you have no data with which to make your decisions come election time.

Nothing has happened in the last 10 years to change who I vote for. And this is the same for the majority of people.

Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by icebraining on Thursday April 11, 2019 @02:59AM (#19631794)
How do you know?
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by ghthor on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @06:11PM (#19629270)
Being stressed out and dying early is what you're losing out on. Also being in pain and unhappy.
Re:The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News by drb91 on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @06:53PM (#19629520)
Being stressed out and dying early is also a likely result for an apathetic population.