News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DNS-over-HTTPS Policy Requirements for Resolvers by JohnFen on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @04:34PM (#19628519)
> Personally I'm not an "owner" of the networks I'm connecting to.

But I am the owner of my own network, and DoH reduces my ability to protect it. That is the main (but not only) reason why I strongly object to DoH.

> I think this train has passed.

I suspect the battle has just begun. For example, my response to DoH has been to implement a MITM packet inspection system on my network to regain control over this. This means that DoH will not work from my network. I expect that we're going to see this sort of thing more and more.

Re:DNS-over-HTTPS Policy Requirements for Resolvers by comex on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @10:08PM (#19630540)
What exactly are the threats that you expect blocking DoH to protect you from?

If you are MitMing all encrypted traffic anyway, why not block whatever you want to block when someone actually tries to connect to it, rather than trying to prevent them from learning where it is?

Re:DNS-over-HTTPS Policy Requirements for Resolvers by JohnFen on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:38AM (#19634343)
> What exactly are the threats that you expect blocking DoH to protect you from?

I want to maintain the ability to block the resolution of certain domain names.

The threat model is malicious software or websites that want to phone home. This includes reaching out to command-and-control servers, ad tracking servers, data exfiltration points, etc.

> If you are MitMing all encrypted traffic anyway, why not block whatever you want to block when someone actually tries to connect to it

Because most of the malicious actors don't use raw IP addresses as they can change frequently and without notice. They resolve a domain name instead. Blocking the domain name lookup is therefor more effective and less likely to result in blocking the wrong things than working with raw IP addresses.

This is not a replacement for other security measures (including IP-based blocks), but is is, in my opinion, a critical measure in and of itself.