Re:Boeing 737 MAX crash and the rejection of ridiculous data
by prmph on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @06:01PM
(#19629207)
There is a difference between the AF 447 situation and what is recommended in the article.
What is suggested is that the aircraft refrain from performing risky manoeuvres based on such wildly out-or-range sensor outputs.
This does not mean that aircraft should suppress warnings of such sensor readings from the pilots.
The "solution" described in the article seems to add more complexity and surprises to a system (MCAS) that already behaves in surprising and unexpected ways. Engineering is hard, adding a band aid on top of an ill devised clutch without carefully thinking, writing, and peer reviewing all the possible consequences, is unlikely to help.