News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fxbl0i on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:08PM (#19608124)
How many of those consumers expect to keep using Google services for free?
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by JohnFen on Monday April 08, 2019 @04:33PM (#19608746)
I would be absolutely thrilled if, in exchange for not using Google services at all, Google would stop spying on me. That's not an option, though.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by sandov on Monday April 08, 2019 @04:52PM (#19608898)
In which ways would they keep spying on you?

If you install privacy badger, block their IP addresses on your hosts file, don't use an Android phone(at least not a stock ROM), don't visit Google sites, etc. I don't think they would be able to gather much info about you.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by tremon on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @05:40AM (#19613052)
In which ways would they keep spying on you?

Other people have already brought up Android and GMail contacts. Here's some purely web-based examples:

- Google Analytics

- ajax.googleapis.com

- fonts.gstatic.com

- Google Maps (embedded on other sites)

- ReCaptcha

There's way too many sites that simply break if you null-route googleapis.com. Trust me, I've tried.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by codedokode on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @04:50AM (#19612873)
And when Google installs free face recognition cameras in shops and malls, where are you going to buy things to avoid surveillance? I would prefer to be able to use online shops, taxi apps, smartphones, bank cards, but without spyware and unlimited data collection.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by Viliam1234 on Monday April 08, 2019 @05:02PM (#19608995)
For example, they would still have all e-mails sent from/to people using Gmail.

Unless you have a strict policy of "stop using Gmail, or I will stop corresponding with you electronically", Google is going to read large parts of your private correspondence anyway.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by kortilla on Monday April 08, 2019 @07:15PM (#19610089)
Add:

Don’t use credit cards (they buy the transaction data)

Don’t let your contacts with Gmail addresses email you

Don’t let your contacts with android or ios setup to sync contacts add you as a contact

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by sandov on Monday April 08, 2019 @07:43PM (#19610273)
Good points. I didn't know about the credit cards part.

I stand corrected.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by JohnFen on Monday April 08, 2019 @05:06PM (#19609040)
Google also buys real-world credit and debit card usage and correlates that with the other information they gather, for example.

I defend myself against Google as much as I can using the methods you cite (among others), but the reality is that it's impossible to avoid their spying entirely.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:12PM (#19608152)
Both senses of the word free work beautifully together. Free as in beer and free as in speech. We shouldn't put up with violations of our personal liberty for no-cost software.

Tech is such a young industry- we still have time to shape it into a place that can be free in both senses of the word. Just because shareholders demand it doesn't mean that consumers should accept immorality.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by geddy on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:16PM (#19608187)
>We shouldn't put up with violations of our personal liberty for no-cost software

This is exactly what we've been torpedoing towards since Google Docs came out and people didn't have to pay for Acrobat Reader to see PDFs. Unfortunately from free services where the user is the product, and free apps with in-app purchases on mobile, the general public has been conditioned to never spend a dime, privacy be damned. We did it to ourselves.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fixermark on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:19PM (#19608205)
Not only did we do it to ourselves, we're mostly enjoying and benefitting from it. The alternative (where all software is pay-to-play) actually shuts out the vast bulk of the world's population that doesn't have chips to play yet.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by max76 on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:53PM (#19608464)
A lot of software, like Libre Office, neither track users, nor sells advertising space, nor charges users.

For important infrastructure pieces, like how businesses communicate with each other, we should strive for this level of privacy and availability.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fixermark on Monday April 08, 2019 @04:02PM (#19608525)
Does Libre Office allow for simultaneous collaborative editing by multiple users and seamless passing of current version by passing a URL around? Does it require correct set up and maintenance of a Linux installation (which has gotten a lot simpler in the past 20-odd-years, but still requires more than its fair share of technical expertise), or can it be used by anyone with a web browser, regardless of operating system or installed software configuration (save, of course, the web browser)?

If not, it's definitely an option but I'd generally anticipate it'll lose out in userbase to the alternative that has those features.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Monday April 08, 2019 @06:31PM (#19609733)
I think most of us can agree that sometimes Google services are extremely practical. I just don't think that the practicality is an argument towards the morality of their business.

I wouldn't make this a morality based argument if we just had transparency. If they were perfectly transparent, their business model would be fine (in terms of morality at least). But I believe, personally, that they have the responsibility to better inform consumers exactly what data they're collecting and exactly where it's going.

If you are a well educated consumer who decides that they are comfortable with the level of surveillance in exchange for that product, than by all means. I just wish it wasn't impossible to be a well educated consumer in this field.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fixermark on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @08:03AM (#19613722)
Privacy isn't a morality question for most users. If it were, we would expect to see more people up in arms about demographic surveys instead of willfully participating in them.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @08:39AM (#19613962)
privacy isn't the morality question, being misleading about your privacy is the morality question.

Google is collecting surveillance data on it's consumers, that the majority of it's consumers don't even know is being collected.

At what point does it become Google's responsibility to make a reasonable effort to inform people about their surveillance practices? I'd say if polling shows that the majority of your consumers aren't aware of your surveillance practices, you aren't being honest.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fixermark on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @09:59AM (#19614655)
> At what point does it become Google's responsibility

The last time we tried to push the responsibility onto individual organizations to inform the public of the basics of how the Internet works, we ended up with "This site uses cookies" dialogs popping up redundantly and annoyingly everywhere.

I think I'd rather see the money spent on a public education campaign, not unlike the US Health and Human Services videos of the 1950s. While hokey and hilarious by modern standards, they provided a real service in helping Americans reconcile with rapid advances in technology and hygiene (including now "common sense" ideas such as "Don't play in construction sites" and "Drinking and driving are dangerous").

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Thursday April 11, 2019 @02:27PM (#19637627)
so now I'm supposed to pay even more taxes so the government can pay to advertise to me to inform me of an american companies lack of ethics?
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by mirimir on Monday April 08, 2019 @08:43PM (#19610588)
With exceptions on the level of sharing recipes or whatever, I find it hard to imagine collaborators using such an insecure platform. Sure, communications are encrypted, but Google has full access to documents.

How do IT security staff sign off on stuff like that?

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fixermark on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @08:05AM (#19613738)
Perhaps the security staff are convinced that either Google doesn't actually have access to it in any practically-concerning sense (https://www.quora.com/Can-Google-open-and-see-files-in-my-Go...), or the risks associated with that access are negligible?

I think you've hit on a very interesting point. The fact that IT security staff (with careers and reputations on the line) do sign off on companies using Google's platform for business applications that include passing sensitive data around might indicate that our assessment of the risk model is flawed?

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @08:36AM (#19613943)
Many of us are the people making those risk assessments. What information would these IT security staff have that we don't?

It's no secret that a lot of companies don't have great information security.

I think that the fact that people are signing off on it just emphasizes how little some people care about information security.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fixermark on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @10:00AM (#19614667)
> What information would these IT security staff have that we don't?

The cost-benefit analysis of their individual industries and the risk tolerance of their companies.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @03:45PM (#19618267)
I'm talking about actual information about what Google does with their data.

The cost-benefit analysis and risk tolerance doesn't tell us about how much Google secures their privacy, it tells us about how much the company cares about their privacy/security.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fixermark on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @03:57PM (#19618348)
Google's entire privacy policy is laid out in (by the standards of other documents I've seen) very digestible language. https://policies.google.com/privacy#intro

Beyond that, it's a trust and a penalties-for-violating-policy exercise.

And I agree with you: you can probably tell volumes about how much a company cares about the risk factors based on who they trust. But I don't generally think companies are being ignorant placing their chips on Google---it's a big org with a lot to lose if something goes wrong. That gives it advantages over either smaller competitors or rolling one's own (factoring in that to match the security of a dedicated service's cloud offering while approaching the convenience of such an offering, you basically have to hire your own full-attack-surface-spectrum infosec team, and that's one more line item in a small company's budget).

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Monday April 08, 2019 @05:20PM (#19609156)
Open source solves both of these problems. The way I see it, software that costs money is a problem, and software that compromises your freedom is a problem.

Sure Google can solve one of those problems, but we also shouldn't pat ourselves on the back unless we solve both problems.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by 43920 on Monday April 08, 2019 @06:18PM (#19609633)
I've seen this attitude a lot, and I don't really understand it. Software takes a ton of work to produce, and in many cases a significant degree of skill as well, and I don't really see an issue with wanting to be compensated for it. If charging money is bad, and advertising is bad, what are you supposed to do? Given that you're posting here, I'm assuming that you likely get paid to write software as well - do you think it's reasonable for everyone to expect that you produce software for free?
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Monday April 08, 2019 @07:56PM (#19610343)
You're right, it's certainly more nuanced than 'money = bad' and 'advertising = bad'.

I still think that in the context of this discussion, open source does solve both the privacy problem and the accessibility problem. But you're right that there are problems, namely incentive, that open source does not solve.

Open source is not the only solution to those problems, and sometimes solving those problems (privacy and accessibility) just isn't practical. In those cases, I would just wish for more transparency.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by lotu on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:58PM (#19608499)
Nitpick, can we say "the user's attention is the product" instead of "the user is the product". It is less descriptive and hyperbolic which reduces the speaker's credibility. It also minimizes the suffering of people that have (and unfortunately still are) sold as slaves (literal human products).
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by jonfw on Monday April 08, 2019 @05:26PM (#19609203)
The user's attention isn't the sole product though. Personal information about the user is also a huge part of the product.

Saying it's just your attention doesn't accurately convey concerns about their data collection.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by codedokode on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @04:54AM (#19612891)
Android is not free, but it tries to collect as much data as possible, for example, WiFi access point identifiers tied to GPS location. Paying for a product doesn't stop you from being a product at the same time. Because this way the corporation would earn more that just from selling a product.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by codedokode on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @04:44AM (#19612841)
Free or paid doesn't mean anything. You buy Windows 10 or you buy an Android phone - and you get under surveillance. Actually, using a "free" linux distribution or a "free" pirated Windows might give you higher chance to stay under radar.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by syrrim on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @01:25AM (#19612034)
There are search engines that offer search without collecting user data. Advertising provides enough revenue to make this sustainable. I doubt that google will switch to this model of it's own volition of course.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by wolco on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:32PM (#19608301)
Most would. There have been many search engines never a paid one. Many free email providers existed before and after gmail.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by max76 on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:23PM (#19608241)
DDG Search is a free competitor to Google Search that doesn't track. It's not that Google either tracks their users or charges their users. In addition, there is a whole range of tracking activities and we should have open and informed discussions about if some of them should become illegal, or if companies require simpler disclosures about their privacy policy.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by trpc on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:30PM (#19608287)
>DDG Search is a free competitor to Google Search that doesn't track

prove it please

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by max76 on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:37PM (#19608340)
"We don't collect or share personal information. That's our privacy policy in a nutshell." https://duckduckgo.com/privacy

I can't prove that DDG doesn't track users, but their entire brand is based on very hardline privacy policy. If they are secretly tracking, and they are caught, their brand value will be reduced to near zero.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by fxbl0i on Monday April 08, 2019 @04:05PM (#19608553)
I doubt it. Firefox has had a few privacy scandals of their own, but as long as they are marginally better than Google, they'll keep having a fervent user base.
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by wolco on Monday April 08, 2019 @04:06PM (#19608559)
They record searches. They do not offer personalized ads that track users interest and sell ads.

Depending on what you are hiding. If you want to hide that anyone searched for a term, no. If you want to hide that you searched for a term, yes.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by trpc on Monday April 08, 2019 @04:12PM (#19608600)
>They record searches

so they record the most important thing a search engine can get from users in order to make profit from ads, true respect for privacy indeed!

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by vonmoltke on Monday April 08, 2019 @05:12PM (#19609092)
You ignored the rest of that post:

> If you want to hide that anyone searched for a term, no. If you want to hide that you searched for a term, yes.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by graeme on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:34PM (#19608322)
This isn’t proof, but wouldn’t we hear some employee or partner leaks if it did? It’s hard to keep a really big secret while publicly proclaiming the opposite.

Exception would perhaps be a govt enforced one, with jail threats for those who leaked.

Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @03:09AM (#19612466)
Would google actually lose money on most of these services if they had to use non-tracking ads?
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by tlynchpin on Monday April 08, 2019 @09:29PM (#19610844)
How many of those consumers expect to keep watching soap operas for free?
Re:A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track the... by nukeop on Monday April 08, 2019 @03:58PM (#19608500)
This doesn't matter, even if it were paid they'd still spy on you, because they can. The list of paid services that still do a ton of spying is neverending (Netflix, Uber, Spotify, I could list them all day).