News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by skookumchuck on Monday April 08, 2019 @01:26AM (#19602380)
As I get older, I find I am reading more and more non-fiction and less and less fiction. I had a curious epiphany about it.

I novel has a beginning, middle, and end. That's all there is to it. If you're a fan, there's nothing more. You can study it all you like, it's fruitless. You can see this with the Star Trek fans, all that interest and excitement pretty much goes nowhere. They wind up memorizing the scripts and doing cosplay.

With non-fiction, there's no beginning and no end. There is always more to the story. There are details omitted. There's a bias. It's like a fractal, the closer you get, the more detail there is. Thus if you find it interesting, you can satisfy that itch for more.

Caro's books are ones that satisfy the itchy person who wants to delve much deeper into a story than the usual insipid treatment. And if that isn't enough, Caro didn't include everything, there's always more for the next historian to unearth.

Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by ctchocula on Monday April 08, 2019 @02:59AM (#19602787)
I think there is a lot of value in fiction. Reading some classics like the sibling commenter mentioned: Shakespeare, Homer, Tolstoy, etc. Even if the fiction is a lie, you learn a lot about how other people think through fiction. "Fiction is a lie that tells the truth" or so they say [1].

Even with Star Trek beyond TNG, the show fundamentally reflects Gene Roddenberry's ideas of what a post-scarcity society (symbolized by the replicator) looks like. Unlike our society that prizes money as what others judge you based on, in Star Trek, there is no money. People have the right not to work if they don't want to, but to gain prestige you need to contribute to society by joining Starfleet where values like morality and heroism are highly prized [2].

[1] http://edteck.peterpappas.com/rothberg/fictionisalie.htm

[2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/27040338-trekonomics

Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by aestetix on Monday April 08, 2019 @07:46AM (#19604259)
Good fiction explores ideas which are timeless.

Also, I would say that the "beginning, middle, end" model is a rather superficial framing. Take the Homeric works like the Iliad, for example. It starts right in the middle of a massive conflict that leads to the Trojan War (in media res). A new reader actually has to spend some time reading to get context as to what the hell is going on, and why.

Also, novels are not the only forms of fiction. What about plays and short stories, or even songs?

Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by skookumchuck on Monday April 08, 2019 @07:48PM (#19610305)
I enjoy songs. A lot. The lyrics, however, are meaningless, mostly just short phrases repeated ad nauseum. It's silly to impute deep meaning into them.

    She loves you, yeah yeah yeah
    She loves you, yeah yeah yeah
    She loves you,
    and you know that can't be bad!
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by aestetix on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @02:39AM (#19612339)
What about lyrics from artists like Bob Dylan? Clearly I'm not the only one who thinks he writes poetry, given that he won the Nobel Prize for it ;)
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by skookumchuck on Tuesday April 09, 2019 @03:58AM (#19612636)
Sure, Dylan writes poetry. And it's enjoyable, I have many Dylan CDs. But if you're interested in learning more, it's a dead end.
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by teddyh on Monday April 08, 2019 @06:42AM (#19603921)
The problem with fiction is that it suffers from the “author fiat” problem a.k.a. “it works and has no problems because the author says so”. Real life has no such cheat, and real history and situations can be more usefully examined for problems. Fiction can be useful for brainstorming ideas, but as realistic target it is dangerous.

Regarding Star Trek and post-scarcity, I can only say that not everybody is convinced by what it canonically presents itself to be:

http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Essays/Trek-Marxism.html

Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by krapp on Monday April 08, 2019 @06:57AM (#19603995)
Star Trek was never intended to portray a realistic, consistent or well thought out post-scarcity society. You could probably describe the entirety of what's portrayed about that society on the back of a napkin.

It runs on magic and nonsensoleum (replicators, transporters and free energy, none of which can exist in the real world) and the unjustified assumption that humanity will simply abandon its vices and prejudices if presented with enough magical wish machines and space communism, rather than use those magical wish machines to manufacture weapons and drugs and rob banks and kidnap people with transporters.

Star Trek is just entertainment, and any attempt to read more deeply into it or extrapolate it into the real world, other than through whatever vaguely moralistic message the plot, itself, attempts to portray, is bound to be a waste of time.

Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by skookumchuck on Monday April 08, 2019 @05:56AM (#19603697)
Oh, I still read fiction, and I enjoyed watching Star Trek TOS. But really, how many times can you rewatch them? I know about Roddenberry's ideas, too. Lots of people have ideas. Roddenberry's are not that sophisticated (compared with, say, Tolkien's). It doesn't take much text to explain his ideas. And then what? You have silly people attempting to create "canon" for their dreamworld?

ST certainly is Roddenberry's vision of utopia. But consider that people have endlessly attempted to create utopias on earth. Isn't that more interesting? The Pilgrims tried to create one. The Amish tried. The Mormons tried. The Soviets tried. The Nazis tried. Kellogg tried. Jim Jones tried.

What's different about ST is you can always make a fictional utopia work by just typing in "... and it works!" That makes it, to me, fundamentally uninteresting compared to real world attempts that are unable to adjust their scripts to reality.

Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by spookybones on Monday April 08, 2019 @02:43AM (#19602713)
Yeah Shakespeare and Homer’s works were one time reads. No depth! But let’s compare a non-fiction great work to genre fiction based on a TV show...
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by skookumchuck on Monday April 08, 2019 @05:40AM (#19603631)
You're never going to find out any more about Romeo or Juliet than the words in the play.
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by qntty on Monday April 08, 2019 @09:29AM (#19604953)
It's a mistake to think that Romeo and Juliet, or any fiction, is really just about the characters in the story. You might not learn more about Romeo or about Juliet but you can learn more about what people will do for love. You don't have to read fiction for this, you can learn it from psychological studies if you want.
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by skookumchuck on Monday April 08, 2019 @07:52PM (#19610320)
> you can learn more about what people will do for love

Not from reading R+J, you won't, any more than you will learn about how utopias work by watching Star Trek.

If you want to learn about what people will actually do for love, read one of the many biographies of Henry VIII. (And there's always more to learn about him, if you're interested.)

Or you could read about Cleopatra & Antony.

Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by qntty on Monday April 08, 2019 @08:15PM (#19610453)
A piece of literature is an argument. If it fails to convince you, then it must not be very good. I think Romeo and Juliet says interesting things about love and I think that Star Trek says interesting things about utopias.
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by Retra on Monday April 08, 2019 @09:53AM (#19605184)
Yes, I think that's the point. What fiction offers is less than what non-fiction offers.
Re:Robert A. Caro on the means and ends of power by qntty on Monday April 08, 2019 @12:50PM (#19606851)
What I'm saying is that they basically offer the same thing, in different rhetorical modes.