Re:Sweeping Reform Would Tax Capital Gains Like Ordinary Income
by deanalevitt on Sunday April 07, 2019 @03:11PM
(#19599187)
re: Chesterton's Fence - great analogy. Until they mention the significant benefits of the lower capital gains tax, and how raising taxes won't detract from those benefits, the entire premise appears woefully unprepared.
All of which ignores that one of the (multiple) important reasons longterm capital gains are not taxed like income is that those investments are adversely impacted by inflation, which is not deductible in the US. In many other countries that tax capital gains at income-like rates, the cost basis is inflation adjusted, which substantially reduces the amount of taxes actually paid on capital gains. Most countries deal with longterm inflation on capital gains either by allowing deduction of inflation or lowering capital gains tax rates to compensate (which is viewed as simpler to implement), but it would very poor policy to do neither.
tl;dr: This is not realistic tax policy. See also: Chesterton's Fence.