Probably the single most effective way to enable progress on Alzheimer's research would be to discover something else they could all work on, and stop blocking infectious disease specialists' work.
- Heart disease is actually caused by metabolic syndrome (read: same cause as diabetes)
- Alzheimers is analogous to diabetes (some are calling it Type 3)
I'm not convinced of the above, but it's interesting.
Your post reminded me of this pub: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3709085/
The easiest example of this sort of highly polarized dynamic is in the realm of diets.
But it could still mean that preventing the plaque formation would stop the dementia, right?
That might be totally fine if the effects of the disease the plaques fight are not as bad as the disease they cause -- e.g. the "prolonged" disease is not as bad as Alzheimer.
I guess it comes down to whether you believe that an infection disproportionately affects old people and causes dementia. It probably doesn’t, not for any good biological reason, but because it doesn’t sound like any progress has been made on the biomechanics of dementia.
Laypeople obviously don’t care about the plaques. They want the dementia to go away. You can make a mouse model that has a brain infection, and then potentially a model where that infection shows plaques, and then a molecule that gets rid of the infection. But it’s really hard to tell (in real life, not in science speak) if a mouse has dementia. That’s the limitation.
We’re so incredibly far away from drug interventions for dementia.
What they're saying is that after many years of fighting the infection Alzheimer's starts to develop. Certainly people who are older have the potential to have more years of infection. This seems plausible.
How about older people not having the health required to fight the infection?
"It turns out that [amyloid-beta proteins] form [plaques] because they're trying to help us. They're trying to fight an infection," said Robert Moir, an assistant professor of neurobiology at Harvard Medical School and the Massachusetts General Hospital.
"The Alzheimer's disease dementia that comes after years of this battle, are something like collateral damage from their actions. But it's not that it's intrinsically bad what they're doing. It's just that if you keep doing it for long enough the amyloid that is generated in this battle starts to become a problem in itself."
If this theory, which Moir outlines in a review article published in the December issue of the journal Alzheimer's & Dementia, proves true, it could mean researchers' current strategies to combat the disease — fighting the plaques — is misguided.
https://www.cbc.ca/radio/quirks/dec-8-2018-why-are-users-tak...
The antimicrobial protection hypothesis of Alzheimer's disease:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S155252601...