Nietzsche is by no means an individualist. He had no interest in any current of thought talking of "individualism". Moreover, while he was no doubt interested in certain individuals, he made it clear that the individuals he was interested were the product of entire cultures - the most refined possible people.
Nietzsche also essentially produced a position that was impossible to realize. Indeed, no one can practically agree with Nietzsche on everything. He wanted an elite but wanted that elite to be aesthetic and removed from ugly character of politics as usual. He hated antisemites and militarists yet these were the most common type to take up his name.
Still, I'd certainly agree Nietzsche is interesting and worth reading.
Edit: Also important is the way Nietzsche refuted the certainties of philosophy yet did not consider himself a philosopher. He called himself a "psychologist" early on and his discussion of philosophy was often "what character would cause a person to believe such a thing".
Moreover, I don't think Nietzsche advocated that everyone think independently. Following the "order of rank" logic, he might advocate that those of a higher order think for themselves (but even he's concerned with what is healthy for the individual, not what opens the person's mind the most). He'd not want free thinking for those of a lower order of rank (something that indeed doesn't paint ole Fred in the best light).
Do you recall where he wrote that? I only read Zarathustra and I do not recall those thoughts in there.
He was an individualist and he wasn't interested in any current of thought, talking of individualism or not.
But the tendencies calling themselves "individualist" like Stirner, say, evoked only contempt in him (and basically little mention).
I don't think he had any preference for political systems, except, like you said, as a way to create interesting individuals.
Indeed, Nietzsche didn't even "believe in thinking for yourself" in the sense that he didn't think that random people should necessarily be encourage to do so.
While I, as I've said, I think no one can really embrace all of Nietzsche, I'm fond enough of some of him to want to point out how he denounced all those types that would love to evoke his name - the precursors of the NAZIs, anarchists and all philosophies glorifying "the individual" and so-forth. Not the Nietzsche would have embrace my own ideas but then again, I don't carry his "banner".
Do you remember where those comments are? Never heard of them.
While I, as I've said, I think no one can really embrace all of Nietzsche
Indeed. He seems more of a critic than a creator, still he had many original ideas, maybe because he didn't feel the need to create a coherent system, that would have forced him to discard some.
he denounced all those types that would love to evoke his name - the precursors of the NAZIs, anarchists and all philosophies glorifying "the individual" and so-forth
Were they sincerely individualists? First image that comes to mind when mentioning nazis is a bunch of uniformed people marching in perfect formation.
"They are no philosophical race, these Englishmen: Bacon signifies an attack on the philosophical spirit; Hobbes, Hume, and Locke a debasement and lowering of the value of the concept of “philosophy” for more than a century. It was against Hume that Kant arose, and rose; it was Locke of whom Schelling said, understandably, “je méprise Locke” [I despise Locke]; in their fight against the English-mechanistic doltification of the world, Hegel and Schopenhauer were of one mind (with Goethe)—these two hostile brother geniuses in philosophy who strove apart toward opposite poles of the German spirit and in the process wronged each other as only brothers wrong each other."
https://www.reddit.com/r/Nietzsche/comments/a7btg5/nietzsche...
He does so because they fail to understand that language is something historical that is fought over and changes over time. Thus his aphorism that 'only that which has no history can be defined.'
Though the interpretation doesn't hang on Nietzsche explicitly adopting the label 'psychologist', but in the substance of his philosophy.
“Who among the philosophers before me was in any way a psychologist? Before me there simply was no psychology” (Ecce Homo page 93)
I can and I will, but why is a source needed?
This is a pretty well studied aspect of Nietzsche (lots of books, papers, critique of later philosophers on the matter etc), and it's evidently true even in parts of his works where he doesn't openly talk about psychology (ie. you don't need to openly name a thing to practice it).
If people have read Nietzsche, they would have witnessed his affinity for psychological examination of philosophy, morality etc. If they haven't, I don't see why would they need a pointer to such a source. What use would that be if they have not read the rest of Nietzsche?
I'm saying this because to me the request sounds like either "I know Nietzsche and don't believe you, where's the proof?", or "I couldn't be bothered to read Nietzsche, but don't believe you anyway, where's the proof", both of which I find problematic (the first because I don't believe someone can read Nietzsche and miss this aspect, and the second because it's a little lazy and insulting).
For me such a request would make sense if it was for a controversial and not well known aspect of someone's philosophy. E.g. "Where does Marx say socialism is possible in a non-industrialized country". But not something well known, like "Where does Marx say he is in favor of workers over capitalists?". If someone doesn't know the latter already, then a reference seems moot. They can just read a 101 on the subject.
In any case, here are some references from "Beyond Good and Evil" and "Ecce Homo":
"Never yet did a PROFOUNDER world of insight reveal itself to daring travelers and adventurers, and the psychologist who thus "makes a sacrifice"—it is not the sacrifizio dell' intelletto, on the contrary!—will at least be entitled to demand in return that psychology shall once more be recognized as the queen of the sciences, for whose service and equipment the other sciences exist. For psychology is once more the path to the fundamental problems".
"In that the NEW psychologist is about to put an end to the superstitions which have hitherto flourished with almost tropical luxuriance around the idea of the soul, he is really, as it were, thrusting himself into a new desert and a new distrust"
"Wherever sympathy (fellow-suffering) is preached nowadays—and, if I gather rightly, no other religion is any longer preached—let the psychologist have his ears open through all the vanity, through all the noise which is natural to these preachers (as to all preachers), he will hear a hoarse, groaning, genuine note of SELF-CONTEMPT."
And in case in these it's not clear that he speaks of what he does and himself, because he frequently does so in the third person, even though the overal book and context makes it evident, here are some more:
"What man, before my time, had descended into the underground caverns from out of which the poisonous fumes of this ideal—of this slandering of the world—burst forth? What man had even dared to suppose that they were underground caverns? Was a single one of the philosophers who preceded me a psychologist at all, and not the very reverse of a psychologist—that is to say, a "superior swindler," an "Idealist"? Before my time there was no psychology. To be the first in this new realm may amount to a curse; at all events, it is a fatality: for one is also the first to despise".
Or how about a boast of being the biggest psychologist:
"The fact that the voice which speaks in my works is that of a psychologist who has not his peer, is perhaps the first conclusion at which a good reader will arrive".
Ice
Yes! I manufacture ice:
Ice may help you to digest.
If you had much to digest,
how you would enjoy my ice!
Nietzche's poetry is an underappreciated component of his philosophy.What edition should I read? So I stayed true to the early thinkers that interpreted him (to not be fooled by thinkers like Steven Pinker who trash him).
Off topic: for a moment I considered learning German just to really understand this man.
Considering a philosophical model a logically interconnected and consistent system of assumptions, rejecting some of the assumptions/propositions can be an indication that the entire model is to be rejected even if other assumptions seem acceptable.
Even math couldn't be that, despite the efforts of Hilbert, Russel, and co.
In the case of Nietzsche in particular, he scoffs at philosophers pretending theirs to be one.
He offers observations, and individual ones, jumping from one to another, and doesn't pretend to offer a model.
But even for those philosophers that do think their work is a "logically interconnected and consistent system", you can still have perfectly good (or, perfectly useful) parts of their overall system, while others might be wrong.
He was a stark individualist that put into question a lot of the building blocks of liberal democracy, such as the notion that all men are equal. I don't agree with all of what he puts forth but he is without a doubt one of the most dynamic and influential thinkers of the 19th century and still relevant to read even today.
If you're interested in reading him, start with Twilight of the Idols and Beyond Good and Evil. If you like those two then you can delve into some of his other work such as the Antichrist, On the Geneaology of Morals, Human, All Too Human, and Thus Spoke Zarathustra