Might be wrong and misinterpreting.
Did everyone who originally downvoted the "epic fail" post realise the context and just not like jokes on HN, or did a couple of people choose to downvote, and then more people see what looked like a Reddit-esque joke that was being downvoted and just join in without understanding the point of the post?
As others pointed out, a similar mentality could explain the results on the Yelp page we are discussing, even if the entire thing was actually orchestrated by a competitor and/or triggered by a single unhappy customer where we don't know the full story.
On HN, I downvote that comment.
On Reddit, I leave it alone or perhaps upvote it.
On Slashdot, I probably make the joke myself if I'm the first one to get to it.
I appreciate HN's "no class clowns" tone, as I can (and do) easily get my fill of that elsewhere.
That was sort of the point of the comment. :)
People should be less edgy...