Re:Ethiopian Airlines 737 MAX Investigation Preliminary Report
by robryan on Thursday April 04, 2019 @04:33PM
(#19576808)
What about a single button to turn MCAS off and return to trim to a neutral position? Or a setting where the pilot is telling the system to ignore the sensor input.
Maybe a bit like a self driving car planes will eventually have a system where they can use visual markers as a check on what sensors are reporting.
Re:Ethiopian Airlines 737 MAX Investigation Preliminary Report
by javagram on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:01PM
(#19577071)
Indeed there are many ways to design this better.
The 737 max was designed to not be any different to fly than previous 737s, so adding a button to disable this system was not allowed as I understand it.
As these two tragic accidents have made clear that specification was pretty wrongheaded...
Re:Ethiopian Airlines 737 MAX Investigation Preliminary Report
by fgonzag on Thursday April 04, 2019 @05:28PM
(#19577308)
Seriously, a MCAS indicator light (if MCAS is actively issuing commands), a big red button below it called "Disable MCAS" , and a MCAS disabled light (so pilots actually remember when it is disabled) should be more than enough to prevent this.
Besides adding the AoA disagree light AND having MCAS use a triple AoA sensor vote to determine the AoA angle.
Re:Ethiopian Airlines 737 MAX Investigation Preliminary Report
by cjbprime on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:23PM
(#19578120)
I think they're not gonna do that because they'd lose the 737 type.
The faulty AoA sensor is causing the plane to think it’s about to stall and therefore MCAS works as designed to prevent the pilot from putting the plane into a stall.
Of course the design is wrong because the plane is actually pointing toward the ground and MCAS thinks it’s pointing to the sky...