News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Editing in an age of outrage by Aloha on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @02:00PM (#19565592)
"Silencing people we don’t like will make it easier for others to silence the people we do."

I think this is the entire message of this article, and its one I wholeheartedly agree with too - suppression of speech, be it governmental or by internet mobs is detrimental to a free society.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by bduerst on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @03:21PM (#19566373)
What do you think about Popper's paradox? The reason I ask is because even the philosophers behind free speech didn't see it as a blank check for every expression, and agreed that there are situations where a free society benefited from speech being curtailed.
Re:Editing in an age of outrage by deogeo on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @04:13PM (#19566867)
Paradox of tolerance? I think it's built on shaky foundations at best. It assumes that tolerance is the highest value, to which other values (e.g. free speech) can be sacrificed, if necessary. If you value freedom of speech higher, you would not make that sacrifice.

Second, it's doubtful that allowing intolerant speech makes a society intolerant. After all, the society became tolerant when intolerant speech was allowed and accepted - why would this process now reverse itself?

And if it did reverse itself, perhaps there's a good reason for it - perhaps voters aren't happy with the fruits tolerance bore. It's a bit undemocratic to say that free speech philosophers know best how a society should be structured, and if the populace disagrees, they'll be censored until only permitted ideas may be expressed.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by anoncake on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:04PM (#19567255)
Free speech is tolerance of other opinions.

> why would this process now reverse itself?

Are you trying to argue that the process never does reverse itself? Because that does happen.

> And if it did reverse itself, perhaps there's a good reason for it - perhaps voters aren't happy with the fruits tolerance bore. It's a bit undemocratic to say that free speech philosophers know best how a society should be structured, and if the populace disagrees, they'll be censored until only permitted ideas may be expressed.

Thats what the makers of the Weimar Constitution thought.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by deogeo on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:41PM (#19567475)
> Are you trying to argue that the process never does reverse itself? Because that does happen.

It does, but it is not guaranteed to - not even close. So to claim a tolerant society can't exist without censorship is reaching.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by anoncake on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:54PM (#19567559)
Maybe a tolerant society can exist without censorship. But censorship is no the only way not to tolerate intolerance. If advocating against free speech makes you a pariah, then society does not tolerate intolerance even though it is legal.

Another possibility is that there are other mechanisms that can protect tolerance, such as a constitution that is very hard to change. The paradox of tolerance would not apply to societies that have such a mechanism, but still would be valid for others.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by Aloha on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:56PM (#19567911)
I'd argue there is a fundamental difference between tolerating intolerant thought and tolerating violent (or even pseudo-violent) acts. People will always have intolerant thoughts, they may not however, ever take that to violent actions.
Re:Editing in an age of outrage by anoncake on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @07:25PM (#19568085)
We cant ban intolerant thoughts whether we want to or not since we cannot read peoples minds. Besides people cant just change their believes at will.

The question is what we do about intolerant speech.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by Aloha on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:30AM (#19569321)
Basically all intolerant speech should be allowed, so long as you're not trying to call people to arms to act on that speech - the speech itself probably doesn't matter much.

I'd rather be able to spot the hateful people, than not know who they are and let them act on their hate in silence.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by bduerst on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:47PM (#19575092)
>Basically all intolerant speech should be allowed, so long as you're not trying to call people to arms to act on that speech

So all intolerant speech should be allowed, except for this speech that shouldn't be tolerated?

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by Aloha on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:38PM (#19575676)
Generally, yes, provided you're not calling people to action, presenting an imminent and present threat, it certainly should be allowed.

I have as much trouble with the government banning speech as I do with people getting doxed for saying something unpopular.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by Aloha on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:52PM (#19567888)
Free Speech isn't a blank check - there are limits - even in the United States we have well defined limits on speech - most critically we limit speech that is a 'imminent call to lawlessness'. I'd like to broaden the limits on speech some, specifically to cover doxing and incitement of online harassment - its a balancing test between free speech and civility, and I fear we are on the wrong side of this currently.

Saying something unpopular, but non-threat provoking shouldn't give your opponents carte blanche to do whatever they like.

Re:Editing in an age of outrage by bduerst on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @07:11PM (#19568009)
Right, makes sense. You made it sound like any suppression of free speech (i.e. by gov't or mob or whatever) was detrimental to a free society, when there are some forms of speech that should be curtailed (and not based on opinion either).