A requirement that it must be commonly and reasonably purchaseable as stand-alone content on some reasonable schedule wouldn't necessarily be out of line. "You want to win an award, you must put it out in a format that it can be legally archived outside of your particular walled garden. We're not willing to give an award to a movie that may not be available in 50 years."
You know how at the end of every movie it has that MPAA registration number? The only way to get that is to submit a copy of the film to the MPAA for archiving. So they have a copy of every film. If the movie studio ceases to exist, they still have at least one copy.
I'm not in the movie business at all, so I'm just a regular person, but I guess what I'm saying is, in 50 years, why do I have to just take the Academy's word that Film X is good? They'd be saying, "Trust us. We have a copy of it, and we've seen it. It's one of the best films ever." Which is fine. But why can't I get it and judge for myself? Why can't I get it show it to some friends and neighbors and talk about it? It's a legitimate issue in my view.
Netflix is selling tickets for like ten bucks to see Roma for a whole month.
The Louvre has a ticket for about $20. Here in the Chicago area, you can visit the Art Institute for $14, MOMA in New York is $25.
I guess the Smithsonian is free, but that's just my tax dollars already spent, really. ;)
I'm not in a position to find out right now or for the next several hours, so, open question to the house: do Netflix's in-house movies have those numbers already?
That's slightly different, because a customer could assume that eventually they could purchase a physical copy of a film. Neither Disney and Netflix were/are being customer-friendly here. If I want a physical copy of a TV show or film they created, I should be allowed to buy it.
Cannes’ festival makes it an actual requirement to be shown in theaters, and I think it discredit lot of the prestige that it had, now that truely excelent pieces are tv only or streaming only. All the more so, showing in theatres has legal ramifications that go beyond art and movie making.
You see "ability for the public to see this movie in X years" as important for cinema.
Steven Spielberg sees "ability for the public to see this movie in a theatre" (at some point) as important for cinema.
Both are valid criteria.
However, if you believe that the theatre experience is critical to a film, I think it's also fair to be annoyed at what Netflix is doing. Only a select few have the ability to see Netflix's films in a theatre, because they're only released to a couple theatres in a handful of major cities.
That was the default for decades in film. Film schools had personal libraries students would schedule time to use. Home video changed that (which was fought against by the industry) and the original DVD Netflix changed that again for rare movies. I can see how that would affect your emotions but it has had little/no effect with the Academy Awards.
I actually think Spielberg would be ok with not allowing Apple, either. Years ago, when iTunes and iPod video started getting films, Spielberg said something like, "I didn't create these movies to be viewed on a tiny screen."
I haven't followed this too closely, but I get where Spielberg is coming from--although, I dunno if I agree with him that Emmys are better suited for Netflix (they have their own agenda). The Academy was built for the betterment of theatrical feature film. The whole point of the Academy Awards is to promote feature film. If Netflix is just doing the minimum to gain credibility for something that's not feature films, I can see why the Academy is not cool with that.
>I actually think Spielberg would be ok with not allowing Apple, either. Years ago, when iTunes and iPod video started getting films, Spielberg said something like, "I didn't create these movies to be viewed on a tiny screen."
So, in future movies he required a rider on the studio contract that they'd never be released on mobile phone or tablet platforms? He restricted himself to indie movies where he could ensure this artistic purity now that he has unlimited wealth to rest on?
Yes.
“Once you commit to a television format, you’re a TV movie,” he told ITV News in March 2018. “You certainly, if it’s a good show, deserve an Emmy, but not an Oscar. I don’t believe films that are just given token qualifications in a couple of theaters for less than a week should qualify for the Academy Award nomination.”
Spielberg has produced many TV series and TV movies and has won 4 Emmy Awards.
But that's not the thing Spielberg, et. al. are saying disqualifies them. It's this vague idea that it's a "TV format" and something about amount of time in theaters:
> “Once you commit to a television format, you’re a TV movie. You certainly, if it’s a good show, deserve an Emmy, but not an Oscar,” he said at the time. “I don’t believe films that are just given token qualifications in a couple of theaters for less than a week should qualify for the Academy Award nomination.”
I don't have much sympathy for Netflix since you can't acquire a standalone copy of most of their content (TV yes, but I believe to date they've yet to release an original movie on physical media) - you must subscribe to watch the videos. They sort of release in theaters, sometimes, whenever they feel like it, but the majority of their content is locked into their platform. I feel like Netflix would love for there to be zero requirements to show their movies in theaters.
On the other side though, Spielberg is well invested into Hollywood production, and it seems clear that he wants the Academy to shut out a huge competitor. For some reason, I don't take anything he's saying as genuine concern of film.
EDIT: I just thought about it. I feel like he's possibly trying to protect standard exclusivity agreements. Check out a related story when Netflix started a simultaneous release agreement with IPic: https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/envelope/cotown/la-et-...
The movie industry relies on theaters (and then royalties/physical media sales to a lesser extent) to make money on their content. The theater industry wants exclusive release windows. Netflix doesn't have either of these problems, and that's a threat to the standard business model of the movie industry. So I feel like that's why he's trying to push for a staggered release for Netflix, so that Netflix has to be encumbered by the same business model he deals with.