Facebook and Instagram feel different to me just because people tend to use them in more personal ways. But, again, if you plan to make the data public anywhere it can always be gobbled up by spiders and three-letter agencies.
If Facebook, Twitter, Instagram etc were to actually charge fees for the cost of running the services without the advertising/data harvesting cover, I wonder how 'valuable' the perception would remain...
But suppose you did want to publish your content. For instance I make videos about tech and programming that I enjoy sharing with others and getting feedback on, so I post them on YouTube. Some people like to do that with their selfies or political commentary. To me that's all fine as long as they understand that it's no longer private.
The bigger privacy violations, imo, are the hidden ones. The web trackers, IoT data collection, location services, conversation metadata, etc. These are situations where it's not "public" like YouTube or Twitter, but it sure isn't private either.
Does an amateur baker have to have a stall at the farmers' market, an amateur knitter have to have an Etsy store?
Nothing wrong with just taking photos for the love of it (literally the definition of amateur) and sharing them with your friends because you think they'll appreciate them. Not every hobby has to be taken up with so much effort it's like a second job.
You've not understood what the word amateur means, at all. It's like suggesting an amateur tennis player doesn't care if he isn't trying to play Wimbledon. Or an amateur runner doesn't care if he isn't top 5% of marathon.
Do you not have hobbies or something?
Different people use platforms in different ways.
What else did you evaluate?
Many people feel compelled to remain on Facebook because they're afraid of missing out on events that get scheduled through Facebook. But here is what I discovered: people who like you will go out of their way to make sure you get the invitation, even if that means using something barbaric and old fashioned like a phone number or email address. FOMO is probably Facebook's most valuable asset, but it's largely unjustified.
Yeah, but sometimes you want to get invited by people who don't actually like you enough (or even know you well enough) to remember you're not on Facebook.
I'm not on FB, but I know of multiple local groups discussing issues and organizing meetings on private FB groups, which would be hard to participate in without an account.