News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen band... by pilom on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @05:13PM (#1955797)
Lots of people seem to be forgetting that content providers want to connect to customers just as much as the customers want the content.

Comcast:"L3 you want to connect to all my cable customers fast and you don't want to pay even more to get to me through AT&T so lets make a deal."

It makes perfect sense that Comcast should be paid for access to their customers.

Re:Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen band... by jordan0day on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @05:39PM (#1955879)
"It makes perfect sense that Comcast should be paid for access to their customers." I disagree, heartily. Comcast's customers are paying Comcast for access to the entire internet, not just to the little segment of the network that Comcast owns.
Re:Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen band... by boredguy8 on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @06:15PM (#1955999)
Exactly this, especially in markets where there isn't consumer choice (which is something I don't see anyone talking about on HN).

Conceivably an ISP could charge customers for a connection AND charge providers for access to that base. For instance, magazines charge for both the subscription and the advertisements.

However, I can decide if I want Harper's or US Weekly. If one provides value and the other doesn't, I get to pick. With ISPs, the same feature isn't at play: I either use Road Runner or I don't get high-speed bandwidth. At that point, ISPs have a larger obligation to protect the customers by not doing things like what Comcast is doing.

Re:Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen band... by brown9-2 on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @07:53PM (#1956316)
And the bullshit part about this is that most of Comcast's customers have little choice in being a customer. They're trapped and have no ability to choose.
Re:Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen band... by anonymous246 on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @05:32PM (#1955864)
Even though Comcast customers already pay Comcast to receive those bytes? As others have pointed out above.
Re:Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen band... by spindritf on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @05:43PM (#1955899)
Paid magazines often still sell advertising space, same is true for paid cable channels, so it's not unheard of to charge both the "broadcaster" and the "receiver".
Re:Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen band... by jordan0day on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @05:59PM (#1955946)
But that is a model in which the advertises is "subsidizing" the effective cost to the end user. (Whether or not it's an actual subsidy or just a nice bit of profit for the cable network/provider is anyone's guess.)

Obviously, without legislation, the internet will end up being no different, with Comcast, AT&T, and ultimately high-traffic sites like espn.com nickel-and-diming each other and end users. Sticking to the principles on which the web was (allegedly?) founded doesn't hold much water in a shareholders meeting.

I hate to sound so cynical and resigned to this fate, but left to their own devices this seems like exactly what the big ISP's and sites will do.

Re:Level 3 outbid Akamai on Netflix by reselling stolen band... by pilom on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:16AM (#1966089)
I agree that it is very easy for this to lead to a bad situation for customers. But that subsidizing model still applies. You know how much it costs to connect a cable line to a house? That wiring costs 100s-1000s of dollars per house (why FioS went to apartment buildings first). Of course the end users are getting subsidies.