If the share price falls over the lockup period, employees end up owing tax at a share price higher than they are able to sell. Some of that is usually offset by the company withholding some of the released shares for taxes, but the current withholding rate is substantially under most engineers' marginal tax bracket. It amounts to a ~10% extra tax penalty on the share decline.
RSUs are withheld at Federal bonus rates, which seemed pretty reasonable (it's 25% until your total taxable comp from an employer hits $1M in the tax year, and then it jumps to 39.6%); and California equity statutory rates, which is the second to top marginal rate, which works out right, unless you made enough to pay the mental health tax.
Although, given that state tax isn't deductible anymore, perhaps 25% isn't nearly enough at the federal level anymore?
Realistically, since the standard deduction is way more than SALT deduction plus the maximum mortgage deduction, few people are going to end up deducting those, unless they've made a lot of charitable contributions or had a lot of medical expenses in a given year.
The analysis of 2018 tax return trends is going to be very interesting.
Here is an 60-minute interview, in 1999. The journalist/expert made the same argument as in your graphic, that a software company is overvalued because its market cap is higher than traditional companies
https://youtu.be/VuI-ss5aQU8?t=629
the interviewer literally laughed at how Amazon is overvalued, because its stock price was worth 20% MORE than a real company like Sears. Your graphic uses the same logic as that interviewer did in 1999.
But I'll note that for every Amazon there's dozens or more Pets.com. So, yes, maybe Lyft is the next trillion dollar company -- or maybe it's, you know, a cab company.
You can argue that Lyft will become Pets.com, due to other reasons, such as growth potential etc. That would make sense.
BUT, the argument in your graphic, that a company is overvalued simply because its valuation is higher than traditional well-known brands, that ARGUMENT is flawed.
Lyft's valuation is totally independent of Ford's valuation. These are separate companies with separate paths. Amazon's valuation was not tied to Sears--the 60-minutes journalist made the mistake of connecting the 2 together. The argument behind your graphic is wrong.
"I found this simple graphic a great distillation of why Lyft and Uber may be considered overvalued"
If Lyft becomes the next Pets.com and goes bust, its stock would be worth $0. If that happened, it would be laughable to say that Lyft is under-valued, simply because Ford is valued in the billions.
Ford's valuation has nothing to do with how Lyft is valued. To say that Lyft is over/under valued because Ford has X valuation, like what your graphic is saying, makes no sense at all.
And that's the most simplified model possible. If you have a 1/1000 chance of being worth a trillion dollars, you may also have a 10/1000 chance of being worth ten billion dollars, 100/1000 chance of being worth one billion dollars, and 200/1000 chance of being worth 100 million dollars. That adds $220 million of expected value. You can add another couple million if you account for the company still having liquefiable assets even in the case that it ends up folding like Pets.com (which ended up returning at least a few million dollars to their shareholders: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1100683/000089161802...).
For example, the graphic includes both Delta and American Airlines as well as Jetblue. Airlines are effectively a zero-margin business for some interesting reasons (https://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines). You might say, so are Uber and Lyft, but airlines have a static business model that hasn't changed for decades, can't fundamentally change because it's regulated within inches of its life even after "deregulation", and Delta and American have no real room for growth.
Ford isn't really even comparable. It's a car manufacturer. At least airlines transport people from point A to point B. Likewise for Embraer, which manufactures jets.
Royal Caribbean is a cruise line, which puts it more in the "leisure" sector than the "transportation" sector. (Can you expense Uber or Lyft for work? Yes. Can you expense airline tickets? Yes. Can you expense a Royal Caribbean cruise? Not likely.)
And that leaves a shipping company and a car rental company, which are at least in the same ballpark as airlines in that they're basically logistics companies (with an optional customer service component), but Uber and Lyft are different from these in that Uber and Lyft don't have to manage the physical capital.
Do I still think Uber and Lyft are likely overvalued? Honestly, yes, and that's why I don't buy them. Am I shocked that Lyft is approximately as valuable as Delta Airlines? Not at all.
Also, that graphic doesn’t make Uber and Lyft seem all that overvalued - does it really seem unusual for Lyft to do as well financially as Delta?
Delta's operations threw off $7 billion of cash in their FYE 2018 [1]; Lyft's burned over $280 million [2]. In the same period, Delta's net income was almost $4 billion [a] while Lyft lost over $900 million.
Lyft is not doing as well financially as Delta. Instead, its investors are betting that it will--in the future--do much better than Delta is doing today.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/27904/000002... page 56
[a] page 54
[2] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1759509/000119312519... F-8
[b] F-4
This of course depends on when they sell, or sold!
... not really? Most of those folks are locked out for several more months and can't sell -- at which point the stock may suffer increased selling pressure, much like Snap. These folks are no more successful now than they were a week ago.
Also the IPO price was $72 -- and Lyft is selling at $69 right now, so, no, the institutions that bought the IPO are not having a windfall at present. (But now I see this article was published Friday, before today's continued decline, so I see why this made it past the fact checkers.)
I found this simple graphic a great distillation of why Lyft and Uber may be considered overvalued:
https://i.imgur.com/z1aCZaX.png