Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos...
by KKKKkkkk1 on Monday April 01, 2019 @01:05AM
(#19540653)
I like the analogy of the internet. In order to have the internet, we have packet switching, retransmissions, flow control with exponential backoff, distributed spanning tree algorithms, etc. If we accept what the AI proponents say, the internet is a jumbled mess of conflicting hand-crafted rules that has no chance of ever working. And yet here we are on the internet, and we don't even need a Go or chess solver running in each router.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos...
by nradov on Monday April 01, 2019 @01:27AM
(#19540734)
You're making a strawman argument and I have no idea which AI proponents you're referring to. Internet routers mostly rely on deterministic non-conflicting rules with little or no AI involved. It generally works fine, although there are multiple major failures every year.
How much large scale network engineering have you done?
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos...
by carlmr on Monday April 01, 2019 @08:16AM
(#19542522)
>Internet routers mostly rely on deterministic non-conflicting rules
Exponential backoff (which the previous poster mentioned) is randomized and success is by definition non-deterministic algorithm to resolve conflicting usage. It works very well, and is very simple. But deterministic and non-conflicting are really not qualities that the IP protocol is known for.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos...
by adontz on Monday April 01, 2019 @01:12AM
(#19540671)
And sometimes networks go down, but nobody dies.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos...
by rhacker on Monday April 01, 2019 @02:57PM
(#19546815)
That is what my retort was going to be. The stakes are a lot higher when it's a human at 65 mph.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos...
by nisse72 on Monday April 01, 2019 @01:24AM
(#19540722)
And packet collisions are not unusual. But then you simply wait a short time, and try again.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos...
by zimpenfish on Monday April 01, 2019 @05:02AM
(#19541621)
10 Drive forwards a bit
20 Stop
30 Did we hit something?
35 YES: Sleep for a short time
40 GOTO 10