News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by epo on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @08:02AM (#1953948)
The broken window fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window as a parable was new to me. A good debunking of the justification that all this security activity is a net economic benefit to the US.
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by NeilCJames on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @01:02PM (#1954947)
I read that comment too, but I am not sure 'broken windows' truly applies here. Although I believe there is net public harm from US post-9/11 "security" policies, when you consider that: a.) the spending being done on security is entirely public deficit spending not offset by tax increases or cuts in other departments, b.) the economy has been well below full employment (~58-62% employment-pop ratio during the period) and full capacity utilization (~68-81% capacity utilization during the period), c.) no other expansion of public employment and spending would have likely occurred in the past decade absent the 9/11 attacks (arguable, but there really isn't a political consensus for expanding the US welfare state), and posit that the 2000s growth rate would have taken essentially the same path absent the 9/11 attacks, then it would appear that much of the security theater policies have had a small medium-term stimulative economic effect (small because it is largely offset by increased consumer travelling expenses and time, dampening productivity). The three keys I mention above violate the pretext of the broken window fallacy (at least in the medium term, and probably in the long-term because of historically low interest rates). In a full employment situation, there would be significant deadweight loss, and in a balanced budget situation, there would be significant economic impact due to either increased taxation or offsetting spending cuts. But neither of those conditions applies to the recent US situation. The BWF assumes that the money would have been spent doing something else (more profitable), and I am pretty certain that will not be the case until the debt needs to be paid, which is unlikely to ever occur (I think the assumed future policy is to continue to roll the debt over until the singularity).
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by nir on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @11:11AM (#1954517)
John Robb has been writing about these kind of tactics for a while, he calls it "Open Source Warfare": http://globalguerrillas.typepad.com/globalguerrillas/2010/11...
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by 3pt14159 on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @10:10AM (#1954274)
For a long time I've debated writing an article in a similar vein of this one by Schneier. I studied structural engineering in University and you would not believe how easy and cheap it is. With a solid iron pipe and the right knowledge you can kill hundreds of people and delay hundreds of thousands.
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by daeken on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @11:53AM (#1954698)
For the longest time, I thought about terrorism from a security standpoint. If you treat the US as a system to break, then you see a lot of weak points: bridges, trains, malls, etc (in other words, the stuff you see on 24). If you damage these, you could do a whole lot of damage to the US economy, kill a lot of people, etc. But then I realized something: destroying bridges doesn't cause fear in the same way that, say, flying a plane into a landmark building does.

I used to think that the terrorists were idiots that couldn't pull off a simple attack... now I realize just how good they are at what they do: causing fear. The point of terrorism isn't to kill, it isn't to cause direct harm in any way. Those are tools to make us scared, and we've all played right into it. I'll never forget exactly where I was when I found out about the attacks on 9/11, or any of the resulting protection mechanisms; they succeeded in their goals, probably more than they ever thought they would.

Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by hugh3 on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @02:02PM (#1955170)
I think it's a mistake to lump all terrorists into one group. Different terrorist groups have very differing goals, moral systems, and levels of sanity.

The IRA, for instance, while an evil bunch of fuckers, would never attempt to kill thousands of people in a single attack, because they had clear and fairly realistic political goals and a strategy for pursuing them.

Islamic terrorists, on the other hand, for the most part appear to just like killing -- it's not too much of an exaggeration to say that their goal is more or less the genocide of every non-Muslim on the planet, and individually their goal is to die for Allah. This gives them a very different set of priorities to old-school terrorist groups like the IRA or ETA.

To summarize: the IRA wants to terrorise you to achieve a goal, but Al Qaeda pretty much just wants to kill you.

Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by chc on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @02:54PM (#1955351)
Then why have their attacks so far had the primary effect of creating panic when a couple dozen random bombs would both be easier to execute and cause more destruction? Why continue to attack planes — the area in which our paranoia is most concentrated — when legions of American-born madmen have proven that just pulling out a gun in a public place and shooting people is plenty effective?

It seems to me that they don't necessarily want us to die, at least not on any particular schedule — just to be so afraid that we won't be able to oppose them with any strength.

Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by metageek on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @02:15PM (#1955220)
A disturbing thought: if we were sensible about the risks, and refused to be unreasonably afraid, we might see greater loss of life, as the terrorists would have to kill more people to make us afraid.
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by forza on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @01:54PM (#1955151)
I can't help to think that if the US people, media and government hadn't been so busy "fighting terrorism", then events like hurricane Katrina, the BP oil spill, subprime mortgage crisis and the following recession could, if not have been avoided, at least been handled a lot better.
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by daeken on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @02:42PM (#1955312)
I think it's a serious stretch to say that, coming from someone who sees the "war on terrorism" as completely silly. Those "fighting terrorism" aren't the same people doing, say, banking oversight. While these things are both handled by the government, the government is not all one big team, it's a bunch of individual components working on totally different things with small amounts of overlap.
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by forza on Wednesday December 01, 2010 @05:17AM (#1957426)
I agree it's somewhat of a stretch, but not completely irrelevant. I don't mean on an individual level, but more the overall political climate. For instance George W. Bush might not have been re-elected if it wasn't for the wars. I think it pretty safe to say that the "war on terrorism" has effected America in more ways than the obvious ones, but it is of course very hard to say how or how much.
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by rimantas on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @02:29PM (#1955255)
I was going to recommend the paper „The Psychology of Security“, so I googled for it. It was fun to see, what results were (I did not remember the author) :)
Re:Causing Terror on the Cheap by InclinedPlane on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @04:03PM (#1955572)
Terrorism is just guerrilla warfare against civilians and infrastructure. The goal is to get the most bang for the buck from cheap attacks.