News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by copperx on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:34PM (#19538186)
Perhaps an easier and quicker fix (although extremely costly) is to outfit all roadways with aids for autonomous driving. Otherwise, we will have to wait decades for the technology to be mature enough.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by hrktb on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:20PM (#19538474)
I wonder though if the roadway maintenance would be good enough to have that work reliably. The car would still have to react to misconfigured , misplaced or defective aids.

Even if it’s not just negligeance, if an accident were to move the markers, would it cascade accidents until these markers are fixed ?

In the end, it seems we’d still need cars way clever than what we have now for it to be trustworthy.

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by bobthepanda on Sunday March 31, 2019 @06:18PM (#19538797)
The fatal Tesla crash into a highway barrier a while back was because of faded highway markings.

Many localities can barely keep the lines painted. Many more have all sorts of adverse weather conditions (e.g., snow and slush) that make road markings hard to see. The chances of this being a workable solution, at least in the US, is nil.

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by nikofeyn on Sunday March 31, 2019 @06:57PM (#19538997)
that crash wasn’t because of the markings. saying so, although maybe accurate, softens the issue. it was because tesla has a poor autonomous system that couldn’t plainly see a road splitting and instead hit a barrier at full speed wit no braking. the markers were a contributor since all teslas seem to mainly do is stay between the lines they see.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by sorenjan on Sunday March 31, 2019 @07:30PM (#19539174)
No tech that requires a special type of road will ever get successful, whether it's aids for autonomous driving aids, electric roads for on the go charging, or similar. The world already have countless of kilometers of roads, and all you need to drive a regular car is a relatively hard and flat piece of dirt. The cost and time required would be immense, and there will always be a need to use cars outside any built up road network.

Sure, for commuting in large cities anything is possible, but then cars still need to be able to do both old an new navigation.

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by weregiraffe on Monday April 01, 2019 @02:17AM (#19540955)
>No tech that requires a special type of road will ever get successful

I'm reading this from inside a train.

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by glenneroo on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:33PM (#19545111)
Trams are also very popular in Europe and cars can still drive on roads with tram tracks.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by mrguyorama on Monday April 01, 2019 @03:34PM (#19547237)
Notice how few miles of train tracks there are in comparison to roadways.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by imtringued on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @09:21AM (#19553739)
That's exactly why trains are not as successful as cars.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by copperx on Monday April 01, 2019 @01:02AM (#19540637)
It doesn't have to be an all-or-nothing proposition. For example, just augmenting interstate highways to enable reliable autonomous driving would be a complete game changer for commerce, let alone personal use.

Let the driver drive the car manually for the last mile of travel. Most of the problems of autonomous driving are on the last mile (pedestrians, unmarked roads, poor lighting, school crossings, train crossings, etc.). The last mile is the most expensive to outfit and maintain, too.

I wouldn't be disappointed at all to find that in the future, cars drive by themselves 80% of the time, and humans take over for the tricky 20%. If the roadway isn't autonomous-ready the car shouldn't become a brick. You just drive it manually.

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by CaptainZapp on Monday April 01, 2019 @03:52AM (#19541351)
Who pays for that?

You would either have to add massive taxes to road usage (not just gas), heavily tax automobile ownership or use general purpose taxes for such very expensive upgrades.

As a non-owner of a car I would balk at the last option.

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by copperx on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:50AM (#19543812)
You're assuming the upgrades will be extraordinarily expensive. What if what is required is something as simple as radar-reflecting paint, and somehow encoding additional information in the markings? Or maybe all cars should have an RFID-like thing on their bumpers to make car detection more reliable. The gov't could distribute that bumper sticker along with the car registration sticker. You could enforce that in the annual inspection.

Sure, a car that doesn't need any aids is much cooler. But if you look at the history of technology, especially in the PC world, there were a lot of clever hacks and external aids that had to be used in order to make the tech feasible. Then with time, they were rendered unnecessary.

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by ex3ndr on Monday April 01, 2019 @04:15AM (#19541452)
Roads already refreshed regularly, may be some specific color will be enought.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by magduf on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:33PM (#19545113)
>Roads already refreshed regularly

You don't live in the US, do you?

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by ex3ndr on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @09:17AM (#19553704)
regularly doesn't mean yearly, but 10 year interval is okeyish for slow infrastructure upgrade.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by magduf on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @10:50AM (#19554666)
Here in DC, we don't update roads nearly that often, judging by all the potholes.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by ex3ndr on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @10:35AM (#19563656)
Road lines are colored yearly or something like this on most streets
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by jniedrauer on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:23AM (#19540486)
> No tech that requires a special type of road will ever get successful

Except, y'know, those newfangled automobile things that they had to build special roads for.

Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by fullshark on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:44AM (#19540568)
What if China does it first and the western world sees it as another Sputnik moment?
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by nikofeyn on Sunday March 31, 2019 @06:51PM (#19538963)
yea, just like we’ve been able to outfit all roads properly for aiding human drivers. you mentioned it’s costly, but this just won’t or can’t happen. we don’t even properly maintain our roads.
Re:Researchers trick Tesla autopilot into driving into oppos... by Diederich on Monday April 01, 2019 @04:01PM (#19547572)
Just a random data point. I've used Tesla's autopilot on completely unmarked dirt roads in the past. The speed was low an I was monitoring the it very carefully, but it did somewhat work on some of the dirt roads I tried it on.