Re:Build an Air Quality Monitor with InfluxDB, Grafana and D...
by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 28, 2019 @07:38AM
(#19511161)
How accurate are these, anyway?
I run a Luftdaten module myself (with SDS011 particulate sensor), but with no government meteorological station next to me, I don't really have a reference point. All I can say is that this SDS011 spews out some numbers, and when testing indoors those numbers got higher when I turned on my air humidifier. I have a similar concern about DHT11/DHT22 - it's a random small box I got mail-ordered from China, which purports to tell the temperature and humidity of air. But again, those are two arbitrary numbers I don't have anything to calibrate again.
Just using these sensors and trusting the results is an accepted practice in DIY electronics community. But I keep wondering - are those sensors actually calibrated, or it's that people don't really care if they get garbage results?
(Related, it's also my number one complaint against a particular air quality startup in my country. They rent out air sensors which you can't inspect (there are contractual penalties involved), and they happily market their map as a vital tool for air quality, but nobody really knows what sensors they're using, and they don't even bother to put error bars on the values they show. I mean, I thought including measurement error is how adults behave.)
I run a Luftdaten module myself (with SDS011 particulate sensor), but with no government meteorological station next to me, I don't really have a reference point. All I can say is that this SDS011 spews out some numbers, and when testing indoors those numbers got higher when I turned on my air humidifier. I have a similar concern about DHT11/DHT22 - it's a random small box I got mail-ordered from China, which purports to tell the temperature and humidity of air. But again, those are two arbitrary numbers I don't have anything to calibrate again.
Just using these sensors and trusting the results is an accepted practice in DIY electronics community. But I keep wondering - are those sensors actually calibrated, or it's that people don't really care if they get garbage results?
(Related, it's also my number one complaint against a particular air quality startup in my country. They rent out air sensors which you can't inspect (there are contractual penalties involved), and they happily market their map as a vital tool for air quality, but nobody really knows what sensors they're using, and they don't even bother to put error bars on the values they show. I mean, I thought including measurement error is how adults behave.)