Re:CERN is the Doomsday Machine
by Rickasaurus on Tuesday May 20, 2008 @04:43PM
(#195291)
This article is laughable.
First of all, all of this controversy has to do with the Large Hadron Collider (Black Holes) and the Low Energy Antiproton Ring (antimatter). Much else goes on at CERN.
Secondly, they are going to be making extremely tiny amounts of antimatter (just enough to study it's effects). Not enough to blow up anything significant. Antimatter is really, really hard to keep around and control.
See: http://public.web.cern.ch/Public/en/Research/Antimatter-en.h...
Third, the "mini black holes" they are making are nothing like what a layman would consider a black hole. They will be only the mass of a few thousand protons and if our current understanding of particle physics is even close to correct they will evaporate almost instantaneously. The funniest part of this whole thing is extremely high energy cosmic rays have been making much higher energy collisions on earth for it's entire existence.
This is all about laymen getting up in arms about things they don't understand. The scientists shouldn't have called them black holes in the first place as it incites ignorant people to speak out when they know very little. With all the science fiction surrounding black holes anyone could have predicted this kind of outrage.
See: http://public.web.cern.ch/Public/en/LHC/Safety-en.html
Re:CERN is the Doomsday Machine
by maximilian on Tuesday May 20, 2008 @02:58PM
(#195147)
If black holes usually get created by collapsing massive stars (much bigger than the sun), then how could CERN possibly create a black hole? I don't know too much about the particle physics of black holes, but it doesn't seem to make that much sense.
Black holes basically happen because the gravity of the thing overcomes all other forces because its so incredibly massive in such a small space (overcomes the forces keeping atom's nuclei apart too). Smashing together a few protons together might make those proton nuclei to crash together, but I don't see how that could possibly make a black hole.
To me, any crazy thing like a black hole that could destroy the earth, is far too energetic and ridiculous for humans to actually make unknowingly. (for now I guess)
I'm sure the smart dudes at CERN thought about this and aren't worried.
First of all, all of this controversy has to do with the Large Hadron Collider (Black Holes) and the Low Energy Antiproton Ring (antimatter). Much else goes on at CERN.
Secondly, they are going to be making extremely tiny amounts of antimatter (just enough to study it's effects). Not enough to blow up anything significant. Antimatter is really, really hard to keep around and control. See: http://public.web.cern.ch/Public/en/Research/Antimatter-en.h...
Third, the "mini black holes" they are making are nothing like what a layman would consider a black hole. They will be only the mass of a few thousand protons and if our current understanding of particle physics is even close to correct they will evaporate almost instantaneously. The funniest part of this whole thing is extremely high energy cosmic rays have been making much higher energy collisions on earth for it's entire existence.
This is all about laymen getting up in arms about things they don't understand. The scientists shouldn't have called them black holes in the first place as it incites ignorant people to speak out when they know very little. With all the science fiction surrounding black holes anyone could have predicted this kind of outrage. See: http://public.web.cern.ch/Public/en/LHC/Safety-en.html
Black holes basically happen because the gravity of the thing overcomes all other forces because its so incredibly massive in such a small space (overcomes the forces keeping atom's nuclei apart too). Smashing together a few protons together might make those proton nuclei to crash together, but I don't see how that could possibly make a black hole.
To me, any crazy thing like a black hole that could destroy the earth, is far too energetic and ridiculous for humans to actually make unknowingly. (for now I guess)
I'm sure the smart dudes at CERN thought about this and aren't worried.
The video featuring the earth collapsing is fun. But science is even more fun. Don't stop the geek. Let 'em rock the universe.