Re:Mumble – Open source, low latency, high quality voice cha...
by dymk on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:52PM
(#19493574)
Hole punching through routers. It's hard to generically connect two NAT'd devices directly. It's simpler to route through a central server.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mumble – Open source, low latency, high quality voice cha...
by oarsinsync on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @01:43PM
(#19494209)
Skype's original USP was that it resolved the NAT issues that plagued SIP based VOIP implementations, exactly by performing hole punching through routers (I suspect just UDP hole punching)
Re:Mumble – Open source, low latency, high quality voice cha...
by kitotik on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @01:10PM
(#19493803)
Hasn’t this been a solved problem for a while with STUN / TURN servers?
The centralized server just handles the negotiation, so that the p2p clients can do their thing.
Re:Mumble – Open source, low latency, high quality voice cha...
by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @01:24PM
(#19493974)
I don't recall this ever being a problem with Skype, and I used it quite extensively at the time.
(Mumble is another matter...)
Re:Mumble – Open source, low latency, high quality voice cha...
by api on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:17PM
(#19497916)
This isn't that hard. It's even easier now that many people have IPv6. IPv6 still usually requires rendezvous due to stateful fireballing but it otherwise behaves like 1:1 NAT. (IPv6 is occasionally deployed with NAT, but in that case it is 1:1 NAT without port remapping which is also P2P-friendly.)