>City officials adopted the language for subminimum wage for people with disabilities in 2015 in its minimum wage law. That language had been modeled off the State Minimum Wage Act, which allows for “special certificates” that can be issued if someone has a disability.
>In September, the Seattle Office of Labor Standards stopped issuing those certificates based on the director’s rules. The bill, which passed through council member Teresa Mosqueda’s committee late March, officially changed the code to remove the option altogether.
The nonprofit that got fined was due to their underpaying workers without the previously-necessary certificate.
1. There are loopholes around paying minimum wage that are separate from the core subminimum wage legislation. The sheltered workshop exemption is federal disability law. If the location uses this exemption, then they can employ the workers as contractors and the federal law applies. (If not using the sheltered workshop exemption, such contracted workers must be paid $10.35 per hour.) 2. My understanding is that Amazon started this program before the 2015 reform and has expanded its scope over the years. 3. I didn't mean to imply Amazon paid subminimum wage, as I don't know the wages. (Although the quote in the story is unclear as to whether the minimum wage being referred to is the shelter exemption rate or Seattle's minimum.) My main intent (as a former Seattle tech founder) was to relay the disappointing background of their partner.
I was not attacking the integrity of the program and apologize it came off that way.
> “I’m grateful to actually have gotten a job,” Howard said during a work break. “It’s just part time, but even still, it’s a good job. … I’m making above minimum wage.”
> Likewise, Northwest Center employees and those it places with Amazon are paid at least minimum wage. (Seattle closed a loophole in its minimum wage law that allowed employers to pay people with a disability a sub-minimum wage and recovered back wages from Northwest Center in 2018. Washington and many other states still allow minimum wage waivers.)
The NC used this exemption in the past and claimed the workers were contractors - and therefore only beholden to federal wage and disability laws. As long as they (Amazon and the NC) properly established the business as a sheltered workshop, workers would be looking at a few dollars an hour. Otherwise the federal minimum of $10.35 applies.
This "gotcha" is like saying, "$CARMAKER is only investing in electric cars because such autos get tax subsidies." Well, yeah. Public policy encourages things that are underproduced relative to the social optimum. That's why you need public policy to do it, and not regular businesspeople.
We have a term for where no one does anything good because the public will ridicule them for not having 100% pure motives: hell.
[1] a sibling reply suggests this exemption has been phased out
As for the exemption for subminimum wage, the NC's arguments in the past have been that only federal wage and disability law applies to them, as the workers are contractors. As a result, if the sheltered workshop exemption is properly applied, the workers are only eligible for a few dollars per hour. If that federal disability exemption applies, workers only earn a few dollars per hour. Otherwise, they earn $10.35.
Then re-read your comment and considering whether that's the impression you can expect someone to take away from it.
For some mental disabilities, expecting economic output above minimum wage is unrealistic.
But these are still human beings who have social wants and c. 16 waking hours every day. If they're unemployable at minimum wage, all they have to do is occupy themselves with extremely cheap leisure-- because they can't afford anything else.
I have a mentally disabled family member who used to have a below-minimum-wage sorting job at a direct mail place. The wage laws changed and that dried up.
My family is able to support him, but he spends a lot of time walking around and mumbling to himself. He seemed happier when he had somewhere to go and something to do. Of course, it's not easy to understand his perspective.
Please consider that, in some circumstances, a company hiring severely disabled people below minimum wage is making a positive contribution to society.
That said, as a former founder from Seattle, I'm quite aware of the NC's shenanigans. If there's scope to pay the proper minimum wage to these employees ($10.35 based on the NC's arguments that only federal disability and wage laws apply to them) then I'd prefer to see that happen.
As it stands, if one assumes the NC's stance on contractor wages to be correct, the disabled workers could still be paid a few dollars per hour. This would still be above the subminimum wage, so the article's quote about being above the minimum wage would still be accurate. But these workers would be missing out on $7-8 dollars per hour that federal wage law demands they be paid.
There are some disabled people, though, who can't provide $10.35/hr in economic benefit. If the "full" minimum wage is applied to them, it's much more likely that they end up with nothing to do than they end up making those extra $7-8/hr.
Businesses are not charities and will we shouldn't expect them to behave as such. If our society wants to provide for a disadvantaged group, straightforward taxation and redistribution is a much more fair way to accomplish that goal than enacting a wage minimum.
This was mentioned and it is implied that amazon is not paying these employees less
> employees placed at Amazon by Northwest Center chalked up a productivity rate that was 98 percent of the average while achieving 37 percent better quality work than the general population, and with a perfect safety record, compared with a 1.1 percent warehouse incident rate. They also had better attendance.
This sounds like a pretty big win
Disclaimer: I am a former amazon employee
> “I’m grateful to actually have gotten a job,” Howard said during a work break. “It’s just part time, but even still, it’s a good job. … I’m making above minimum wage.”
> Likewise, Northwest Center employees and those it places with Amazon are paid at least minimum wage. (Seattle closed a loophole in its minimum wage law that allowed employers to pay people with a disability a sub-minimum wage and recovered back wages from Northwest Center in 2018. Washington and many other states still allow minimum wage waivers.)
I guess - without any further information, why spread this negativity?
I don’t understand the agenda here. My personal experience with shopping Amazon and AWS has been generally really good. Even if you’re has not been good, how do you extrapolate to Amazon people all being part of some evil conspiracy?
If they can find more profit by employing folks with disabilities, that's a net good. And why shouldn't they get some good PR out of it? Nothing wrong with that IMO.
However, Amazon has a history of aggressively exploiting workers who have little bargaining power.
It is worth noting that the person with disabilities is quoted as saying he makes "above minimum wage". Likewise, later in the article:
> Likewise, Northwest Center employees and those it places with Amazon are paid at least minimum wage.
And indeed, I suspect this is the "double-bottom line" motive. Community impact is all well and good, but it has to serve the business as well. In this case, it's good PR, but it's also tapping a new talent pool to hire from. An Amazon rep is quoted saying same:
>... “a hybrid of a business need and a philanthropic opportunity.”
I also am not sure which minimum wage is being referred to - the sheltered workshop wage (a few dollars per hour and federal law, not the state subminimum law), the Seattle minimum wage or the federal minimum ($10.35 and only applies with the sheltered workshop exemption.)
Since the NC was caught violating state and city laws, they've claimed they don't have to comply with said regulations as their workers are contractors and only federal disability and wage law applies to them. In that case, the minimum is $10.35 - unless the sheltered workshop exemption is invoked, in which case the wage is a few dollars per hour. Those few dollars are still above the statutory subminimum wage, so the quote could refer to the sheltered workshop wage and still be true.
The NW Center has been cited in the past for such underpayment. https://patch.com/washington/seattle/nonprofit-underpaid-dis...