Similarly, zoning laws are beneficial to resident homeowners and detrimental to renters, potential startups, real estate speculators.
There is no uniform "public interest". Any significant policy will have some people it helps and some people it hurts.
Why should a city prioritize the needs of landlords and visitors over most of their constituents? Would love to see the number of mayors who love Airbnb. I can’t imagine there are many, if any.
I've used them for staying in Kirkland, WA; Amherst, MA; Santa Cruz, CA; Redding, CA; Gualala, CA; Carmel, CA; Morro Bay, CA; Kihei, Hawaii; Croatia; Sarajevo; and several other places. They're an absolute lifesaver there: in some of those locations, there are literally 1-2 hotels in the whole town, they are frequently fully booked, and they cost 2-3x an AirBnB.
And I'd also doubt very many mayors like AirBnB all that much. My point is that interests diverge - there are some people who derive a lot of benefit from AirBnB, and there are other people who have good reason to hate it.
The host had soft partitioned her apartment and was renting out the bedroom. Because it was “owner occupied” I don’t believe it is illegal. By being present, she could ensure I kept to the social norms of the building.
Airbnb in NYC isn’t just tourists having raves in quiet apartments. There are socially acceptable use cases that don’t result in housing shortages or significant downsides to current residents. I wish more people could accept nuance in the debate.
While making it a nuisance for people actually living in the city. I live in a condo in downtown Toronto, and every tenant in my building unanimously hates airbnb residents. There are weekends when people who airbnb and come for the sole reason to party throw liquor bottles and garbage in the lobby, destroy elevator buttons because they can't access their floor with the fob, puke in the hallway/elevator when they come back from a night out at 3am. The list goes on. While it definitely does benefit people who actually want to travel and are respectful of the building, not everyone is like that.
>their hosts (many of whom keep their finances afloat through AirBnB revenue, or have been able to enjoy life-changing increases in their standard of living
Agreed, but this is when Airbnb is actually used how it is supposed to. Either the host lists it as a short term rental for a one off weekend, or a spare bedroom in their apartment. What ends up happening for a majority of units is, that a lot of rich people end up 1+xth property just for the sole reason of Airbnbing it full time and thus decreasing the supply of long term rental units for people in the city. You know what this leads to.
If airbnb actually cared, they would have more checks before a host can sign up, work the city to give them names of owners who list their unit for more than allowed days (a lot of European cities actually allow 90 days of rental or something similar), work with condo-boards to ban the building if it's against the building policy, etc.
You asked if there were other companies who operated substantially illegally,* not if there were other companies who operated substantially illegally and also weren't in the public interest. I offered examples.
Perhaps my musing at the end isn't widely applicable, the only one of the services listed I've substantially used is Uber, but nevertheless AirBNB certainly isn't alone in their behaviour.
* You said mostly illegally, but I don't know that that's even true of AirBNB.
When I moved to Seattle a few years ago after college, I wanted to explore different neighborhoods to find out where I wanted to live. I found an Airbnb that let me rent out a persons mother-in-law house for $1000 for a month which is like 1/3rd of hotel rates and way more spacious because the alternative is that they would just let that space sit empty.
How does Airbnb benefits residents of a city outside of landlords/slumlords? In markets with low housing supply they crowd out housing for permanent residents and create safety issues for neighbors. I would be pissed if I lived in an apartment complex with a steady stream of random strangers coming in and out because my neighbor rented it out on Airbnb.
Residential zoning laws are in the public interest. A city that made it legal for any home, apartment, or condo to be turned into a mini hotel does not benefit the people that live there at all.