News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by ackfoo on Saturday March 23, 2019 @08:46PM (#19473282)
That's not really accurate. Boeing is under continuous attack by hatchet jobs like this that insinuate they cut corners and are solely responsible for these accidents.

First, we don't have final reports from the investigators yet, so it's awfully early to point the finger.

Second, every major aviation accident is multi-factorial. It's never just one failure that causes it.

If it does turn out to be the faulty AOA indicator causing the electric trim to go nose-down, there are still a number of other obvious contributing factors in addition to the faulty sensor.

The public is demanding low airfare prices because they are getting squeezed by the increasing disparity of wealth worldwide. Wages are not rising as fast as prices, and as the cost of doing business with China slowly rises due to the trade war, prices start to creep up and the squeeze increases.

Airlines respond by flying pilots with lower time and lesser training, paying them less, and working them harder.

Pilots spend less time in the simulator working on abnormal conditions, and while they are undoubtedly great at monitoring normal flights and navigating controlled airspace, they have less experience hand-flying approaches and dealing with rare equipment failures and emergencies.

Every pilot should have adequate simulator time to be competent with every emergency procedure for which there is a checklist, but that is not the reality. The three seconds allotted by the FAA to diagnose critical systems failures is simply not enough if you can't find and execute the correct checklist in that time period.

In the old days, every single pilot from a Cessna 152 on up knew exactly what a badly trimmed airplane felt like and how to fix it instantly. When you felt that extra force on the controls, you would instinctively rotate the trim wheel in the direction of the force that you were needing to apply.

Same for electric trim systems: if the force doesn't ease the way it should, you have a runaway and you need to interrupt power to the electric trim system.

But that is hand-flying, stick-and-rudder-type stuff. If you're not getting the hand-flying time and the simulated failure time, you just don't develop that instinct.

It's not entirely Boeing's fault that an aircrew can't recognize and counter a runaway electric trim, no matter what the details in the flight manual. It's only reasonable to assume that basic level of competency.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by asmithmd1 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:48PM (#19473603)
All pilots of Boeing aircraft know that when the autopilot is off, there is no automation between the controls and the control surfaces - until the 737 Max changed that. The MCAS system is only active when autopilot was off, a big change. Imagine the faulty AoA sensor is causing the aircraft to hunt around to different altitudes. The pilot switches off autopilot by just applying force to the controls and suddenly the plane starts pitching down.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by foldr on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:02PM (#19473654)
>All pilots of Boeing aircraft know that when the autopilot is off, there is no automation between the controls and the control surfaces

This isn't even approximately true. Pretty much all passenger jets since the 50s and 60s have had yaw dampeners, for example.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by asmithmd1 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:20PM (#19473751)
True, but a yaw dampener is sort of like a steady cam, it isn't going to over-rule a pilot's rudder input.

Put yourself in the seat of a pilot who has flown an electro-hydraulic 737 for years. Something "funny" seems to be going on with the trim, so you take control and the trim seems to be working perfectly while you manually toggle it, but then the MCAS kicks back in after 5 seconds and tries to push the nose down again. This kind of behavior is coming from a system Boeing did not tell the pilots about.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by inferiorhuman on Sunday March 24, 2019 @08:21AM (#19475914)
True, but a yaw dampener is sort of like a steady cam, it isn't going to over-rule a pilot's rudder input.

No, but a rudder hardover might ;). The 747 and 767 were sometimes equipped with stick pushers as well.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by zaroth on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:44PM (#19473855)
> This kind of behavior is coming from a system Boeing did not tell the pilots about.

True for the first crash. However, no longer true by the time of the second crash.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by myrandomcomment on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:24PM (#19474040)
I cannot agree more. After the 1st crash you would think every pilot would have become familiar with this system and how to override it. The stuff that has come out from the most recent crash shows that the pilot was read through manuals trying to understand what was happening. Given the most recent crash, why would he not think, hey lets disable this new system because my plane is acting in the exact same way. I am not saying that Boeing is not at fault for poor training or documentation but if I was flying the same plane as one that recently crashed I know I would have known everything I could about that crash before I lifted off in that same model.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by faizmokhtar on Sunday March 24, 2019 @12:10AM (#19474251)
Not likely. When the first crash happened Boeing try to shift the blame to Lion Air citing lack of maintenance and what not.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by jiqiren on Sunday March 24, 2019 @12:14AM (#19474266)
As many report have already mentioned: the MCAS is not in the manuals.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by CaptainZapp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:48AM (#19500287)
After the first crash Boeing should have pulled that plane out of service, period. It shouldn't be up to pilots to try to find workarounds for rotten engineering.

The first crash can be chalked up to engineering errors, corner cutting and the desire not having to retrain and recertify pilots.

The second crash is outright criminal by Boeing, for not immediately pulling that plane out of circulation after the Lion Air disaster. Regardless of the cost (which will be much, much more expensive after crash 2).

Their cozy relationship with the FAA also didn't help and I hope the people responsible pay dearly for that.

Throwing the pilots under the bus is how they tried to handle that PR desaster. Doesn't seem to work well, though.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by pishpash on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:16PM (#19474002)
Still an unnecessary cognitive load.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by lsh123 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:00PM (#19473649)
Not a Boeing driver, but in a few GA aircraft I flew, runaway trim can happen regardless of AP on/off status.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by ams6110 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:06PM (#19473675)
Yes it can happen due to a jammed switch, relay, wiring short, etc.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by ekianjo on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:17PM (#19474004)
You can however disable the MCAS and it is apparently well documented in the pilot training material. When the trimming wheel acts strangely this is a sign that something may be going wrong and this is part of what pilots need to know when flying this aircraft.

Now whether or not such information is widely known among all pilots is another matter altogether.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by raverbashing on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:30PM (#19474067)
MCAS wasn't, runway trim was, however, I don't believe the pilots would expect/recognize a runway trim failure on the occasions that MCAS would fail
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by kalleboo on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:55PM (#19473630)
I agree with most of your points in general, but Boeing tried as hard as possible to pretend MCAS needed no training. There WAS no simulator scenario to train on for this failure.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by rootusrootus on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:06PM (#19473676)
Based on accurate descriptions of the intended scenario for MCAS, they would be right. When the system is working, it does what it was designed to do. The failure mode when an AOA sensor goes on the fritz is the problem. The proposed fix is what they should have shipped out with the first plane, that's the real failure here -- someone at Boeing surely saw this coming and raised a flag, and got shouted down. A reckless decision given that the 737 is a cash cow and historically such a successful line of planes that I imagine Boeing would be keen to keep the reputation intact.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by cjbprime on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:32PM (#19473800)
Sort of with you, but I think once you're willing to admit that MCAS failure can be catastrophic, airworthiness regulations may require three AoA sensors (as Airbus planes have) so that you get error correction, rather than the two that should have been being used to detect disagreement (but weren't).
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by ams6110 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:41PM (#19473843)
I think the issue is that Boeing didn't see a potential MCAS failure as really any different from any other cause of runaway trim, for which there was well-established procedure and training. Clearly at least not all pilots seem to recognize this in time, particularly with other distractions caused by a faulty AoA reading, such as stick shaker, other warnings and alarms, and all of that happening at low altitude.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by cjbprime on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:54PM (#19473890)
I don't think that matters here, though I agree with what you said. There's also going to be redundancy on the other mechanisms that can lead to runaway trim, because runaway trim can be catastrophic, because we don't assume that pilots are perfect, and because (as you say) runaway trim can happen in situations where the ground will necessarily arrive before your recovery does.

I think it takes around thirty seconds for the trim motor to move you from one end (where both crashed planes had it) of the jackscrew to the other. And that's with the motor! If you cut out the motor because it was literally trying to kill you -- and as Boeing advises you to -- you'll have to use the hand crank and it will take much longer. Runaway trim at low altitude is death.

It really seems to me that the MAX as shipped was not plausibly airworthy (due to the use of a single sensor). I think even Boeing's going to agree eventually.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by asmithmd1 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:39PM (#19473831)
A "more right" solution would have been to implement a "stick pusher" system to make it obvious to the pilot what was going on. But that would have required pilot training and punctured the illusion that the plane can be flown by any pilot who has flown any 737 made since the 1960's
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by salawat on Sunday March 24, 2019 @11:34AM (#19476891)
Boeing is solidly at fault here.

I have to preach the idea that networks and computing are not magic. While yes, I cam talk to people all over the world, the information I'm trying to communicate still has to be put in front of a person to be communicated.

An aircraft company should treat information dissemination to pilots as as critical a toolchain as their supply and manufacturing processes.

If your tool cannot be used safely, your job isn't done, no matter what your marketing people say.

If it were a financial services, or big data cpmpany maybe I'd lend credence to the safety of leaving that out.

Not aviation. There is too much at risk there. Flight is the equivalent of riding a bubble of air to your destination, which necessitates the continuous balancing of aerodynamic forces, facilitated by increasingly complex hybrid systems of direct human control and automation.

At the end of the day though, a pilot/plane combination should be able to be salvaged even with catastrophic loss of piloting aids, even with catastrophic loss of integrity of the automation on board.

Automation should make flying a plane easier. Not render pilots ineffective when it malfunctions or fails.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by sgwae on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:22PM (#19473472)
Has the same issue happened for airbus with half a thousand dead, and any of their planes grounded world wide?
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by ams6110 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:04PM (#19473662)
Well the maiden passenger flight of the A320 crashed at the Paris Air Show, and the pilot said the fly-by-wire system didn't let him pull up[1]. Officially it was pilot error though.

There have been nearly 1,400 fatalities with the A320, with some pilots blaming the fly-by-wire systems, but many of those happened before the age of Twitter and social media virality of this sort of thing so who knows what the public reaction would be today.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_296

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by selectodude on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:36PM (#19473544)
The A330 had some weird pitch down incidences due to a faulty ADIRS, and obviously AF447 due to faulty pitot tubes and the completely idiotic issue where the control sticks aren't synced and the inputs are averaged out before being sent to the plane. There were some considerations given to grounding the fleet, whether or not Airbus wanted to admit it at the time.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-plane-denial-sb/ai...

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by cjbprime on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:21PM (#19473756)
A330 has fewer total fatalities over its 27 years of service (339 deaths) than the MAX does in a year and a half (346 deaths).
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by raverbashing on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:34PM (#19474092)
The pitch down incidents I believe were caused by a non compliant part replacement (I don't remember which company it was though)
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by sidlls on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:52PM (#19473620)
There are several pilots who've had this very issue happen to them and they managed to diagnose and address the problem without flying the plane into the ground.

These incidents are almost always the result of a combination of errors ranging from negligent engineering and documentation to mechanical defects to human (pilot) error. We simply don't know all the facts in these two crashes.

The publicly available information to me indicates negligent documentation (pilot manuals should have been updated to reflect the new mode and how to treat the issue similarly to runaway trim), negligent sales practice (the AoA disagree feature shouldn't be an option), and poor reactions by the pilots involved. But that's purely speculation at this point: there could very well be some other causes instead of or in addition to these.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by myrandomcomment on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:20PM (#19474016)
Air France Brazil to France flight.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by rootusrootus on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:02PM (#19473655)
Is that a serious question, or did you just not do any research? Yes, Airbus planes have crashed due to malfunctioning automation. It hasn't even been that long since one of their newest planes actually experienced a problem eerily similar to the 737MAX issue, but got lucky in that it occurred when the plane was higher and had more altitude to trade for time and the pilots were able to regain control.
Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by sgwae on Sunday March 24, 2019 @09:46AM (#19476305)
Yes, I also tried to google if airbus grounded thier entire fleet, but nothing came up, so I thought there were not any systematic issues.

Im not a comercial plane enthusiast either.

Re:Boeing Was ‘Go, Go, Go’ to Beat Airbus with the 737 Max by cjbprime on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:27PM (#19473780)
> If it does turn out to be the faulty AOA indicator causing the electric trim to go nose-down, there are still a number of other obvious contributing factors in addition to the faulty sensor.

There's no serious argument here. It isn't airworthy on an airliner to have a system with flight control capability using one sensor with no redundancy. It doesn't happen anywhere else and there are regulations that forbid it. Airbus uses AoA for autopilot and therefore puts three AoA sensors on the plane with majority voting.

It appears that Boeing (during certification) either lied about the severity of MCAS failure, or lied and said they were using two sensors when they weren't.