People on the left who are not part of the machine of the Democratic Party - Ralph Nader, Noam Chomsky, many lesser known people in that orbit, have said all along that this whole Trump/Russia thing has been overblown.
The Democrats lost the 2016 election. Trump railed against NAFTA and TPP and campaigned around working class people in the Midwest and said the US was in too many wars abroad and steel workers needed help. Hillary took money from Wall Street, initially supported TPP, didn't visit the Midwest despite Michael Moore's entreaties - he was saying at the time which states she could lose, all of which she did.
Nader said, paraphrasing - "The Democrats had unappealing policies in 2000 and lost, and in 2016 and lost. They could be self-critical and see US workers did not support their policies, and change them to be more appealing to US workers. Or they could keep taking corporate PAC money and find a scapegoat. They chose that option. The scapegoat was me (Nader) in 2000. In 2016 it was Putin."
In a move to try to be less appealing to voters, the DCCC just passed a number of policies trying to prevent local Democratic parties from running primaries against incumbents. They want control to be held by incumbents and corporate PACs and party hacks - any body other than the local Democratic voters who do all the leg work and voting.
They're his best friends.
If anything, all this media coverage shows is that the US mainstream media is now spectacularly ineffective and irrelevant.
They might have brought down Nixon, but they can't bring down Trump.
Everybody on all sides already has their minds made up, and they only read the news for entertainment, to confirm their biases, and to find talking points.
> An NBC source said that an Access Hollywood producer remembered the conversation on Monday, October 3, and located it in the show's archives.[4][11] The celebrity news website TMZ reports a different chronology: when senior executives at NBC learned about the video, they thought it was too early in the presidential campaign season to release it with maximum effect, and (according to TMZ) those executives publicly said they learned of the video long after they actually learned about it.[12][13]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Trump_Access_Hollywood_...
The Hollywood access tape was covered for weeks, and it's not exactly political. We've all said things in private that would make us look bad if they were recorded and displayed to the world. He apologized for it.
Occasionally (both online and in real life) I feel that whatever I say tends to be interpreted in the binary: "are you with us or against us". This makes it hard to have a thoughtful discussion. Clarifying that I'm loyal to whatever cause the audience supports helps to some degree.
I would hope on a forum such as HN people wouldn't make assumptions ... but I think we all have an assumptive instinct on some level.
Intersectional issues (race/gender/class), some things about China, obviously religion - they're all so loaded it's hard to have a discussion.
Finally, even though I have very nuanced views of Trump, and don't think he's 'all bad' - and my own politics are utterly not on the American spectrum ... I just don't want to be associated with him frankly.
Agreed...
That said, there are people who are happy to have an open discussion without judging everything on the basis of "friend" / "enemy". I wonder if there's a forum, online or offline, where ideas are shared and discussed in good faith.
There was one https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/02/22/rip-culture-war-thread... <- a very interesting read.
Various satellite forums of slatestarcodex have grown and are around, and only the original Culture War thread is gone. That whole group seems to be politically mixed and at least partially vaccinated against the dangers of framing political disagreements in terms of tribes and dehumanising the outgroup/opponent.
In this case, it seems the original attempt didn't survive the influx of people from outside who were not interested in a civil discussion.
Perhaps a smaller, invitation only, forum might stand a better chance?
We made a choice, in this country, to give away our spectrum to the highest bidder, no questions asked. We used to restrict programs that called themselves "news" to have to present a balanced, reality-grounded perspective, but by the early 90s fear of alternatives like the internet provided the fodder to dismantle that regulation.
It wasn't necessarily bad foresight either. These days, influencers on YouTube regularly get the same viewership that cable news does. Only very recently[1] have we begun to grapple with the social decay and radicalization that results when their engagement-optimization algorithm meets vulnerable folks. Try searching for historical, economic or political content and see how quickly Related Videos draws you down a conspiracy theory rabbit hole.
1. https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/youtube-announces-it-...
In my mind, these two acts alone have warranted the last two years of coverage and investigation.
Simply imagine a world where these things were ignored. How untrustworthy would the press seem then?
Also after Comey’s restart of the email investigation many Dems wanted him fired.
>Also after Comey’s restart of the email investigation many Dems wanted him fired.
Irrelevant.
The second (which is also a conviction by way of a guilty plea) and the final indictments made public were for collusion. Or, rather, for lying about collusion, but the collusion itself is part of the factual background of the indictments and a central and necessary one in each case.
If there is a media failure, it's in continuously reporting the Presidents claim that no collusion was indicated and either letting it stand or endorsing it when that is factually incorrect.
There's nothing wrong with the press on this one.
Not buying into the 'red scare' means that in the eyes of some you must be a Trump supporter.
This is a failure of critical thinking and far too many people fall into this trap, thereby perpetuating things like 'RussiaGate' when it no longer makes sense to do so.
The suspicions won't die down amongst those that have been sat in front of their televisions feeding their imaginations with 'RussiaGate'. To them 'it happened but it could not be proven'. Their suspicions are still confirmed.
There is also a failure to take people at their word when it could be prudent to do so in this world of politics and lying. People have motivation for lying and people have motivation for being honest.
The leadership in Russia - Putin, Lavrov and others - have stated why it is that they have not secretly foisted Trump on the American people. But those that don't listen don't want to take them for their word on that.
Fundamentally the Kremlin see other nations as having national interests and, in the case of America, they have no need to care about who sits in the Oval Office as the national interests will be the same. The Pentagon isn't going to go away, the need for oil isn't going to go away, the need for the world to be using the dollar as the world currency isn't going to go away. American capitalism is always going to be what it is. American national interests are a constant as far as Russia is concerned. They cannot expect some external change, they have to be self-reliant and foster their own good relationships with traditional partners.
The Russian leadership have also stated why it is not in their interest to put 'their man' in the Oval Office. It is not due to any standards of conduct it is simpler than that. Thinking two moves ahead, what legitimacy would a puppet President hold, how long would he/she last and how would Russia be treated should the American people find out?
The Kremlin have thought this out. However, explaining to someone that the Russians are not motivated to influence the American elections also falls under the 'instant disclaimer'.
'So you must be a Putin fan?' is the expectation for proffering this explainer. But it is not about that, it is about understanding motivation and the Russian leadership are not motivated to influence American elections in some super-sneaky way.
There is a failure by the press that have pursued RussiaGate to empathise and understand others, whether they be the people that voted for Trump, the Russians, the Democrat machine or even themselves. It is because of this that you are correct, the press will not reform. It is not in their culture and they don't have the mindset to do so.
Diplomacy is a game of liars probing liars. Everyone at the table will tell you exactly what they know you can prove, and no one tells anyone everything they can prove since that would give away valuable information with regards to their own intelligence and reconnaissance capabilities. It's a game in which every comment spoken by a Diplomat, Ambassador, or Head of State is scrutinized and cross-checked against every participating country's models.
Outright deception is one of many tools that is employed, and even if Russia truly didn't have anything to gain from Trump ending up in the White House, they did get a chance to dry-run a potential doctrine against one of their biggest international rivals.
The press was right to be suspicious, and the ethical shortfalls of the President and his administration only amplified the situation in terms of the optics required.
Make no mistake. Intrigue happens. It's why diplomats love the phrase "Trust, but verify."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_20...
That's 496 citations and a warning "This article may be too long to read and navigate comfortably".
In other words, there's overwhelming evidence that Russia interfered. Like, not even a question. Suggesting it's a made-up media frenzy is just... alternate universe.
I'm not pointing to the length of the article or the number of citations as direct support - I'm simply showing how overwhelmingly the burden of proof is on the person claiming it's all made up. To suggest that there was no Russian election interference of any sort is on par with moon landing denial. Literally nobody seriously asserts that - not even Trump! (Not anymore, anyway). That bears repeating, if you think Russians didn't interfere with the 2016 presidential election, you have a weaker grasp of reality than Donald Trump. It's frightening post-truth wingnuttery.
https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/87841331318880256... https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/96520255620400332...?
I didn’t really address the case that Russia hacked the DNC, content to stipulate it for now. I was told early on that this piece of the story seemed “solid,” but even that assertion has remained un-bolstered since then, still based on an “assessment” by the intelligence services that always had issues, including the use of things like RT’s “anti-American” coverage of fracking as part of its case. The government didn’t even examine the DNC’s server, the kind of detail that used to make reporters nervous.
Words like "wingnuttery" and "moon landing" weaken your case. If you get enough publications to print something, you can make a terrifically long list of citations, but what does that prove? Quality matters, not quantity, and the quality of journalism devoted to this case has been astonishingly low, as Taibbi shows. As he says:
We won’t know how much of any of this to take seriously until the press gets out of bed with the security services and looks at this whole series of events all over again with fresh eyes, as journalists, not political actors.
I can find you 496 citations that the Loch Ness Monster ate Freddie Starr's hamster. If this mattered as a matter of national security, would you prefer to simply ask Freddie Starr if someone is having a laugh?
There are precisely zero citations on that page to any Russian sources. There should be. With the original Russian and English translation. With those sources being official.
Why is this?
When I was at school my history teacher told me that we always had to check sources.
Am I to believe that it is beyond the wit of the journalist to link to words uttered by the Kremlin, posted onto an official Kremlin blog? So we can read the original denials verbatim and in context?
I checked the citations and I am only seeing articles by the media that have been advancing the RussiaGate agenda. Quality is not the same thing as quantity, 496 articles written by Western pundits does not magically make something true.
Not all of the people in those citations are Mother Theresa types. Luke Harding from the Guardian gets a mention in those citations but some Guardian readers know what Luke Harding's game really is. It has something to do with propaganda.
Any story can be made into something it isn't by being economical with the truth. Then we start believing and regurgitating our own falsehoods.
There were a few quips on there about what Putin and Lavrov had to say. Are these cherry picked to support a given narrative? Without links to the source words and the context, who can say?
We need to listen and understand our global neighbours, not live in a world where we only listen to the journalists that Tabibbi is lampooning.
When you can only view the world in terms of who to hold responsible and who to Blame, you get hit in two ways. The chances of producing a reaction, defensiveness etc increase and the chances of connecting and producing healthier outcomes decrease.
Blame takes focus away from where attention needs to be. Empathy does the opposite.
Even the most odious of people can be taken at their word about some things. The heroin addict in the village might not be responsible for every burglary in the village even if they are responsible for 95% of them.
In England we have a tradition that people are innocent until proven guilty. RussiaGate and whatever happened in your linked story very much falls under that category.
Guess what? With not even that much effort I can find out that their dog is outside and unattended most of the day. (Means/Opportunity)
I can infer they don't like to leash the dog, due to the frequency the dog can be found roaming the neighborhood. (Motive)
I've seem the neighbors unattended dog defecate in other neighbors yards. (Precedent)
I've even had to walk it home a couple of times as well. (more precedent)
I COULD go through the trouble of setting up a bunch of cameras to catch it red pawed as it were, however, that's kind of a moot point, because I know the neighbor has the means, motive, opportunity, and a history of prior behavior.
This is not only a preponderance of evidence, but in the absence of someone else's dog traipsing through my property, this could even be legally considered beyond a reasonable doubt.
After reading your various replies, I just want to leave you with a word of caution: not everyone is worth trusting, even in the absence of direct proof. Especially if you can collect a preponderance of evidence that suggests that an action isn't outside their expected behavioral envelope.
The biggest problem we face isn't a problem of unreliable sources, but a crisis of ease of manufacture of the blatantly untrue combined with an asymmetrical distribution of the necessary skills/tools to refute.
We're still well equipped to deal with this type of situation, but it requires an elevated level of skepticism until we solve the problem of information provenance.
If there is one thing we have, going for us, however, it is a large store of information recorded from times before misinformation was so trivially distributed and manufactured to work from, and the wherewithal to reason from it. Trust, I think, is going to develop into a completely different beast in the 21st century from what it was in the 20th.
Trump saying some bad things isn't enough for me. Unless you're also dissatisfied with the character of most presidents, I think your stance is the result of the propaganda machine.
But the author is very correct.
A 'free press' is the 5th estate - an important part of civil society.
... but it only works if they have integrity.
Over the last two years it has become clear how narrow and biased they have become in their contempt for Trump and of course in search of 'more clicks'.
This is a deep wound for America that I do not think we can blame on Trump himself, however much some of us may loathe him.
Trump is a Loki who exposed a serious degradation in another part of the system and it has to remedied.
Sadly, I do not think they will admit their failures, and they will not reform, and as a result, we're going to be having wars over 'fake news' for a long time.
Post-Edit: I don't want this to take away from critiquing Trump for some of the awful things that he's said, or some of his questionable policies - my only point is 'the press broke' on this, and it's a legitimate concern. If the press lacks integrity, we lose the ability to hold people to account.