1) The seasteading.org folks aren't rich, though they can get resources from rich people who like their program.
2) They have a well thought-out program for making their own land.
3) The land they have is very small, and it's perched on top of tall towers, therefore easy to defend. Private security and agreements with local governments should suffice for their needs.
4) The seasteading folks plan to use flags of convenience, or plan to just not be noticed. The platforms will most likely be mobile, so if they don't like their neighbors, they'll just move.
5) Since each unit is relatively small, they can use the same legal framework that captains aboard oceangoing vessels use.
[1] The seasteading folks seem to be about Libertarian ideals of freedom. I understand that there are indeed some folks willing to die for those ideals. I am not saying if this this is a good idea or not.
Disclosure: I am not a member of seasteading.org. I just think they have neat engineering ideas.
They are sitting ducks, one well armed rogue pirate ship could finish them.
North Korea has shown that the easiest way to defend against invasion by the US is to have a number of nukes. This seems to be Iran's strategy too. Until they have nukes, they are vulnerable. After they have nukes, they are much less likely to be attacked themselves.
If North Korea, Pakistan, and (soon) Iran have managed to get nukes, I don't see why small groups of rich, smart, western businessmen won't be able to.
A floating settlement armed with robotic drones and nuclear missiles would be pretty secure I think.
Why would an armed rogue ship want to do that? Seastead platforms would only have value as a floating platform. It's not as if you could easily fence the thing.
The platforms could also be hosting things of value, like a casino. A casino would probably be able to afford really good security, and its owners might well have enough political pull to get the assistance of land-nation's militaries. It would have to be a really organized and well equipped rogue pirate ship. I'm not sure these exist. The closest analogues are small open boats of armed Somalis and actual military ships.
Most likely, the platforms would be of little value to a pirate. The few that are going to be worth hitting will probably be too hard to hit.
The only well-armed ships are navies. Yes, a navy or an ICBM could easily destroy a seastead. They could also easily destroy Monaco, Vanuatu, Dominica, or any other small country. The world is full of sitting ducks, yet we don't see them "finished" very often, because there is little profit in it for a government and it is politically unpopular.
Reason: There will never be new country on the ocean in a world full of nation states.
The reason there are lawless international waters 13 miles offshore is because there is no threat to incumbent nations there.
The moment Seasteads start floating around, the UN will abolish the concept of international waters thus rendering the entire project worthless.
Putting a Seastead in someone's 200 mile EEZ, with that country's blessing, to run a private marine park, offshore free trade zone, etc. seems quite viable. By being physically separate and potentially mobile, a host country would have a lot less ability or desire to regulate beyond basic things. There are also some inherent advantages to an offshore platform in a marine environment (there are some concrete platforms floating in the Great Barrier Reef of Australia to support scuba diving operations already).
TSI does a decent job of splitting the technical (difficult, but reasonably feasible, and predictable) from the political, compared to most free-state projects in the past.
http://articles.privateislandsonline.com/island-industry/rep...
Didn't turn out too well.
I'm sure at least one of these guys might enjoy the challenge of making it hospitable :)
You'll still get taxed on your income generated in other countries.
If they ever do start acknowledging claims, Russia or China or the USA will claim whatever you squat on, and what will you do to prevent them from that? If they wanted to build a giant monument their awesomeness, how would you stop them from building?
Pseudo-kingdoms need soldiers, or at the very least, advanced automated weaponry.
It's still not clear why you'd want to, though. I doubt you could avoid much in taxes, and it's really unpleasantly cold down there. On the upside you'd probably be safe from pirates.
edit: A nice yacht is probably cheaper per square foot than an Antarctic base, and tends to have much better weather.
2,060 km2 (795 sq mi) of unclaimed land next to Egypt.
Don't you think that would be a magnet to just about every terrorist organization in the world? Not to mention if it is anywhere near East Africa I would image a few boat loads of real pirates turning up pretty quickly - even in a lot of what would look like safer neighborhoods I would expect you would start getting a lot of attention from organized crime and other very scary people.
1) Starting their own country wouldn't offer them much they don't already have.
2) There's no unclaimed land. That means you either need to build your own land (which is really expensive) or take it off someone else, which probably makes you a criminal around the world and might ruin your life already.
3) Once you've got the land, you've got to defend it, and mercs[1] + military hardware gets expensive really fast.
4) Even then, the nasty things you'd have to do to establish a country and get it recognized around the world will probably cripple your commercial activities.
5) They don't necessarily have much ability for governing/retaining power.
[1] No-one is going to die for Gatestan out of patriotism.