News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by semi-extrinsic on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:18AM (#19469723)
Why "unfortunately"? Would it be better if every company that does a bad thing was forced to just close shop?

If that be the case I'm pretty sure we'll have to shut down Tesla within a couple of years over their "Autopilot"/"Full Self Driving" claims.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by akanet on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:22AM (#19469739)
"Do a bad thing" is a pretty major understatement of the degree of criminality we're talking about here. Over-representing the capabilities of Autopilot is a totally different thing that embedding a defeat device to defraud every national regulatory agency.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by blattimwind on Saturday March 23, 2019 @07:12AM (#19469980)
If you excluded every manufacturer that did this at some point, you're pretty much only left with Tesla and probably some other smaller new EV companies.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by hndamien on Saturday March 23, 2019 @08:39AM (#19470198)
This speaks volumes.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by blattimwind on Saturday March 23, 2019 @11:12AM (#19470760)
... and I wouldn't be all that sure that none of the EV folks aren't cheating on their range tests ...
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by natch on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:32AM (#19470376)
>Over-representing the capabilities of Autopilot is a totally different thing

Citation needed. They didn’t do that.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by freeflight on Saturday March 23, 2019 @12:41PM (#19471155)
As convenient as it might be to burn VW at the stake for this as the "sacrificial lamb", that misses the point.

Because VW ain't the only ones who engage in these kinds of tactics, by now it seems like it's some kind of "open industry secret" how manufacturers try to get the best measuring results during environmental testing for those good ratings, which directly translates to good marketing.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by xedeon on Saturday March 23, 2019 @06:13AM (#19469860)
> embedding a defeat device to defraud every national regulatory agency.

Cite this claim.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by UncleEntity on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:00AM (#19470264)
> Cite this claim.

It is, literally, a large portion of TFA.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by natch on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:57AM (#19469827)
You may have misread what Tesla says about these technologies. They state very clearly that FSD is not here yet, and they also are very clear about the limitations of Autopilot. The problem is that people (like you, for example) mistakenly assume there are “claims” beyond the statements that are made.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by close04 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @06:26AM (#19469889)
> They state very clearly

They state it in the fineprint. This is what the Tesla Autopilot page used to say for years (this is a 1+ year old screenshot) [0]. Which part of that is accurate? How clear are they about the limitations and the real capabilities of the system? Tesla took the narrow areas where those systems can do a reasonably good job and extrapolated to the whole self-driving experience, blaming regulations for the bits that aren't really there. No autonomous system in the world at this time is capable of anything close to what a human is.

They still claim that:

> Your Tesla will figure out the optimal route, navigate urban streets (even without lane markings), manage complex intersections with traffic lights, stop signs and roundabouts, and handle densely packed freeways with cars moving at high speed

Which is patently false.

[0] https://imgur.com/a/bsgxCCn

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by xedeon on Saturday March 23, 2019 @06:32AM (#19469901)
> No, they state it in the fineprint so to speak.

Self-Driving is not even released yet, prove me wrong otherwise. What you're attempting to quote are forward looking statements. Maybe you need to read the document you linked, slowly this time.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by close04 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @07:10AM (#19469977)
I don't have to prove anything, I know they're not flat out lying [0], they're just misleading. Many drivers (ask the dead) are/were under the impression that the car can drive itself. And Tesla doesn't do much to make this distinction clear.

[0] Except for the "we'll have it next year" bit. That's just to get a little more cashflow, pretty sure not even Musk expects to have FSD ready "next year" unless it's a perpetual "next year".

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by xedeon on Saturday March 23, 2019 @08:14AM (#19470116)
> I don’t have to prove anything

You can’t just make bold claims and not back them up... Makes you look imprudent.

> Many drivers (ask the dead) are/were under the impression that the car can drive itself.

Everytime you engage Autosteer. You get a warning that says “Always keep your hands on the steering wheel” and “Be prepared to take over at any time”.

More importantly, each driver assistance update also explicitly state the capabilities and you HAVE to toggle them on. No where in the car UX or manual even suggests that it can “drive itself”.

I think it’s you have the wrong impression. Unless you’re speaking anecdotally, which is I highly doubt.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by close04 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:18AM (#19470319)
> You can’t just make bold claims and not back them up

That's not how the burden of proof works. Tesla is claiming the following:

> All new Tesla cars have the hardware needed in the future for full self-driving in almost all circumstances.

> The future use of these features without supervision is dependent on achieving reliability far in excess of human drivers as demonstrated by billions of miles of experience, as well as regulatory approval, which may take longer in some jurisdictions.

Where is the proof of that? The suggestion is that everything is in place short of regulatory approval. And it's always "next year". The result is this [0]. People genuinely believing and insisting that car can drive itself. The result is the only driver fatalities while autonomously driving were in a Tesla.

Do you see how people interpret this as "well it's there but you know, pesky regulators want to delay it by testing and stuff". If the vast swaths of internet commenters and drivers that can no longer provide an opinion is not proof enough that the statements are misleading I don't know what is [0] (again). You may see through them but it doesn't make them less misleading. That whole page is designed to give an inflated impression of the state and capabilities of the system regardless of consequences.

Other manufacturers have at least equally capable hardware and software but none make these claims, because they are misleading and will cause deaths.

What would you think if someone sold you a mobile phone claiming it's able to crack any encryption no matter how strong? Of course it might take longer than the lifetime of the universe but hey, it is possible. Not lying, just misleading. So wanna buy a phone?

[0] https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=tesla+self+driv...

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by xedeon on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:33PM (#19472471)
> People genuinely believing and insisting that car can drive itself. The result is the only driver fatalities while autonomously driving were in a Tesla.

This is hilariously false. Do you really want to prove this? Go on the teslamotorsclub.com forums or teslamotors subreddit and ask actual owners if they think the car can “drive itself”.

Link the post and I will PayPal you $1,000 if you’re right. Because at this point you’re just going around in circles.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by natch on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:45AM (#19470422)
It’s hard to discuss these things when both sides don’t have all the facts.

Just as a basic background for what happens, please try this: sit in a recent Tesla, engage autopilot, and read what it says on the screen. Also try ignoring the advice the screen gives you (pretend you didn’t read the “fine” print as you call it, and see what happens when you try to let the car drive with no input.)

Do this, then we can talk about this stuff, OK?

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by xedeon on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:39PM (#19472494)
> It’s hard to discuss these things when both sides don’t have all the facts. Just as a basic background for what happens, please try this: sit in a recent Tesla, engage autopilot, and read what it says on the screen.

My point exactly. Yet he seem to have pretty stong and absolute (albeit skewed) opinions. A true armchair quarterback.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by close04 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @03:08PM (#19471850)
Unless the dashboard tells me why the Tesla website and marketing (not to mention its CEO) make all the false/misleading claims I don’t think we need to talk about anything else.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by xedeon on Saturday March 23, 2019 @05:35PM (#19472478)
> Unless the dashboard tells me why the Tesla website and marketing (not to mention its CEO) make all the false/misleading claims I don’t think we need to talk about anything else.

Honest question. Do you have a short position on the stock?

[dead]
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by close04 on Sunday March 24, 2019 @11:06AM (#19476732)
Were they? As I said (I'll say again it but slower) Tesla is the only manufacturer with multiple driver fatalities while "self driving". Plus the countless crashes with no fatalities.

Either the description of the Autopilot's capabilities is misleading making drivers assume it's more capable, or drivers with severe comprehension issues are over represented among Tesla drivers, to the point where they actually kill themselves. The car or the driver have a problem. You pick.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by xedeon on Sunday March 24, 2019 @01:46PM (#19477620)
> Were they?

Yes, many times.

> Tesla is the only manufacturer with multiple driver fatalities while "self driving". Plus the countless crashes with no fatalities.

Again it's pretty obvious that you have no idea what you're talking about here. That statement is not only grossly false but also ignorant (seem like a theme with your comments). For one, autopilot features are really just glorified Lane Keeping Assist System (LKAS) and Traffic-Aware Cruise Control (TACC).

They are one for the umpteenth time NOT "self-driving" any Tesla owner knows this (prove me wrong otherwise my $1K offer still stands). There are ZERO indications that even remotely suggests that the car is "self-driving.

From the moment you take delivery and they show you the features of the car, to turning on each individual driver assist features and actually engaging TACC and LKAS. Zero, nada, none. So stop saying this. Go find any Tesla owner discussion group/forum on the internet and ask actual owners. You will quickly see how wrong your assumptions are.

More importantly, TKAS and LKAS have been around for a while now and the only significant difference with Tesla's version is the auto lane change functionality.

Below are just a few other safety systems that have TKAS and LKAS:

1. Honda Sensing 2. Toyota Safety Sense™ (TSS) 3. AcuraWatch 3. Some Mercedes Benz vehicles with the Driver Assistance Package

There have been plenty of fatalities with these systems as well. But guess what? you don't see them in the news.

Some Tesla owners on reddit even talked about the differences with these systems from their anecdotal experiences and found that Tesla's implementation was better (these are actual owners not marketing BS). i.e. Some won't even give any visual/audible warnings when disengaging.

https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/6em5kz/non_tes...

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by natch on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:10AM (#19470301)
No, you are just proving my point.

The screenshot is talking about future functionality that is not released yet, but you are mistakenly evaluating it as patently false when you have absolutely no way to know, since it isn’t released yet.

“System B will do X” is not invalidated by observing that System A does not currently do X.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by close04 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @09:55AM (#19470446)
> but you are mistakenly evaluating it as patently false when you have absolutely no way to know, since it isn’t released yet.

What makes it patently false is that Tesla hasn't proved it even after claiming "next year" for several years now. Even worse, they still don't and can't know if the system will ever be able to perform as described or if the hardware is enough as claimed. If the party making a claim doesn't have the proof for themselves then how can the statement be true today, when they claim it? They are selling today's assumption as a certainty. It doesn't say "we hope" or "be believe" or "it might". They say "it will" with no reservation and no proof available anywhere. That is the falsehood.

And just as a sidenote, the company that was providing Tesla with the hardware and knowhow when the statements were originally made, Mobileye, ended the partnership in 2016 because they did not believe their own systems are able to fulfill the promise. That shows that promises were already made once without Tesla having any proof.

Any other company doing this and people would be all over them with accusations. But Tesla has great PR, it is actually working for a better future, and people love a good cause enough to disregard the dirt under the rug.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by natch on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:19AM (#19470532)
This is all a bunch of fake outrage. Words are written. Some people skip reading important parts of those words, and then blame Tesla for their own laziness or poor reading skills. This is basically what you’re doing, although maybe more as an apologist for others who don’t care to read or pay attention.

I’m not even talking about fine print. The stuff that covers this is all very straightforward and not fine print at all. People should take responsibility and read what is actually said.

The outrage should be directed at people who make wild misinterpretations of perfectly reasonable statements.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by close04 on Saturday March 23, 2019 @03:39PM (#19472002)
Yes... it perfectly reasonable to make claims that even the supplier of your HW refutes. Really says a lot about your willingness to say whatever it takes to get more PR and push a few more sales.

In the meantime Tesla is the only company with autonomous driving driver fatalities. Multiple. Unless you’re going to claim Tesla buyers are more predisposed to... laziness and inability to process information, then something is definitely wrong in the way the system is presented. Something other manufacturers and all their buyers get right. Mostly all others insist overpromising and underdelivering can be dangerous.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by natch on Saturday March 23, 2019 @10:28PM (#19473784)
They are not autonomous driving fatalities. They can’t be, because there is simply no autonomous driving. You are very confused. Autopilot is not autonomous driving.
Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by close04 on Sunday March 24, 2019 @11:14AM (#19476778)
It's self driving. It's not L5 but the car was taking the decisions in that limited set of conditions.

And that's the whole point, the car is unable to take the correct decisions but people still trust it to do so. Why would they? Unless you'll tell me Tesla drivers are intellectually challenged then it must be that they somehow get the wrong impression of what the car can do.

How come this doesn't happen to any other manufacturer building cars with this type of limited automation? I see a some people victoriously claiming I've been proven wrong yet all avoid answering this direct question. If nobody can explain why so many Tesla drivers are suicidal then the blame must lie with the system or the way it's described.

Re:How the car industry hid the truth about diesel emissions by natch on Monday March 25, 2019 @06:18AM (#19481353)
>If nobody can explain why so many Tesla drivers are suicidal then the blame must lie with the system or the way it's described.

I see. You are looking to explain the facts and you have three theories here. 1) Suicidal drivers; 2) Bad system; 3) Bad system description.

Let’s just agree it’s not #1. Effectively suicidal you could say, but let’s agree they were (likely) not actually intending suicide.

Number 2 is ruled out because the system was never designed to be fully unmonitored... blaming it would be like blaming a seatbelt for an injury sustained by someone who wears the seatbelt incorrectly.

Number 3 seems like a likely possibility on the face of it, but the system is actually pretty well described in practice so I would suggest another, fourth, possibility which does not appear on your list:

4) The drivers were imperfect humans who, as some will do, failed to heed the ample safety warnings and were unlucky enough to encounter situations where this failure led to disastrous results.

I’ll note this kind of thing happens all the time in cars without autopilot as well. You can point out that in those cases an autopilot system was not in the picture, but that’s a circular argument... of course it wasn’t. People will sometimes be foolish. No system can protect all fools all the time. Expecting otherwise is unreasonable. You’re just blaming Tesla because its autopilot is the first / most prominent such system that has been rolled out to production vehicles. Of course there will be a few foolish people amongst the hundreds of thousands of Tesla drivers. That’s on the people, not the system or the description. Nobody ever promised autopilot would be a perfect nanny that can fend off all dangers and control all human behaviors.

>nobody can explain why so many Tesla drivers are suicidal

Not suicidal. Just foolish. And not “so many.” We are talking about a handful of incidents, in fact fewer than can be counted on one hand.

Fake outrage.