If I want to run a FOSS project, I might not be interested in the details of managing distribution and security of some server (one-click software rather than setting up some server myself)
I also .... kinda don’t care about account management (=> using something that people already use is nice)
Peer to peer isn’t actually interesting for almost any aspect of a project. The main advantage is availability, but it doesn’t help (and can hinder) other objectives of running a FOSS project.
I think that there’s a way to get most of the goodies (see GitLab... kinda), though it’s a hell of a lot more work than “just send email patches around!” I think sourcehut is getting there though
Pirate Bay for torrents, Napster, GitHub for git, ... They do fix a problem.
I actually think that Microsoft is the lesser evil in this case. They will add azure flows, but not enforce them. I believe they will also embrace other services ( not the embrace and extend way though. The Enterprise culture makes them support things for a very long term ( even codeplex still let's you download old archives)
They reinvented themselves with the mantra: developers.
Making them pissed off for using something else is not their mantra any more ( them = developers outside the dot Net/ windows ecosystem)
And yes, as each business, they also want profits. But the way to do it has changed.
Ps. Google code also let's you download the old repos ( just checked it)
Edit 2: the only thing I can think of is that the evolution of Windows forms didn't go as planned and got changed to "more web". As a result, WPF ( I think) is in maintenance mode and considered as feature complete untill it's fully integrated in. Net core ( which was a hard change because of differences in graphic rendering cross platform). The only thing that got deprecated here was Silverlight, which was a correct and hard decision.
Also of note: github blocks indie search crawlers, contributing to search engine monoculture. Moreover, your user's clicks are captured by a company with an incentive to push for privacy invasion as a business model going forward. So, indeed, F/OSS projects using gh should definitely reconsider, if they haven't already done so when MS bought gh.