News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by Nursie on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:03AM (#19453123)
> With Bitcoin it's much harder to get a loan with near-0 interest rates, as money can't be printed out of thin air.

But a new cryptocurrency can be. The network effect is literally all a specific chain has going for it. Though of course with an 'official' chain that's not the case.

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by xiphias2 on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:12AM (#19453256)
Sure, you can create a currency which can have bail outs by having a magic private key for yourself, just like how central banks work right now.

Good luck getting other people to use that currency though :)

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by rrdharan on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:15AM (#19453284)
Isn't that exactly what ethereum eventually demonstrated via the DAO fork?

The core developer team effectively wields this power, but people still seem to be using their currency.

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by xiphias2 on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:24AM (#19453386)
Ethereum has very different philosophy (just as an example it's supposed to be an universal computer, not a cryptocurrency).

I'm in the Bitcoin camp, and I think that the Ethereum developers are not careful enough with the changes they make to a multibillion dollar system, but you are right, many people like to use it.

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by throwawaylolx on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:34AM (#19453506)
> Ethereum has very different philosophy (just as an example it's supposed to be an universal computer, not a cryptocurrency).

Etherum doesn't have much of a philosophy. They have recently been pivoting away from a "universal computer" rhetoric to one focused on "decentralized finance."

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by feanaro on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:36AM (#19453542)
Didn't Ethereum simply make a fork of the client and the rest of the network agreed to use that fork?
Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by throwawaylolx on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:50AM (#19453757)
No, Ethereum didn't fork the client. The main client was patched to automatically use the bailout-chain, and anyone who upgraded their node was thus switched to the new chain.

But this is merely a red herring: Ethereum was centralized from day 1 due to their distribution method, and the DAO is just a natural consequence of centralization.

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by feanaro on Thursday March 21, 2019 @02:13PM (#19455508)
Perhaps I didn't quite phrase that as clearly as I could have. I meant to say that changing a client incompatibly is effectively forking the blockchain.

Naturally, you still have to be mindful about whether or not you want to upgrade to software you do not wish to use. Upgrading to the new version and continuing to use it was a conscious decision to continue using that branch of the chain, made by the majority.

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by throwawaylolx on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:20AM (#19453344)
Yes, people use central banks as well. However, if you want to opt-out of centralized control, you have the option to use Bitcoin instead of fiat, Ethereum, or any other coin that had an ICO.
Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by Nursie on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:23AM (#19453379)
That's not actually a response to my point though. My point was that the limited quantity of BTC is really only 'limited' by perception. Sure, the amount on the BTC chain is limited, but copy the software, boot up a new chain and you have another 21 mil to play with.

The reason the one has value and the other doesn't is pretty much down to brand recognition/network effect.

Though as I also said - in a central bank situation where a single chain is mandated, that's less of a concern.

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by root_axis on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:39AM (#19453603)
Exactly. The BCH hard fork is a great demonstration of this. After the split the total value of BTC + BCH exceeded BTC before the split; that means new coins were printed out of thin air.
Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by Geee on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:48AM (#19453728)
Well, you're still wrong. If someone wants a loan in BTC, they don't want your fake BTC.

Infinite blockchains argument is not valid. Blockchains need to be secure and you can't get billions worth of mining power or POS investments from thin air. Certain blockchains have value because of this security and also from network effects. Both of these effects favor existing blockchains, not new ones. Strongest get stronger.

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by Nursie on Thursday March 21, 2019 @02:51PM (#19455982)
> If someone wants a loan in BTC, they don't want your fake BTC.

Which is purely down to branding.

>Infinite blockchains argument is not valid.

Because you say so?

> Blockchains need to be secure and you can't get billions worth of mining power or POS investments from thin air.

These follow value, they don't create it.

Re:Bitcoin Spreads Like a Virus by proy24 on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:29AM (#19460064)
Is that true to most companies in tech? I mean granted google has ip behind its tech...but basic versions of social networks like facebook, reddit, twitter could be cloned by a couple of teenagers in a basement in a week.