Re:Scientists rise up against statistical significance
by wallace_f on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @08:50PM
(#19448426)
Is saying it "meshes with specific other results" just a signal of cognitive bias?
I personally would confidently guess there are unconscious faculties in the mind, but I dont see how this experiment is remarkable in proving this, see here(1). Is it not an equally likely conclusion that the brain takes a few hundreds of a second to develop a conscious decision? Actually, the inverse of that is what would be remarkable.
Re:Scientists rise up against statistical significance
by azernik on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @10:05PM
(#19448735)
The issue isn't whether a decision is unconscious or conscious. It's that we often think that we've made a conscious decision when the decision process we narrate for ourselves and others is provably impossible.
I should have phrased the original as "it is a relatively weak example of this specific set of experimental results".
I'm not sure philosophically whether our inability to understand our decisions undermines our free will, but it certainly undermines any ability to consciously prime ourselves to make certain decisions - hard to have that feedback loop when you don't even know what decision you made!