Atheism is about belief, agnosticism is about knowledge.
They are complementary.
You can be atheist/agnostic, theist/agnostic, atheist/gnostic, theist/gnostic. It's a matrix.
Also there are two flavors of atheism: those that believe there is no god (a minority in my opinion, and that position requires a burden of proof).
And there are atheists who simply reject the claim that there is a god. They say there might be a god, or maybe not, but that people who claim there is a god have not presented enough evidence for that claim to be accepted.
If I look at a grass field and tell you there is an even number of blades of grass in that field, you are not going to accept my claim.
Does that mean you think that number is odd?
No. You're just saying I have not provided evidence for my claim, and therefore, you do not accept it. But you are not taking any position yourself.
That's atheism.
Atheism: belief there is no god.
Agnosticism: we don't, we can't, know whether a god exists or not.
> They say there might be a god, or maybe not,
This by definition is not atheism, it's agnosticism.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/atheism
https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/atheism
You also seem to be strafing your dictionary claim and then ignoring anyone who shows that you’re incorrect. That’s a poor way to debate.
Knowledge is a subset of belief. Both are defined by different words: (a)theism is about belief, (a)gnosticism is about knowledge.
The first dictionary hit I get on atheism matches my claim:
"disbelief or lack of belief in the existence of God or gods."
Traditionally, most people understood "atheism" to mean a positive disbelief in God – either, you are certain God doesn't exist, or at least you think the non-existence of God is significantly more likely than God's existence. People who are close to 50-50 on God's existence would call themselves "agnostics" not "atheists".
In the last few decades, there has been an increasing tendency to define "atheism" as a mere absence of positive belief in God, so that the 50-50 folks get classified as "atheists" as well.
To read Geisler's remarks charitably, I think we have to keep in mind that he is likely using the older definition of "atheism" rather than the newer one.
Theists put forth a claim: god exists. They need to prove that claim. It's not up to anyone else.
Atheism is simply looking at the evidence that has been provided for the claim. It is non-existent. Therefore it cannot be said that god exists. You need to prove the claims you put forward.
Note, it's not 50/50 (like agnosticism says). Atheism doesn't say: one side says a teapot exists out in space, and another side says it doesnt.. so it's 50/50. If there's no evidence of the teapot, there's no reason to believe it is there. That's atheism.
No, they don't. The whole point is believe without proof. It's called "faith."
It's completely consistent with the scientific method.
Said to be coined around 2003: https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/489221/word-for-...
- Atheist: Believes there is no God.
- Agnostic: Doesn't know/isn't sure/doesn't care if there is a God.
- Anti-theist: Is against the mere idea that there is a God.
That may have changed in the intervening decades, and with the rise of the internet, the term "atheist" seems to have changed in popular culture, often to suit a particular person's views or vocabulary. A lot of internet atheists strike me as anti-theists. But that's not a common term.