News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by JamesBarney on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @12:07AM (#19438876)
This article is filled with large claims that run completely counter to all economic intuition and evidence we've gathered over the last century like "low interest rates hurt businesses and cause slower growth", "large companies buying startups for lots of money hurts start up creation".

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence but the article provides none, and the study's the article links to are behind a paywall.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by paulpauper on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @01:20AM (#19439243)
The shape of the curve matters. In high interest rate environments, large companies borrow at a higher rate rate relative to smaller companies because the curve is flatter. In a low-interest rate environment, the curve is very steep, so large companies borrow cheap but small companies only borrow just slightly lower rate than they do in a high interest rate environments. Large companies are able to borrow at rates closer to the fed funds rate whereas small business borrows at am much higher rate. Low interest rates and cheap borrowing allows large businesses to expand and possibly crowd out smaller businesses, that have to borrow at much more unfavorable rates.
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by JamesBarney on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @02:12AM (#19439485)
Why does the steepness of the yield curve influence the interest rates small versus large companies get?

Are you saying that if a big company can borrow at 'fed rate' + 2% and a small company can only borrow at 'fed rate' + 6% that as the fed rate gets smaller the relative differences in the borrowing rates increases so 8% vs 12% isn't as big of an advantage as 3% vs 7%?

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by Fjolsvith on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:58AM (#19440203)
From the viewpoint of the small business owner, I still have to come up with the 4% difference out of my profit margin. If I'm competing with a big corporation, that is a significant disadvantage.
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by navigatesol on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @06:32AM (#19440695)
It comes out of their profit margin too, though. And I'll bet the margins of good, small businesses are as good or better than large businesses.

Of course, large businesses can generally borrow at lower rates, but that's the way "risk" works.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by j15t on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @10:27AM (#19442536)
Are you talking about the yield curve or credit spreads?

Either way, as far as I understand they are independent variables to the absolute value of federal fund rate -- what matters more is the stage in the business cycle.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by Alex3917 on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @12:58AM (#19439127)
If business A can't borrow money at any price, and business B can effectively borrow unlimited amounts of money for free, then how is it counter to all economic intuition than business B would have an advantage over business A?
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by JamesBarney on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @02:14AM (#19439496)
Of course all things being equal a company that can borrow effectively unlimited amounts of money for free has an advantage or one that can't borrow.

But specifically how does that relate to start-ups and hurting growth?

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by garmaine on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @01:06AM (#19439174)
Generally speaking startups don't borrow money to finance themselves.
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by thinkingkong on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @01:10AM (#19439188)
Thats completely untrue. They just dont borrow money from a traditional bank. Lots of growth is actually fueled by debt.
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by navigatesol on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @06:34AM (#19440712)
>They just dont borrow money from a traditional bank.

I'd go a step further and say the vast majority of startups borrow money from traditional banks, through home equity, business loans or credit cards.

The startup world is far larger than the stuff we read about on Demo Day.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by Alex3917 on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @01:12AM (#19439203)
Because they can't. Most people would be far less inclined to sell equity in their company if they could get a loan on fair terms that wasn't secured by their personal assets.

If you watch the videos on Sweetbridge, reducing the WACC for startups and small businesses is one of the main promises of DLT.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by navigatesol on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @06:37AM (#19440719)
>if they could get a loan on fair terms that wasn't secured by their personal assets.

What constitutes a "fair rate", though?

Despite popular opinion, banks are pretty damn good at assessing risk. The fact of the matter is, most small business fails. The rates reflect that.

Sweetbridge looks interesting, but the risk falls somewhere, even if more diffuse.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by Alex3917 on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @11:27AM (#19443132)
> The fact of the matter is, most small business fails. The rates reflect that.

OK but if you look at only the small businesses that are going to go on to succeed and be around for the next couple hundred years, they still can't borrow at the same rates as Apple or whatever.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @12:34PM (#19443858)
Because nobody knows which ones they are. If the banks knew which small businesses would be around for a couple hundred years, those small businesses could probably borrow rather cheaply today.
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by Alex3917 on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @01:12PM (#19444311)
> Because nobody knows which ones they are.

This is obviously correct. But it contradicts the idea that banks are good at assessing risk, if the closest that banks can come is lumping 100% of startups into a 'startup' bucket.

If banks really were good at assessing risk then the fact that the large tech companies have access to cheap capital wouldn't necessarily hurt startups, but that isn't actually the case.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @03:56PM (#19446197)
Banks can be good at assessing risk in general, and still be bad at assessing risk of startups. Nobody is good at assessing risk of startups.
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by charlesdm on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @07:59PM (#19448205)
Traditional banks aren't in the business of taking risks. That's not their function. They exist to finance things and that is why their upside is mostly limited.

I've personally experienced this recently trying to borrow money to acquire an asset: banks will throw money at you hand over fist, at amazingly cheap rates, if you structure things so that it's very very unlikely they will lose their money.

If you set up a company tomorrow with no assets, no cashflow, no nothing. Just an idea. And you go ask for a $100,000 loan. Why should a bank give you a loan, given most businesses fail?

It's 10 to 100x more risky to give a loan to a startup like that, than it is to give a loan to a profitable business that has existing cashflow and profits. Even if the interest rate is 20% for the startup and 3% for the established company.

Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by jldugger on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @02:20AM (#19439522)
Depends on how you view borrowing. They don't get access to fixed rates, and have to sell off promises of future revenue in exchange for money up front instead. It's all financing in the end, whether you get it from bond issuance or equity issuance.
Re:Startups Lose in a Low-Rate World, and the Fed Is Blaming... by cimmanom on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @08:53AM (#19441511)
Maybe it makes it easier to start a startup and get funded, but more difficult to succeed in competition with the big guys?