Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders
by jacquesm on Friday November 26, 2010 @12:18PM
(#1942761)
For that to be true in individual cases you'd have to come up with some pretty hard evidence that a sale would indeed have been consummated.
In the case of the pirate bay the quantity is so large that some aggregate effect can be postulated without stretching credulity, and I think that is the major reason why this judgment sticks even if there is not a single item of hard proof of any lost sale directly caused by the pirate bay.
In that case, if you distribute say, a movie, for free without permission from the publisher, you're effectively "taking" his "money" that he would've earned from the display of his material in a controlled environment. Wouldn't that be stealing?