News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by DrJokepu on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:07AM (#1942500)
Yes it is, in my opinion. It's up to the owner of the intellectual property to decide who can have access to his or her property, not you. If you refuse to accept the conditions that's fair enough, but in that case still accessing the copyrighted material is taking something that you're not entitled to.

I don't agree with the behaviour of the recording industry or with criminalizing the general public but simply taking something that's not yours is not the right solution, in my opinion.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by jacquesm on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:40AM (#1942579)
You are missing out on the fact that 'intellectual property' is a figment of our collective imagination.

Would you respect intellectual property on the wheel or the hand axe in a stone age setting ? I know that sounds ridiculous, but intellectual property has its basis in 'information can be property' and that's so fraught with error that we would still be living in the stone age if it were true.

If you want to keep your stuff to yourself: don't publish. Have it die with you, please do not make your thoughts/writings/music/movie/whatever available to the public in order to then turn around and claim it as your own again.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by GHFigs on Friday November 26, 2010 @12:26PM (#1942776)
Would you respect intellectual property on the wheel or the hand axe in a stone age setting ?

In such a setting there was no notion of "property" at all beyond brute force. Eventually it was discovered that greater things can be accomplished when people adopt the polite fiction that taking something doesn't always make it yours.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by jacquesm on Friday November 26, 2010 @12:34PM (#1942793)
Do you realize that every government in the world is basing their power on their ability to hold on to what they claim is theirs by 'brute force' and that all the laws that derive from there have this 'brute force' as their direct or indirect foundation ?

If you don't believe that then try to declare independence over your garden and claim that since you are now a sovereign state you no longer need to pay tribute to the country that now surrounds yours.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by GHFigs on Friday November 26, 2010 @06:14PM (#1943629)
I'm confused and disappointed by this comment. I can't decide if what I wrote was that unclear or if you're just flaming me, as I didn't say anything about sovereignty, anything about law not having foundation in force, or anything about desiring to declare the independence of my garden. I thought we were talking about individual property rights and have had the rug pulled out from under my feet.

Though it feels like I'm bringing a pen to a flamethrower fight, I'll attempt to clarify.

In describing property as a "polite fiction" I am acknowledging that it is not real. Brute force is as real as it ever was, but in practice the abstraction of property means it is usually the option of last resort. We've all benefited from that. To wit, I consider the present notion by contrast a few degrees beyond (more advanced than) brute force, though you are right to say that it is not beyond (free of) brute force.

So, to venture back to the original context from which we've so far strayed: although you try to cast the concept of intellectual property in an absurd light by putting it into an era of development in which it did not and could not exist, it remains true that the more fundamental concept of property was crucial to the same development beyond that era you claim intellectual property would have prevented. We grew by adopting a fiction, and now have an abundance of recorded history indicating that being a "figment of our collective imagination" is not a bad thing when it reflects the human perception of value better than reality. I trust you can see the parallel in the three centuries that ownership of a book has been distinct from the ownership of a copy of the book, or that at the very least you would not regard our intellectual development in that time as having languished.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by Tycho on Friday November 26, 2010 @07:29PM (#1943853)
It's not really a fiction, it's merely recognizing that humans fundamentally need to (be able to) use their minds in order to survive, must use logic, and that the only logical way to deal with other humans is therefore mutual non-aggression.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by griftah on Friday November 26, 2010 @11:12AM (#1942628)
All human rights are "figments of our collective imagination". Should we abolish them too?
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by jacquesm on Friday November 26, 2010 @11:22AM (#1942644)
They follow some logic and can be deduced from first principles.

We would not have culture or have achieved the level of society that we have if 'intellectual property' were the normal mode and could be deduced from first principles.

Copyright and patents are supposed to foster creation and innovation but it seems they are hindering rather than helping our development in these areas.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by shadowfox on Friday November 26, 2010 @12:22PM (#1942768)
> They follow some logic and can be deduced from first principles

Well. Some of these follow when you accept certain axioms and work from there. Not everyone accepts those axioms (at at least the same ones), if the vast variance in "human rights" across the globe is any indication.

Now of course it can be argued that only a few countries in the "civilized western world" understand logic and can come up with the proper first principles. (People have told me that)

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by baddox on Friday November 26, 2010 @03:36PM (#1943227)
It's logically fine to reject axioms. You could argue, for example, that torture is morally good because you disagree with the axiom that suffering is bad. That's logically consistent, and logic alone is built on axioms and therefore cannot discern which axioms are "better."
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by jacquesm on Friday November 26, 2010 @03:47PM (#1943260)
The solution for that is to reverse positions and have the consequences of your logic performed on you.

In a good system you don't care on which side of the ledger you're on, which is something that that same logic would allow you to deduce.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by lt on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:13AM (#1942509)
He's not saying that piracy isn't wrong. He's saying that the act is called copyright infringement, not theft.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by DrJokepu on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:14AM (#1942513)
I know, that's what I was talking about in the first part of my post. I had to add the the second part just to make sure that I'm not misunderstood.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by axod on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:17AM (#1942524)
> " but simply taking something that's not yours is not the right solution, in my opinion."

I think that was his point - you're not taking something that's not yours.

Say I take a photo of your cup, then feed the 3d image into a 3d printer, so that I have an exact replica of your cup, I haven't stolen your cup have I.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by Kliment on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:24AM (#1942540)
It could be argued that you have stolen the design, in as far as the concept of stealing applies. Just as if you download a movie ripped from a dvd, there is no argument about whether you have stolen the DVD. The content is separable from the medium.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by axod on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:41AM (#1942583)
Again, IMHO the definition of stealing supposes that you have deprived the previous owner of something.

I don't think we should use 'stealing' to apply to 'design' or any type of non-concrete property.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by Kliment on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:44AM (#1942590)
I agree with you, and indeed that is where the argument lies. You have deprived the owner of the design of their right to determine how that design is distributed, in a sense. Whether there is such a thing as legitimate ownership of intellectual property and whether this right in itself is legitimate is a different question. All I ask is that we do not conflate ownership of the copy with ownership of the rights to the design.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by axod on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:54AM (#1942609)
>> You have deprived the owner of the design of their right to determine how that design is distributed, in a sense.

But the whole notion of 'right to determine how IP is distributed' is an artificial, and very recent creation. Why should people have such rights? Why do we need them when we functioned fine as a society for so many millennia without them.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by Kliment on Friday November 26, 2010 @11:55AM (#1942714)
Sure. And I'm in no way arguing for that notion. What I am arguing against is confusing the theft of a copy or object with interfering with said right, legitimate or not. My point is that you have not deprived the owner of the copy/object/medium of anything, but that is a straw man. The real question is whether these rights, which are in fact being violated by the reproduction, are legitimate. I agree with you that they are generally not, from my own moral perspective at least.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by griftah on Friday November 26, 2010 @11:17AM (#1942636)
The whole notion of 'freedom' is an artificial and very recent creation. We functioned fine as a society for so many millennia with slavery.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by axod on Friday November 26, 2010 @11:53AM (#1942712)
Well trolled.

In actual fact, there's more 'slaves' today than at any time in history.

For one, legalized slavery in the US - prisoners are forced to manufacture household appliances, number plates, military uniforms etc. If they refuse, they get solitary confinement and other punishments.

Perhaps the concept of 'freedom' is a good one, but it doesn't map in any way to the real world.

It's not like they created the concept of 'freedom' and then slavery ended.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by GHFigs on Friday November 26, 2010 @12:46PM (#1942821)
The means of mass reproduction (e.g. the printing press) have not existed for nearly so long as you seem to think.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by baddox on Friday November 26, 2010 @03:42PM (#1943242)
A definition of traditional (tangible, physical) property is easier to formalize than your vague notion of a "design." Basically, traditional property is an item with mass that is scarce (can only be in one location at a time).

What's your definition of a design? If I simply think of "the first prime number with 500 billion decimal digits," do I instantly command the right to control the distribution of that number?

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by Kliment on Saturday November 27, 2010 @04:46AM (#1944693)
I'd define a design as the information sufficient to produce a copy that is to some degree recognizable as the original (in terms of visuals, aesthetic effect, etc). An ornamental cup is separable in a sense, you can make a matching saucer with the same pattern of ornamentation, and you can also make a cup without the ornament on it. In one case it is a copy of the function, in the other a copy of the design. There has been some degree of discussion about this in relation to the 3d printing revolution that is currently happening (which I'm very happy to be part of, my printers are happily replicating). Here's some links if you're interested in the sense in which "design" is used in relation to physical objects:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1689527 (Focused on UK and European laws) http://www.publicknowledge.org/it-will-be-awesome-if-they-do... (Focused on US IP laws)

I do not believe there is a counter-argument to the "treating data as large numbers makes it ridiculous to assert control over it". I agree with you on this point. Unfortunately, the law will need to be modernized to take that into account, and that has not yet happened.

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by prodigal_erik on Friday November 26, 2010 @02:24PM (#1943045)
It's in society's interest to compensate creators for their work. But it was a terrible idea to grant them the power to control which other people use that work, and how. It should be work for hire, or supported by a tax, or anything that doesn't so severely damage the work's value to society and especially to other creators.