News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by baddox on Friday November 26, 2010 @03:42PM (#1943242)
A definition of traditional (tangible, physical) property is easier to formalize than your vague notion of a "design." Basically, traditional property is an item with mass that is scarce (can only be in one location at a time).

What's your definition of a design? If I simply think of "the first prime number with 500 billion decimal digits," do I instantly command the right to control the distribution of that number?

Re:Court affirms jail time for Pirate Bay founders by Kliment on Saturday November 27, 2010 @04:46AM (#1944693)
I'd define a design as the information sufficient to produce a copy that is to some degree recognizable as the original (in terms of visuals, aesthetic effect, etc). An ornamental cup is separable in a sense, you can make a matching saucer with the same pattern of ornamentation, and you can also make a cup without the ornament on it. In one case it is a copy of the function, in the other a copy of the design. There has been some degree of discussion about this in relation to the 3d printing revolution that is currently happening (which I'm very happy to be part of, my printers are happily replicating). Here's some links if you're interested in the sense in which "design" is used in relation to physical objects:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1689527 (Focused on UK and European laws) http://www.publicknowledge.org/it-will-be-awesome-if-they-do... (Focused on US IP laws)

I do not believe there is a counter-argument to the "treating data as large numbers makes it ridiculous to assert control over it". I agree with you on this point. Unfortunately, the law will need to be modernized to take that into account, and that has not yet happened.