News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model Y by gamblor956 on Friday March 15, 2019 @12:29PM (#19401212)
It's quite possible to support the goal and criticize the players, especially when those players repeatedly fail to execute and use the lofty goal as an excuse for their failings instead of learning from their mistakes and getting better.

And why should Tesla get the credit for making green cars a thing? True credit belongs to Toyota for introducing the Prius 2 decades ago when gas was king and getting consumers to see alternative engines as viable options, and to California for its green vehicles incentives for making possible the financial structure that has kept Tesla alive.

Re:Tesla Model Y by darawk on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:26PM (#19401966)
> It's quite possible to support the goal and criticize the players, especially when those players repeatedly fail to execute

Repeatedly fail to execute? They've successfully rolled out several wildly popular fully electric cars. They've succeeded in making electric cars cool.

> And why should Tesla get the credit for making green cars a thing? True credit belongs to Toyota for introducing the Prius 2 decades ago when gas was king and getting consumers to see alternative engines as viable options, and to California for its green vehicles incentives for making possible the financial structure that has kept Tesla alive.

Toyota succeeded on one side of the equation: Creating the first commercially successful eco-car. Tesla succeeded in making them cool, and appealing to people who like cars. You need both of these things if you want to actually replace gas-powered cars.

Re:Tesla Model Y by gamblor956 on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:44PM (#19402160)
Repeatedly fail to execute? They've successfully rolled out several wildly popular fully electric cars. They've succeeded in making electric cars cool.

They had hundreds of cars stuck in port in Europe and China over paperwork errors. In the US, they had hundreds of cars stuck in holding lots because they failed to arrange for transportation to their final destinations, or because they failed to coordinate pickups with the buyers, or both. They have a billion-dollar-plus assembly line that sits unused because it doesn't work. There are hundreds of Teslas stuck in shop because Tesla can't manufacture the parts they need for those repairs (and there are no third-party parts suppliers to take the load). They've missed nearly every deadline they've set for themselves, not because the goals are unreachable but because they've overestimated their capabilities or underestimated the difficulty of the task or both. They've paid millions in fines to the SEC, and they're likely to pay millions more soon, all because they can't get their CEO to use Buffer or a similar app/process that would let them review his many inane tweets before review. Their are credible reports of on-the-job injuries swept under the table to avoid worker's comp claims.

Tesla in theory could, and should, be a wonderful company, but that's not the Tesla that actually exists today. And that theoretical Tesla probably won't exist as long as Musk remains in control.

Re:Tesla Model Y by confiscate on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:15PM (#19402547)
Ya but in the end they always delivered. The 35k model 3, scaling up manufacturing to over 5k cars a week, not going bankrupt. They missed the deadlines but eventually they delivered as promised.

Why is missing their self-imposed deadlines such a big deal to you, but the fact that they delivered later on, something that you gloss over entirely? Those were huge goals that they delivered on, that most critics said was near-impossible to do.

It wasn't that long ago that critics were calling Elon a fraud for offering an electric car for 35k, that it can never be done because the cost to build one cannot be under 35k, and that Elon was a car salesman scamming people for pre-order money. And now it's done, the 35k model 3 is delivered, and people are focused on what, missed deadlines they self-imposed in the past? Is that really the most important issue here?

Re:Tesla Model Y by seem_2211 on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:25PM (#19403272)
I eagerly await the rocket car we were promised.
Re:Tesla Model Y by gamblor956 on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:47PM (#19404140)
It wasn't that long ago that critics were calling Elon a fraud for offering an electric car for 35k, that it can never be done because the cost to build one cannot be under 35k, and that Elon was a car salesman scamming people for pre-order money.

No one said that Tesla could "never" offer a Model 3 for $35k. There was a lot of chatter about them not being able to do so on anywhere close to the timeline Tesla claimed they would, and some of that came from Tesla itself. As recently as 2018 Elon Musk said that offering the Model 3 for $35k would bankrupt the company due to the non-existent profit margins due to the unit economics.

And while we're on that subject: Tesla also announced that in order to build the Model 3 for $35k they would need to fire the entire sales team and switch to online orders only, and eliminate referrals. So it seems that even Tesla still doesn't think that they can offer a $35k Model 3 profitably based on their existing unit economics.

And now it's done, the 35k model 3 is delivered, and people are focused on what, missed deadlines they self-imposed in the past? Is that really the most important issue here?

For investors, a company that perpetually misses deadlines is a serious, real-world problem indicative of poor planning, leadership, and management. It's one thing to miss the occasional deadline by a few days or weeks. It's another thing to miss every deadline announced, by months each time. At some point, the "self-imposed" publicly announced deadlines are just fraudulent statements intended to induce investors to buy shares of the company. CEOs have been criminally prosecuted for that in the past...another former SV darling is being prosecuted for that right now...

Re:Tesla Model Y by confiscate on Saturday March 16, 2019 @03:38AM (#19406808)
That makes no sense.

Even now you are saying above, that it's extremely hard to build and sell Model 3 for 35k. Even now you are listing many reasons why Tesla can't do it based on unit economics.

But when Tesla actually does it? What if they actually deliver? Then suddenly the 35k Model 3 is not important to you anymore.

Suddenly it's all-important to focus on "missed deadlines" of a few months.

It seems to me, critics only focus on the 35k Model 3, when it can be used as a talking point to attack Tesla. When Tesla actually delivers on the 35k Model 3, critics then focus on "missed deadlines". Critics never really cared about the 35k Model 3, they only care about attacking Tesla.

While we are on the subject, what proof do you have that a missed deadline is "intended to induce investors"? How do you know it's not just that technical difficulties?

While we are on the subject, which former SV darling are you talking about, that you are comparing Tesla to? I want to know why you think a company like Tesla, who delivered on successful projects many times and sold many cars, is somehow being compared to the company you mentioned.

Re:Tesla Model Y by darawk on Friday March 15, 2019 @05:25PM (#19404459)
> For investors, a company that perpetually misses deadlines is a serious, real-world problem indicative of poor planning, leadership, and management.

Huh, I guess it must not be worth tens of billions of dollars to investors then.

Re:Tesla Model Y by swagasaurus-rex on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:31PM (#19402727)
Criticisms like these make me think somebody is paid to smear Tesla's name.

Cars in holding lots mean this company will go under?

Re:Tesla Model Y by jessemillar on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:32PM (#19404011)
> Yes they have issues (as does literally every brand/company)...

Just wanna draw attention again to the above quote from the comment at the top of this chain. Tesla's very public and always in the news. Of course we know about all the things you mentioned in your comment. That doesn't mean Tesla is a failure or needs to be razed to the ground. Work in any company big enough or that's in the public spotlight too long and you'll find exactly these kinds of issues running rampant. I'm not excusing the issues (they definitely need to be looked at and either fixed or learned from), but I do think it's important to look at the big picture instead of getting caught up in the weeds of relatively minor but overly publicized failures.

Re:Tesla Model Y by fumar on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:21PM (#19402624)
The bulk of your argument is that Tesla mismanaged expectations and is unruly due to Elon Musk. Neither of those have stopped the company from rising to the top EV brand in a decade and helping spur the rest of the OEMs to change their automotive strategy to electric.
Re:Tesla Model Y by olau on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:29PM (#19402717)
All big companies make big mistakes. Tesla is much more open, due to their CEO, so you get to see more of the mistakes. I bet you don't track delivery mishaps for other car companies.

And Toyota didn't make an electric vehicle. They made a more efficient gas car.

Re:Tesla Model Y by m463 on Friday March 15, 2019 @08:59PM (#19405720)
This reminds me of the story of the first rifles.

They had lots of problems - they were slow to load and reload so the rate of fire was limited. They would misfire or not fire if it was raining. They were noisy so they were easy to locate. They were very inaccurate.

In all respects the longbow was a much superior technology, quiet, fast and refined.

why would anyone invest in rifles over longbows?

Re:Tesla Model Y by omar3550 on Friday March 22, 2019 @10:25AM (#19462776)
Nope, they have a plug-in all electric Prius too.
Re:Tesla Model Y by m463 on Friday March 15, 2019 @08:54PM (#19405693)
The question I ask myself is:

Is it better to do the right thing imperfectly, or the wrong thing perfectly?

Re:Tesla Model Y by DennisP on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:17PM (#19402569)
And yet, as of October, the Model 3 was the fifth best selling sedan in the U.S.
Re:Tesla Model Y by wilg on Friday March 15, 2019 @12:51PM (#19401517)
> And why should Tesla get the credit for making green cars a thing?

Well, you've awkwardly expanded the wording to make this criticism work. People give Tesla credit for making _electric_ cars a thing.

Re:Tesla Model Y by confiscate on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:23PM (#19401931)
ya but neither of those 2 things (Toyota's Prius 2, and California's green car incentives) were successful in making car manufacturers wake up and go electric. It was only when Tesla started making money that every car manufacturer is being serious about competing in this space, and even then they are behind.

Curious to see why you think credit goes to Toyota, instead of Tesla?

Re:Tesla Model Y by gamblor956 on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:54PM (#19402300)
Car companies started going electric because California and Federal fuel standards require increasing fuel efficiency on a fleet basis, and the only way to achieve those goals is now through zero-emissions vehicles like hydrogen, fuel cell, or EV. Hydrogen tech and fuel cells are still too inefficient and expensive for consumer vehicles (especially given the rare-earth materials required for high-efficiency fuel cells). Batteries happened to get much cheaper due to their increasing use in non-vehicle electronics like cell phones, which made EVs the best choice from a tech and cost perspective.

In other words, Tesla didn't actually make car manufacturers "wake up and go electric." They were going to go electric anyway because it was the obvious tech choice.

Tesla's accomplishment was to show that people were finally ready to buy green cars that looked like normal cars. (The first hybrids and EVs from Toyota and Nissan looked like normal cars, and sold horribly. Toyota and Nissan introduced the butt-ugly designs because green car buyers back in the day wanted distinctive cars to show off their greenliness.)

t neither of those 2 things (Toyota's Prius 2, and California's green car incentives) were successful in making car manufacturers wake up and go electric.

California's green car incentives and fuel efficiency requirements are what drove most car companies to invest in green car tech in the first place.

Re:Tesla Model Y by m463 on Friday March 15, 2019 @09:04PM (#19405744)
I suspect some "compliance cars" are ugly so they don't sell too many of them (since they lose money on each one).

And as to the leaf, I think it was actually modeled after the Prius, and it sold well since there are 400,000 of them out there.

Re:Tesla Model Y by confiscate on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:09PM (#19402484)
I disagree. California's green car incentive drove most companies to invest in green car tech as a toy, but it was always a hobby. A side project for R&D.

Car manufacturers never took green cars seriously and never felt the need to transition large amounts of their cars from gas to green. It was only when Tesla started making a splash that car companies took electric cars seriously.

Re:Tesla Model Y by mikestew on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:13PM (#19402525)
...were successful in making car manufacturers wake up and go electric.

Nissan Leaf owners find it cute that one would think that. And though a hybrid, I think Chevy can get a little credit on that one, too.

Re:Tesla Model Y by confiscate on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:26PM (#19402682)
Agree Nissan Leaf is a good car. It's a shame Nissan didn't sell more varieties of electric cars after the success of the Leaf. Would have been nice if they expanded on the success of the Leaf
Re:Tesla Model Y by mikestew on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:59PM (#19403629)
I wish I knew what was going on over there. First gen had some rough edges, but eight years later we're still glad we bought ours. Yet they went so long with the original design, I figured they just gave up on electric and kept the Leaf as a compliance car. Then they came out with the new one. Okay, so haven't given up. Then where's something other than a sedan? Like a Kia Sol or summat, because our next electric is going to be able to carry dogs.

So maybe Nissan got a head start, but of all the electric vehicle manufacturers Tesla is the only one moving things forward at the moment with saleable vehicles, that much I'll give them credit for.

Re:Tesla Model Y by SEJeff on Monday March 18, 2019 @11:08PM (#19427747)
Toyota has tried VERY hard to get hydrogen fuel cell cars to be "the thing" over electric vehicles. Tesla never said they wanted to make green cars a thing, they said they want to "accelerate the world's transition to sustainable energy"[1]

[1] https://www.tesla.com/about

Re:Tesla Model Y by Ari_Ugwu on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:33PM (#19402060)
I don't think Tesla wants the credit. Open source patents and a simple desire to drive adoption of technology.

I think the eye brow around the criticism is people creating a straw man to knock down.

Tesla doesn't ask for credit and only seems to celebrate the successes which are big wins for all of us regardless of whether we buy their cars or not.

If the critique is that they miss production goals, then the defense is that hey are doing remarkably well for any company attempting to overcome these challenges.

If the critique is that _because_ they are missing production goals they don't deserve praise then well....they didn't ask for praise for it so folks can just keep it and move along.