News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arts contributed $763B to US economy – more than agricult... by drumttocs8 on Friday March 15, 2019 @09:13AM (#19399345)
It would be more honest to use "Entertainment"
Re:Arts contributed $763B to US economy – more than agricult... by sametmax on Friday March 15, 2019 @10:59AM (#19400274)
Yes, a lot of movies or video games block busters, no matter how pretty they are, are closer to a rollercoaster than to a van gogh painting.

Indeed, you may have a lot of fun in the rollercoaster, and it may be aesthetically pleasing, but it's not made with an artistic intent as much as a desire to make the audience feel good and spend money.

You can call anything "art", so it's not like we can state precisely what fall out of the category. Plus I think the intent make things clearer: do you create music for the music, or do you reuse a well known working formula hopping to sell a lot of air time ?

You can mix both, of course. But when ROI is measure by those producing the thing, it's more a product than a piece of art.

Re:Arts contributed $763B to US economy – more than agricult... by beat on Friday March 15, 2019 @11:07AM (#19400340)
That's not art?

The whole point of art is to make someone feel something. And a big part of getting people to feel is playing on familiarity - for example, how much rock music can be traced directly or indirectly to Chuck Berry? Almost every guitarist has been affected by him. We all mine Chuck Berry riffs, and thus the audience can latch on to our original music and have a spark of recognition.

Product "or" art? It's not either/or.

Re:Arts contributed $763B to US economy – more than agricult... by Applejinx on Friday March 15, 2019 @11:25AM (#19400521)
Van Gogh paintings are more like a rollercoaster than most paintings :)
Re:Arts contributed $763B to US economy – more than agricult... by loopasam on Friday March 15, 2019 @10:26AM (#19399965)
indeed, from the cited article (https://www.arts.gov/news/2018/arts-contribute-more-760-bill...):

The arts saw a $20 billion trade surplus, leading with movies and TV programs and jewelry.

Re:Arts contributed $763B to US economy – more than agricult... by nabergh on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:07PM (#19401724)
It definitely would not. "Entertainment" to me would include industries like sports and gambling, which are, to most people, not art (although some gambling could be argued to be art).

I'm not sure why some people in this thread have such a strict definition of art. Hollywood blockbusters are just as much art as poetry.