News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by zipzap324 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:27PM (#19390775)
This is inaccurate. We understand much of how it works, how vision, speech, etc work but we don't understand consciousness which is quite different.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:56PM (#19391073)
Nonsense.

I’m an actual, working neuroscientist and if we’ve solved any of these things, it would be news to me (and everyone else at my institute). We have good, if coarse, knowledge of which structures are critical for which functions—-at least under some conditions. Our knowledge of how they do this is even cruder: neither the representations nor the algorithms are known with much certainty, let alone how they arise.

Let me give you a very concrete example of where we are. There’s a small nemode called C. elegans. It’s about a millimeter long and has 302 neurons. We know its complete wiring diagram, its genome, and the origin and fate of every cell (not just the neurons) in its tiny, simple body. Its behavior has been studied extensively. And yet...we can’t accurately simulate the damn thing—-and it’s not like it does a lot to begin with.

The human brain has about 86B neurons, and we know an awful lot less about them. Neither vision nor speech is remotely close to “solved” or understood. Consciousness, even in the very limited sense of “why do we fall asleep—-or need to?” is a mote off in the distance.

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by zipzap324 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:58PM (#19391108)
Where did I say anything about simulating? Are you really saying that we understand nothing about how vision works?

Also a 10 second google search pulls up papers with plenty of details about vision in the brain so I don't know why you're talking about it as if its some great mystery.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4574956/

A 1800 Page textbook on Vision Neuroscience. I'll leave it to HN to decide if we "Understand" Vision. Arbitrarily high requirements for understanding are being thrown about that would leave modern science in shambles if applied. https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/visual-neurosciences-2-vol-se...

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:30PM (#19391434)
I have a PhD in visual neuroscience, so yeah, I’m pretty comfortable saying we don’t know how it works.

We know a lot of facts, and we have some ideas about how various small things are implemented, but in terms of grand unifying theories, we’re nowhere close.

For example, suppose I showed you two gratings (think zebra stripes): a small patch and a larger one. Under some circumstances, you’ll have a harder time determining which way the big patch is oriented vs. the small one. This is true even though there’s extra information in the big patch. We think this is related to a phenomena called surround suppression, but they’re not exactly the same....and no one can agree on how surround suppression is implemented, let alone what it’s good for. This happens in primary visual cortex, which is probably the simplest—-and most extensively studied—of the visual cortical areas.

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by 0-_-0 on Friday March 15, 2019 @10:42AM (#19400114)
It's quite unrelated, but I've been wondering something about neuroscience grammar: Why is it "in primary visual cortex" and not "in _the_ primary visual cortex"?
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:01PM (#19403657)
I'm not sure!

Your innocuous question has kicked off a pretty feisty debate on my floor about whether it is 'primary' as in first (either in the circuit or evolutionarily) or primary as in most important.

If it's the former, adding a "the" seems to add some unwarranted emphasis. I think there's probably some parallelism too. Primary visual cortex is also called "V1" (as in the first cortical area involved in vision) or "Area 17" (according to a map that defines areas based on their cellular organization). While "in the primary visual cortex" sounds fine, "in the V1" and "in the Area 17" sound barbarous.

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by primo44 on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:17PM (#19402571)
And just regular grammar. "Phenomena" is plural.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:12PM (#19404791)
Got nothing for that one :-)
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:18PM (#19391883)
Re: the book added in your edit. I have it right in front of me.

As I said before, we know a lot of facts. We know a lot about the spectral sensitivity of rods and cones, and the molecular mechanism that lets them turn photons into electrical impulses. We know a little bit about where the areas that process faces are and what visual features the neurons in them respond to. We’ve got pieces, but they’re not put together.

I would say that we understand vision when we can answer a question like “How do you find a friend in a crowd?”

You can start with “When you first met, light bounced off her face and isomerized some retinal from its 11-cis to all-trans form, which caused the bound opsin to change conformation into metarhodopsin II, which activated transducin, which....” Eventually, this cascade caused electrical activity that reaches cortex. A huge set of cortical areas process visual input, and these electrochemical signals flow through all of them. We can predict V1 neurons’ activity reasonably well, less so for the downstream neurons in V2, V4, or the temporal lobe areas. We have only the fuzziest ideas how those patterns are read out, tagged as important to remember, and moved into memory. You've only just met--and yet it gets worse.

To find her, you’ve got to retrieve those patterns from memory (no one knows how, but oscillations might be involved?), and use them to search in a way that’s robust against variations in the friend’s pose, position, rotation, illumination, and even dress style or age, many of which you have never seen before and will never see again. We know, for example, that some cells in IT are fairly robust against some moderate kinds of image changes. Some but not all, of this is done by circuits that look like a convNet. Whether this is a coincidence or not is debatable and how this convNet is trained is a total mystery—-it’s definitely determined by experience, but the feedback signals needed for vanilla backprop are missing.

As you scan the crowd, you’re only getting high-resolution data from a very small part of the visual field. This is (somehow) stitched together into a unified percept. You apply various heuristics—maybe your friend favors bright colors—to speed the search along. How you learn these, and how they’re mixed in with the input from your eyes is unknown, but it’s certainly reflected in your behavioural output: you'll find her faster if you successfully predict what she looks like, and you'll be much slower if you guess wrong. Perhaps you hear a familiar voice or smell the perfume you bought her. This, too, can help you find her, but how information is integrated across senses is unknown too.

Eventually, you find her. You plan a path across the plaza towards a cafe. We have a pretty good understanding of how this works in rats (3-7 Hz oscillations coordinate place cells and grid cells in the hippocampus). Those oscillations are really strong in rodents, but much weaker in monkeys and totally missing in bats, so it's not clear how this works in humans.

Now all you’ve got to do is open your mouth and order coffee....

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by johnsimer on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:40PM (#19392127)
just curious - how do neuroscience people and people of non-CS fields find out about HN?
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:42PM (#19392823)
A lot of bio stuff now generates huge amounts of data and needs computational skills to collect and interpret. My undergrad degree was in CS and I still split my time between training animals and training models (plus writing and, today, RAID-babysitting).

We get about 1 Gb/min of neurophysiological data (x4-6 hours/day) and I'm hoping to scale that up quite a bit soon. People doing microscopy also generate giant datasets, as do the sequencing folks.

Me, specifically? A labmate showed me and said "It's cool...and a timesink."

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by jcims on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:53PM (#19396025)
Just wanted to thank you for wading in here sand sharing your perspective.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:14PM (#19396123)
You're welcome! Random interesting stuff is what makes the internet worth keeping around, after all :-)
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by HNLurker2 on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:24AM (#19396830)
Many neuroscientist turn to teaching mindfulness (e.g Sam Harris) because in their spiritual journey and academic neuroscientist journey they ask : Who am I?

What do you think about this? Who is the I? Where can I find it? Is it just mysticism?

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mrep on Thursday March 14, 2019 @07:01PM (#19394762)
Ever read the book "On Intelligence" by Jeff Hawkins and if so, what are you thoughts on it? I've read that and ray kurzweil's books and On Intelligence was my favorite and got me super interested in AI but I haven't done much with it so I'm curious what someone who has a PhD in neuroscience thinks of it.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by beefcafe on Thursday March 14, 2019 @07:44PM (#19395064)
Also “How to Build a Brain” by Chris Eliasmith. Interesting theories on how neurons represent functions and then build into a greater whole. I’m not a neuroscientist but my intuition says he might be getting closer to a solid mid-level (above the level of ion channels) understanding of brain function.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:16PM (#19396132)
I haven't, though it's been on my list for a while.

I'm collaborating with a woman who has also been working with him to model some of our data with NENGO, so I should really get around to that sooner rather than later.

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by loamseed on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:48PM (#19393542)
Are there publicly available repositories of this kind of data? Where?

What are the best modern methods to analyze them?

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:46PM (#19394127)
Yup. The neuroimaging folks are really good about sharing data. If you want to look at MRI/MEG/EEG data, https://openneuro.org might be a good place to start.

CRCNS (https://crcns.org/data-sets) has some neurophysiology data (i.e., from implanted or inserted electrodes). This sort of data is shared a little less often, in part because it's often acquired and stored in weird, homebrew formats, though that's slowly changing.

ModelDB (https://senselab.med.yale.edu/ModelDB/) has a large collection of computational models. These are mostly biophysical models, though there's some other stuff in there too.

Depending on what you're looking for, there are other more specialized repositories. NDCT (https://data-archive.nimh.nih.gov/ndct) has mental-health related clinical trial data, though you'll have to do some paperwork if you want subject-level data, which is fairly common for clinical data. MIT has a collection of eye movement data sets: http://saliency.mit.edu/datasets.html

As for the best methods, this comment box is far too small to contain all my thoughts on that :-) It depends on your question and experiment. Sometimes, all you really need is a t-test (or the randomized version), but that requires getting the experiment just right. Other times, you might need a morass of signal processing and dimensionality reduction, fed into some giant multi-level Bayesian model in a vain attempt controls for all the stuff you neglected when you designed the damn experiment. Happy to send you some pointers if you have something specific in mind though!

Physics has historically had a huge leg up on the other sciences because they had real models that made testable, quantitative predictions. We're finally starting to learn enough about the brain that we can do this for neural data too, and I'm really excited about that!

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by loamseed on Saturday March 16, 2019 @07:52PM (#19411204)
Thank you for this wealth of information!

I will definitely look through, and after digging around a bit I'd love to get some pointers. I have been curious about this for a long time, but uncertain where to look, so this is very exciting. Thank you again :)

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by codekilla on Thursday March 14, 2019 @04:39PM (#19393446)
what sorts of tools are you using to deal with this data?
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:21PM (#19393891)
It's a hodgepodge.

Mostly Matlab, Python, and R, with a few things that have tight time/memory requirements in C++. Matlab was really popular in neuroscience for a very long time, so we still have a lot of code in m-files, but most labs are moving towards Python (and a few towards R).

The code quality varies a lot. Some of our "core" stuff is great, but there's also a lot of stuff that was written quickly and meant to be run once ("let's just try it"), which is cold comfort when you find it years later.

People also come in with varying levels of programming skill. I'm going to try to do actual code reviews with the undergrads this summer to see if we can't make our stuff a little less embarrassing.

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by codekilla on Thursday March 14, 2019 @07:18PM (#19394884)
I can't reply to your last comment...but yes..anything dealing with time series it's easily the best in the world. In a past life long ago I worked in finance and heard about it then. Recently, I was thinking about simulations and how to maybe deal with and analyze the timeseries data and I thought about it. Apparently, NASA is experimenting with it at their Ames Frontier Development Lab, astrophysics data is huge. Anyway, I am just kicking the tires at this point and trying to find ways to implement and play around with it a bit. If you or anyone you know develops an interest, feel free to drop me a line. grantroy _@_ caltech dot edu
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by codekilla on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:18PM (#19394420)
I'm interested in using kdb+/q for applications dealing with large scale scientific data. Do you think there would be much interest in the neuroscience community?

I'll add, I work in a lab and have seen the stuff of nightmares myself.

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by mattkrause on Thursday March 14, 2019 @07:08PM (#19394815)
Possibly! I've not played with the time series databases much. Most of our queries would be something like "give me signals from channels A-C that are +/- 1 second from all events of type X." If it would help with something like that, it'd be great.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by thereisnospork on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:11PM (#19391239)
We understand lots about how the brain behaves, we understand next to nil about how it behaves that way.

we can't describe how vision, eg, is processed at a molecular or even cellular level, ergo we know nothing.

Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by arendtio on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:47PM (#19390984)
Well, maybe it just doesn't exist and my Roomba is as conscious as me.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by Brifer on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:25PM (#19391943)
This made me ponder.
Re:DeepMind and Google: the battle to control artificial int... by wuliwong on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:26PM (#19391384)
You responded to hyperbole with with a vague and imprecise statement. I will admit it is more accurate since "much" is somewhere between "everything" and "nothing".