News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by newscracker on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:12AM (#19389343)
> When talking about privacy these articles should at least mention Signal. I hope they will use their recent funding [2] to polish their apps and increase the speed of innovation.

I keep repeating this often, but Signal is not a user friendly platform for average users. It is good for ephemeral chats and conversations that one wouldn't care about later. Signal actively blocks chats from being backed up (and restored) on iOS. So if you switch to a new device, you'd have to start afresh without any chat histories and also join all the groups once again. The fact that this issue was opened a long time ago on GitHub and responded to by saying it's a security issue to allow backups shows what audience Signal is focusing on (investigative journalists, dissidents and activists who use burner devices and don't need any traces of chats to linger around).

Telegram, on the other hand (even with the not-end-to-end-encrypted default), makes for easy moves between devices (supporting chat syncing across OSes and devices) and to newer devices, with every chat showing information shared as links, photos, etc., and very easy to get back to. Of course, since the chats are not stored encrypted on its servers, search is also blazingly fast.

One deficiency with Telegram is that the end-to-end encrypted chats ("secret chats") are tied to phones and can't be initiated from other devices or seen from other devices. Those also don't carry over to a new device. There is no technical reason for this, because Wire (which in my opinion is a better alternative to Signal and easier to sell others on) handles end-to-end encryption with syncing across devices.

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by ardy42 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:18AM (#19389409)
> Signal actively blocks chats from being backed up (and restored) on iOS.

I don't think that's true. Signal's backups require you to copy a file from your old phone to your new phone's storage. It's possible on Android to mount your phone's filesystem on a PC. IIRC, Apple is the one that doesn't make that easy on iOS, not Signal.

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by dunham on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:44PM (#19391573)
Apple has backup and restore of device files and the keychain. You can explicitly mark files as "don't back up" and mark keychain items as "this device only" (those items will get backed up, but need a key from the security enclave of that specific device to restore).

It sounds like Signal is explicitly marking its data in this fashion on iOS. I don't know if Android has any options like this for securing data, I'd expect Signal to utilize those options if they were available.

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by newscracker on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:15PM (#19390632)
What I said (specifically about iOS) is true and has been so since 2015 (or earlier).

See [1] and [2] that I linked in another comment here and check on backups explicitly being denied on iOS. This has nothing to do with Apple, and everything to do with the Signal team not willing to make it user friendly (for this case).

[1]: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-iOS/wiki/FAQ

[2]: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-iOS/issues/905

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by tivert on Thursday March 14, 2019 @01:20PM (#19391331)
> See [1] and [2] that I linked in another comment here and check on backups explicitly being denied on iOS.

They apparently have an open issue for this (though it looks like it's locked to prevent people from endlessly complaining in their bug tracker).

https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-iOS/issues/2542

It also sounds like they have a branch where they're working on this feature:

https://whispersystems.discoursehosting.net/t/ios-backup-kee...

> This has nothing to do with Apple, and everything to do with the Signal team not willing to make it user friendly (for this case).

I'd be interested to know the precise reason they have for not implementing this. You seem to have a pretty negative opinion of Signal, but I doubt they've avoided implementing backups on iOS just because they're "not willing to make it user friendly" (which is really uncharitable take, btw). Perhaps there's some nuance to iOS that makes backups far more difficult to implement than on Android while providing the same security guarantees.

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by newscracker on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:01PM (#19392372)
The reason given is “security”, or to copy paste from the link I have given: “iTunes backups are disabled to prevent plaintext leakage to iCloud or insecure systems.”

I have a negative opinion of Signal because they have not dealt with this for years and have been stubborn on that point. Please read the comments on the link I have given and also look at issues they have closed on the same topic. Their responses on the issue tracker don’t look user friendly. So I go with what I’ve seen (which is available for you to examine and make your own inferences too).

For a very long time, I’ve wanted to recommend Signal to others (I still use it, but not for anything that I’d want to save for longer). But this particular issue, introduced and imposed by the Signal team, is a deal breaker. Which average user would want to rejoin all groups or lose all chat history because they bought a new iPhone? If this self-imposed issue is not an example of being user unfriendly, then what is?

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by tivert on Thursday March 14, 2019 @06:05PM (#19394305)
> I have a negative opinion of Signal because they have not dealt with this for years and have been stubborn on that point.

Why? It's their time and I doubt you're their boss.

> But this particular issue, introduced and imposed by the Signal team, is a deal breaker.

It seems like you just fundamentally disagree with their priorities, which is kind of a poor reason for having a negative opinion of them. It seems like they want to create the maximally secure yet reasonably usable chat app, and you want a maximally convenient yet reasonably secure chat app.

IMHO, Signal's priorities are far more unique and innovative, and that's why they have my support. Literally every other app out there decides to make the opposite trade offs.

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by newscracker on Friday March 15, 2019 @10:05AM (#19399776)
I’m not their boss, but who says I can’t criticize it if it doesn’t meet my and others’ needs? If you observe all the discussions here on HN, you’d see that most of the criticisms and disagreements that people have with someone or some company relates to priorities not matching. Signal is not getting some special mistreatment here. In my other comments I have mentioned (that I have been) focusing on selling Signal to the average user. That doesn’t work well because of such issues (I have also listed other issues with Signal in some other comments here).

If Signal wants to become more popular, then it should also look at what average users need right now (the deal breakers) when prioritizing requirements and features. As I said in another comment, Signal seems focused on investigative journalists, dissidents and activists. Nothing wrong with that at all, but it reflects poorly on people who comment on HN recommending that everybody should use Signal.

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by ardy42 on Saturday March 16, 2019 @06:40PM (#19410841)
> I’m not their boss, but who says I can’t criticize it if it doesn’t meet my and others’ needs?

Yeah, because doing that is kinda toxic. It's the kind of behavior that makes open-source project maintainers burn out and quit their former labor-of-love, because they're sick being dragged down by all of the negativity from the internet peanut gallery.

This is especially true since it appears they may actually be addressing your iOS backup concerns, just not with the urgency you demand.

> As I said in another comment, Signal seems focused on investigative journalists, dissidents and activists. Nothing wrong with that at all, but it reflects poorly on people who comment on HN recommending that everybody should use Signal.

No, it doesn't reflect poorly on them at all.

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by codedokode on Thursday March 14, 2019 @10:27AM (#19389514)
Signal requires a phone number that discloses your identity and location, they could have more privacy if they didn't require it.
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by kitsunesoba on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:25AM (#19390049)
I’ll have to check, but I’m pretty sure the Mac Cocoa version of Telegram (not the Mac Qt version) supports secret chat initiation.
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by Aloha on Thursday March 14, 2019 @02:34PM (#19392047)
Yes, it does.
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by tivert on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:03PM (#19390481)
> I keep repeating this often, but Signal is not a user friendly platform for average users.

That's not really true. Signal and WhatsApp are basically the same, and WhatsApp's massive popularity gives strong evidence for their user friendliness.

Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by AtHeartEngineer on Thursday March 14, 2019 @12:06PM (#19390524)
Whatsapps keys are stored on their servers, which Facebook owns. I don't consider WhatsApp anymore secure than Twitter DMs.
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by ubercow13 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @03:30PM (#19392680)
Are they? That seems like an extraordinary claim. Do you have a source?
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by rickycook on Thursday March 14, 2019 @05:18PM (#19393857)
it’s not quite that brazen, but from what i remember the whatsapp server can push a new public key for your contact/chat to the device, which means that they can MITM you. the chat shows that the key changed, but most users wouldn’t know what that means and ignore it
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by ubercow13 on Thursday March 14, 2019 @11:05PM (#19396084)
Isn't that how Signal works too? What else would it do, disallow you from continuing the chat if the key changes?
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by acct1771 on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:35PM (#19402081)
Until reverification? Sure.
Re:Telegram gets 3M new signups during Facebook apps’ outage by ubercow13 on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:11PM (#19403119)
In that case most users similarly won't know what reverification means and will just click through without verifying anything. It's not reasonable to say that that makes Whatsapp only as secure as Twitter DMs.